Modernized edition · Full text · Free PDF/EPUB
The Danger of Tolerating Levellers in Modern English
Want the file? The PDF/EPUB is free with an account.
Summary
- Author
- Edward Winslow, agent in London for the New England colonies, who had lived in New England from the beginning
- Published
- 1649 AD, a reissue of Hypocrisie Unmasked, first printed in 1646
- Source edition
- The 1649 reissue in modern English, with the 1646 dedication to the Earl of Warwick and the committee for the plantations
- Type
- Colonial defense and controversy, with a narrative of the founding of Plymouth
- Length
- 46,000 words · 3 hours
What is The Danger of Tolerating Levellers about?
The Danger of Tolerating Levellers is Edward Winslow's 1649 reissue of Hypocrisie Unmasked (1646), his defense of the New England colonies against the complaints Samuel Gorton laid before Parliament. It prints the Massachusetts court's relation, Gorton's letters, a minister's observations and testimonies against him, answers his book, and ends with the founding of Plymouth and John Robinson's farewell counsel.
Read the full summary (14 points, key themes)Show less
How the argument unfolds
- 01
To the Earl of Warwick. Winslow asks Parliament's committee for the plantations to confirm the Massachusetts sentence, keep Gorton out of New England, restore Plymouth's bounds, and spare the colonies appeals from three thousand miles away.
- 02
The Court’s True Relation. The Massachusetts General Court's account of Gorton's land deal with Miantonomo, his scorn of its summons, the siege of his fortified house, his examination at Boston, and his sentence of confinement in irons and banishment.
- 03
Gorton’s First Letter. Dated November 20, 1642, and signed by eleven men, it charges the magistrates with crucifying Christ, reads the two witnesses of Revelation as the life and death of Christ, and calls every oath perjury.
- 04
Gorton’s Second Letter. Addressed to the “Idol General”, it rejects the court's jurisdiction, threatens force for force, and in a postscript blames Massachusetts for Mrs. Hutchinson's death among the Dutch.
- 05
Winslow’s Note on the Letters. The letters were printed word for word with only the spelling corrected, and a blank was left where the original was worn away.
- 06
Observations: The Magistrates. A minister lists forty-eight reproaches in the letters against the magistrates of Massachusetts, from idols and blind guides to a generation of vipers.
- 07
Observations: Civil Power. The letters strike at all magistracy, since they would give the power of judging to every brother and none to an office, which is “an anarchy worse than the greatest tyranny”.
- 08
Observations: Holy Things. Their speeches against the churches, the calling of ministers, sermons, baptism, the Lord's Supper, repentance and the death of Christ under Pontius Pilate.
- 09
The Publisher to the Reader. Gorton's conduct at his trial in Rhode Island, where he defended his maidservant, mocked the oath, insulted the bench and was whipped and banished.
- 10
Testimonies Against Gorton. The Portsmouth grand jury's presentment, a letter of Roger Williams, the Providence inhabitants' plea to Massachusetts, and William Arnold's reasons against receiving Gorton's company.
- 11
Winslow’s Answer to Gorton. A page-by-page reply to Simplicity's Defence, with the history of the Pequot war, the capture and death of Miantonomo, the Narragansett plot, and Nathaniel Ward's testimony.
- 12
Why New England Was Planted. The Leyden church parted in love, not division: the reasons for leaving Holland, the approach to King James, the parting at Delfshaven and the landing at Cape Cod in 1620.
- 13
Robinson’s Farewell. John Robinson held communion with the Reformed churches, and at parting charged his flock to receive further light from the Word and to seek union with the godly in England.
- 14
Those Who Differ in Religion. Presbyterians and Anabaptists who walk peaceably are left alone in New England, but men like Gorton, who despise dominion, are not to be tolerated.
Key themes
- Civil peace, not religion. Winslow holds that Gorton was punished at Plymouth and Rhode Island “for breach of the civil peace and notorious contempt of authority”, and that his blasphemies came in by his own doing.
- Magistracy defended. The minister's observations argue that Gorton's teaching overthrows every government, for it says in effect, “Down with all officers from their rule, and set up every brother to rule!”
- A church that parted in love. Against the charge that Plymouth began in schism, Winslow writes of the Leyden church, “We did not part rashly, in a troubled and divided mood, but upon joint and serious deliberation”.
- Toleration with a limit. Those who differ in conscience and walk peaceably are borne with, and of them Winslow says “we do not exercise the civil sword against them”, but those who despise dominion are another case.
Reader questions (10)Hide the questions
Questions about The Danger of Tolerating Levellers
Is there a modern English version of The Danger of Tolerating Levellers?
Yes. This is The Danger of Tolerating Levellers by Edward Winslow in modern English. The language is modernized and the author's order and argument are kept. The full modernized text is free to read on this page.
Can I read The Danger of Tolerating Levellers online for free?
Yes. The complete text of this modern English edition is on this page, with no sign-up or paywall.
Is there a free PDF of The Danger of Tolerating Levellers?
Yes. The PDF and EPUB of this edition are free with an Updated Works account. Sign in with Google or an email link; no card is needed.
What is The Danger of Tolerating Levellers by Edward Winslow about?
It is New England's answer to Samuel Gorton, who had been banished from Massachusetts and complained of the colonies to Parliament. Winslow prints the Massachusetts court's account, Gorton's two letters, a minister's observations and testimonies from Rhode Island and Providence, answers Gorton's book page by page, and ends with the founding of Plymouth and John Robinson's farewell counsel.
Is this the same book as Hypocrisie Unmasked?
Yes. Winslow first printed the work in 1646 as Hypocrisie Unmasked. This is the 1649 reissue under the title The Danger of Tolerating Levellers, and it keeps the 1646 dedication to the Earl of Warwick and the committee for the plantations.
Who was Samuel Gorton in this book?
He is the leader of a small company that unsettled Plymouth, Rhode Island and Providence in turn and then bought land at Shawomet from Miantonomo. Massachusetts tried him for his letters and speeches and found him and his company “blasphemous enemies of the true religion of our Lord Jesus Christ”.
What did John Robinson say to the Pilgrims when they left Leyden?
Winslow reports that Robinson charged them “to follow him no further than he followed Christ”, to be ready to receive further truth from the Word, to weigh it against other Scriptures, to shake off the name of Brownist, and to seek union with the godly party in England rather than division.
Did the Plymouth settlers leave Leyden because of a church quarrel?
Winslow says no. The church decided by fasting and prayer that the youngest and strongest part should go first and the rest follow, and he writes that “no people on earth ever lived more lovingly together, or parted more sweetly” than they did.
Why did Massachusetts proceed against Gorton?
Two Indian sachems, Pumham and Socononoco, and some English of Providence put themselves under Massachusetts and complained of Gorton's company. The company refused every summons and safe conduct, sent railing letters, and fortified themselves, and the Commissioners of the United Colonies left them to Massachusetts to deal with according to justice.
How long is The Danger of Tolerating Levellers?
It runs to about 46,000 words. It is set out in fourteen sections, from the dedication through the court's relation, the letters, observations and testimonies, Winslow's answer, and three closing sections on New England's founding and practice.
The Danger of Tolerating Levellers in Modern English · Full text
To the Earl of Warwick
To the Right Honorable Robert, Earl of Warwick, Governor in Chief and Lord High Admiral of all those islands and other plantations of the English in America; together with the rest of those truly honorable members of both Houses of Parliament joined in commission with him for ordering the affairs of those plantations.
Right Honorable,
If your wisdom and experience in the great and weighty affairs of State were not so well known, and if you were not so used to the unjust complaints of clamorous persons, I might be discouraged from appearing in the righteous cause of the United Colonies of New England. I might be especially discouraged from appearing on behalf of the Governor and Company of the Massachusetts, to give an account of their just and righteous proceedings against Samuel Gorton and his companions, who, where they are unknown, go about here in the guise of a peaceable people. Yet if your Honors and the rest of the honorable Committee will be pleased, when weightier business gives way, to read through our just defense against his clamorous complaints and his scandalous treatise called Simplicity’s Defence against Seven-Headed Policy, I do not doubt that you will be fully satisfied with what we have done, and ready to justify our proceedings against them as godly and righteous.
The reason I am forced to appear in print before I give a particular answer to your Honors and the rest of the honorable Committee is this: I find a grosser, defaming slander cast upon the country in the public view of our nation. That nation is dear in our eyes. Witness our frequent public, solemn days of prayer to the Throne of grace for it, together with our private supplications, which the Searcher of the heart knows best; and witness how we have shared its sufferings in every condition, to the loss of ships, goods and the like, and to the great weakening of our estates. And so we desire to remove whatever may turn the thoughts of our nation against us, especially the thoughts of your Honors and of all who are godly in Christ Jesus.
What greater wrong can be done to a poor persecuted people, who went into the wilderness to escape the tyrannical government of the late hierarchy and to enjoy the liberties Christ Jesus has left to his churches (liberties which these blasphemous adversaries of ours so much slight and cast off), than to be counted “persecutors of Christ in his saints, yea, to go thither to that end, to become outrageously cruel, barbarously inhumane, uniting together to suck the blood of our countrymen…”? And yet, Right Honorable, it will and does appear in the following treatise that Samuel Gorton was proceeded against, first, at Plymouth, as a gross disturber of the civil peace and quiet of that government, in an open, factious and seditious manner. Second, he was no less troublesome, but much more so, at Rhode Island. There he had gathered a strong party to stand with him, and he affronted that government (as he had Plymouth) in their public administration of justice so foully and grossly that my ears never heard the like of it from anyone. For that account I refer your Honors to the following discourse, where it is set down as briefly as possible.
Gorton was whipped there in his person and banished from there with some of his principal adherents. They went next to Providence, where Mr. Williams and some others have built a small town. That people received them with all kindness in a cold season, when the places they had left could no longer bear his insolence. Yet he soon undermined their government and drew a strong party among them over to his own side, to the great distress of Mr. Williams and the better part of the people there. He contended against their laws and the execution of justice to the point of bloodshed. This made Mr. Williams and the rest complain sadly to the government of Massachusetts, and made several of them put themselves under the protection of that government to defend their persons and estates.
But Gorton and his company saw Mr. Williams resolve to lose the benefit of his labors rather than live with such ill-disposed people, and they saw the neighboring governments become troubled by Gorton’s misrule there as well. Then he and his companions in evil began to think of buying a place from a great, aspiring sachem, or Indian prince, to the wrong of its rightful owners, two lesser sachems. These sachems, as well as several English of Providence, submitted their persons and lands to the government of Massachusetts. They asked for its protection not only against the oppressive tyranny of Miantonomo, the great sachem already mentioned, but also against Gorton and his companions, who had intruded upon their rightful property by unwarrantable means, and so on.
The government of Massachusetts used every proper means, and none prevailed; their gentleness was answered with the greatest contempt imaginable. So at the next meeting of the Commissioners for the United Colonies they complained of Gorton and his lawless companions. The Commissioners took the matter into serious consideration, all the more because of the extraordinary familiarity of Gorton and his company with Miantonomo and the rest of the Narragansett sachems, who were known at that very time to be in a deep conspiracy against all the English in the land. And therefore, by a solemn act, the Commissioners gave the government of Massachusetts liberty to call them to account and to proceed with them as far as righteousness and justice would allow. This the government accordingly did.
These, Right Honorable, are the true causes of all the sentences and punishments that fell on Gorton in that country. The only addition is this: in their contemptuous answers to the modest and well-ordered writings of the government of Massachusetts, he and his company needlessly belched out horrid blasphemies, not only against that government in particular and against civil government in general, but against the received Christian religion of all the Reformed churches in Europe as well as our own. These were so horrid that many people of tender conscience, both ministers and others, thought the government did not do well in giving him such liberty. By it he may, and (as is reported) does, poison other persons and places with his corrupt opinions, to the great dishonor of God and the ruin of the souls of his followers, who reject the means of grace that God has sanctified to strengthen his people and build them up in faith and holiness.
But so that I may not be tedious, I will presume to present the following requests to your Honors and the rest of the honored Committee whom this renowned Parliament has entrusted with the affairs of the foreign plantations of our nation.
The first is that you strengthen the sentence of Massachusetts by your favorable approval, so far as it shall appear to be just and righteous. Then the country will be the better preserved from its fears of the Gortonians’ desperate union with such dangerous enemies as their malignant neighbors the Narragansetts. I am persuaded that if your leisure allows you to read the following discourse, you will readily agree to this. For, I thank God, nothing is affirmed by me in it but what I may safely swear to, just as it is affirmed there.
A second thing is that you will never allow Samuel Gorton, this pestilent disturber of our societies, to go to New England any more to disquiet its peace.
My third request is that you will be pleased to allow New Plymouth to enjoy its former liberty within the bounds of its government. Those bounds take in the very seat of that company, Shawomet itself, where Gorton and his company lived.
My fourth request is that you take into your serious consideration how destructive it will prove to the well-being of our plantations (which by God’s blessing are growing up into a nation) and of our proceedings there to have to answer here to the complaints of such malignant spirits as shall be sentenced by authority there. The distance is three thousand miles, so far that the journey will ruin anyone who must come for justice. It will utterly disable them from proving the equity of their cause, unless their estate is very great.
My fifth and last request is that your Honors and the rest of the honored Committee will be pleased to take under your protection the weak labors of your humble servant in the just defense he has made for New England and its several governments (especially Massachusetts) against the gross slanders of the scandalous treatise already mentioned, published by Gorton. In this you will not only bind our plantations of New England to continue their daily petition to the God of all mercies for a blessing upon this renowned Parliament, and upon your Honors and the rest of this honored Committee in particular. You will also bind them to engage themselves with and for Parliament and you against all opposers of the State, to the last drop of blood in our veins. Indeed, by this you will sweeten my wearisome travels, great expenses and labors as their unworthy agent. I do and will daily pray to God to repay your vast risks, expenses, studies and cares (spent to advance the public good of this distressed kingdom and its several limbs) with all the blessings of heaven and earth, to you and yours, to succeeding generations.
Your Honors’ humble, devoted servant,
Edward Winslow
The Court’s True Relation
A true relation of the proceedings of the Governor and Company of the Massachusetts in New England against Samuel Gorton and his accomplices, with the grounds and reasons for them, examined and allowed by their General Court held at Boston in November 1646.
Samuel Gorton once lived at Plymouth, where his behavior was so turbulent and offensive, both to the magistrates and to others, that they were compelled to drive him out of their jurisdiction. From there he went to Rhode Island, where he began to stir up sedition and to make a party against the authority there, for which he was arrested and whipped, and so sent away.
From there, with some others whom he had gathered to his side, he moved to Providence, where Mr. Roger Williams then lived. Mr. Williams, with some others, opposed his settling there as an inhabitant; only in consideration of his present distress did they allow him to stay for a time. But once he had a house there, he soon drew so great a party to himself that it was beyond the power of Mr. Williams and his party to drive them out or to rule them there. Both parties came armed into the field against each other, and they would have fought it out had not Mr. Williams used means to make peace.
Upon this, many of the leading men of Providence sent messengers with a letter to the Governor and Council of the Massachusetts, asking for aid against Gorton and his company. But they were answered that since they were neither within our jurisdiction nor in confederation with us, we had no ground to intervene in their quarrels. Soon afterward some of those men offered themselves and their lands to come under our government, and they were received.
There live near Providence two minor Indian sachems called Pumham and Socononoco. Though they are as free as the great sachem of the Narragansett, yet Miantonomo, who was then sachem of the Narragansett (being a very proud and stern man), kept them in great awe. This poor sachem Pumham had a large parcel of land near Providence, very convenient for a plantation. Gorton and his company, who now numbered about thirteen or fourteen, took notice of it. Fearing that they would not be able to keep their power long where they were, they bargained with Miantonomo for this parcel of land, promising him a good quantity of wampum for it. And because they knew that Pumham was the true owner of it, they dealt with him also. But he refused to sell it, for he lived on it or very near it. So they had Miantonomo send for him, and having drawn up a writing that purported to be a sale of the land for a certain payment to be given to both of them, Miantonomo signed it, and Pumham, for fear of Miantonomo, set his mark to it also, not knowing what it was. But when Gorton offered him the payment for it, he flatly refused it, since it is the Indians’ custom not to count anything sold until the party has received the thing it is sold for.
Yet upon this pretended title Gorton and his company entered upon the land and built some houses, and besides this they did the Indians much wrong with their cattle. Having Miantonomo as their friend, they behaved very insolently toward the poor Indians. The Indians, having no friends or means to relieve themselves, came and offered themselves and their lands to the government of the Massachusetts. By order of the Court, the Massachusetts gave notice of this to Miantonomo and directed him to come, or send someone, to the next Court at Boston, to show his title or claim (if he had any) to the said Pumham and Socononoco or to their lands. At the appointed time he came and claimed that they were his vassals. But it appeared clearly, both by a writing from Mr. Williams and by the testimony of some other English in those parts and of various other Indians in no way related to them, that they were free sachems. So, since Miantonomo had nothing to reply, the Court received the two Indian sachems, with their subjects and lands, under the government and protection of the Massachusetts.
Upon that the Court wrote to our neighbors of Providence, informing them of this, and advising Gorton and his company that if they had any just title to the lands they possessed, they should come, or send some on their behalf, to show it to the Court; and the Court offered them safe conduct. They received this letter from the Court with great disdain and returned scornful and menacing answers by word of mouth. A good while afterward they wrote a letter to the Court full of reproach and blasphemies, not only against the magistrates but against the churches and ordinances, as will appear by the copy of it that follows hereafter.
Notwithstanding these provocations, and the daily wrongs done to those few English who were their neighbors (who had previously submitted themselves to our government), we sat still for nearly half a year. Before we attempted anything against them, we took counsel with the Commissioners of the United Colonies. Upon testimony of their insolent and injurious courses, and after reading the letter they had sent us, the Commissioners left them to us to proceed against according to justice. Thereupon the Court sent to them again by two of its members, who carried letters (to require and persuade them to come and give satisfaction) and a safe conduct as well. But they treated those messengers as they had treated the former ones, threatening to whip one man whom the messengers had taken along with them. And they sent us word that if we had anything to say to them, we should come to them, and we should have justice there; and that if we came with force, they would meet us halfway.
When our messengers returned with these scornful answers, the Court resolved to send some force to fetch them in. In the meantime a second letter came from them (a copy of which is also set down hereafter). But before we sent out our soldiers, we wrote to them to this effect: that although the injuries and provocations we had endured from them were very grievous, yet, so that our justice and moderation might appear to all men, we had stooped so far to their own proposal as to send some commissioners to them, to hear their answers and allegations. If after that they would give us such satisfaction as was just, we would leave them in peace; if not, we would right ourselves by force of arms. We let them know as well that we would send a sufficient guard with our commissioners; for seeing they would not trust themselves with us upon our safe conduct, we had no reason to trust any of ours with them upon their bare courtesy.
Accordingly, about a week later we sent three commissioners, and forty musketeers with them. Their instructions were first to speak and negotiate with them and to require satisfaction according to justice, and if it were refused, then to take them by force and bring them prisoners to Boston, and also to take as much of their goods as would cover our charges. On the way our commissioners were met by another letter from Gorton’s company, telling the commissioners that the company did not fear them but was prepared for them. And accordingly they had fortified themselves in one house (some twelve of them), had lined the walls with earth to make them proof against musket shot, had built flanking works, and had laid in provisions and so on to endure a siege. So when our commissioners came to the place, Gorton’s company would admit no parley. But after a while, through the mediation of some of their neighbors, they were content to parley, and offered to refer the cause to arbitrators, provided that some of them might be from Providence or from Rhode Island.
Our commissioners were content to send to us to learn our minds about it, and in the meantime they sat still. Those members of the Court who could meet sent back the answer that their proposal was neither timely nor reasonable, nor could it be safe or honorable for us to accept it:
1. Because they would never offer or listen to any terms of agreement before our soldiers had them in their power.
2. Because the ground of their proposal was false. For we were not parties (as they claimed), but impartial judges between them and the Indians and others who were the complainants. (And yet in a case of war, parties may be judges.)
3. They were no state or body politic, but a few fugitives living without law or government, and so it was not honorable for us to join with them in such a way of arbitration.
4. The parties to whom they would refer it were such as had been rejected by us and by all the governments in the country, and so were not likely to be impartial toward us, nor able to judge the cause. Moreover, their blasphemous and reproachful writings and the like were not matters fit to be settled by arbitration, since they were deeply criminal. They must either be purged away by repentance and public satisfaction, or else by public punishment.
For these and other reasons, the commissioners were required to proceed according to their instructions. Thereupon the commissioners entrenched themselves around the house, and in a few days forced Gorton’s company to yield, and so brought them to Boston. There Gorton and his men were kept in prison until the Court sat, and they had their meals from the cooks (as good food and drink as the town afforded).
The next Lord’s day they refused to go to the church assembly unless they might have liberty to speak there as occasion should arise. Some of the magistrates answered them that it belonged to the elders to order the affairs of the church, but that they might take it for granted they would not be denied such liberty, provided they spoke words of truth and soberness. So in the afternoon they came and were placed in a suitable seat before the elders. Mr. Cotton, the teacher, was then preaching (in his ordinary course) from Acts 19, on Demetrius’s speech for Diana’s silver shrine. After the sermon Gorton asked leave to speak. When it was granted, he took occasion from the sermon to speak to this effect: that in the church now there was nothing but Christ, so that all our ordinances, ministers, sacraments and the rest were only men’s inventions, for show and pomp, and no different from those silver shrines of Diana. He said also that if Christ lives eternally, then he died eternally, along with other speeches of the same kind.
And indeed it appears, both by his speeches and by his letters, that it was his opinion that Christ was incarnate in Adam and was that image of God in which Adam was created. He held that the chief work and merit lay in Christ’s self-emptying, when he became such a thing, so lowly, and so on; and that his being born afterward of the Virgin Mary, and his suffering and the rest, were only a manifestation of his suffering and the rest in Adam. Another of them said that the Sabbath was Christ, and so was born of the Virgin Mary. They called magistracy among Christians an idol. Yet they did acknowledge a magistracy in the world that is to be submitted to as an ordinance of God, but only as a natural one, as a father’s over his wife and children, and a hereditary prince’s over his subjects.
Their first appearance before the Court was on the lecture day at Boston, before a very large assembly. There, first of all, the Governor declared the cause and manner of all the proceedings against them, and their letters were read publicly. They had liberty to object, and answers were given, as follows.
First, to their plea that they were not within our jurisdiction, it was answered:
(1) If they were not within ours, yet they were within the jurisdiction of one of our confederates, who had referred them to us.
(2) If they were within no jurisdiction, then there was no one to complain to for redress of our injuries by way of ordinary justice, and then we had no way of relief except by force of arms.
Second, to their plea of persecution for their conscience and so on, it was answered that we did not meddle with them for their opinions, except as they had given us occasion by their own letters and their free speeches among us. For we wrote to them about civil disputes only, and gave them no occasion to vent their blasphemies and revilings against the ordinances of religion established among us.
Third, as for their title to the Indians’ lands: we had several times asked them to make it appear, but they always refused, even to our commissioners, whom we sent to them last at their own proposal. And since they had been in prison, we offered to send for any witnesses they would name to us for that purpose, but this also they refused. So our title (by the Indians’ surrender) appears good, and having regained possession, we need not question them any further about that.
When their letters had been read and they had acknowledged their signatures, they were asked one by one whether they would maintain the things contained in them. Their answer was that they would, in the sense in which they wrote them; and so they were returned to prison. The next day they were brought before the Court one by one, to be examined on particulars (many of the elders having been asked to be present), because they had said they could give a good interpretation of every part of their letters. But since the interpretation they gave was contrary to the words, they were asked whether they would then retract those words, which differed so plainly from their pretended meanings. This they refused to do, saying that then they would be denying the truth.
To give one or two instances: one of their letters was addressed “To their Neighbors of the Massachusetts,” and the other “To the great honored Idol General of the Massachusetts,” and both were delivered to our Governor by a messenger of their own; and many passages in both letters were pointedly applied to our courts, our magistrates, our elders and so on. And yet when they were examined about what they meant by their reproachful passages, they answered that they meant them of the corrupt state of mankind in general, and not of us. Likewise, in their letter they had charged us with the error of teaching “That Christ died actually only” when he suffered under Pontius Pilate, and before that only in types, and so on. Yet on examination they said that their meaning was that his death was actual to the faith of the fathers under the law (which is in effect the same thing we hold). Still they would not retract the words they had written.
The elders conferred with them for many hours before the Court, and in the course of this they revealed various blasphemous opinions which they maintained. We will give one instance, which was mentioned before, delivered by Gorton: namely, that the image of God in which Adam was created was Christ, and Adam’s losing that image was the death of Christ, and the restoring of that image in regeneration was the resurrection of Christ; and so the death of him who was born of the Virgin Mary was only a manifestation of the former.
Mr. William Tompson, one of the elders, had earlier spent some time with them in the prison about the opinions they held forth, and they had professed their agreement with him (in substance) on every point. So he came to the Court intending to speak on their behalf. But when he heard them reveal themselves in this way at their public examinations, he declared how he had been deceived by them. For they surpass the Jesuits in the art of equivocation. They do not care how falsely they speak as every other man understands them, so long as they keep to the rules of their own secret intentions. Being asked why they spoke against the ordinances of the ministry, the sacraments and so on, seeing that Scripture allows them, they answered that these were ordained only for the time of being under age; but after the Revelation was written they were to cease, because we find no mention of them in that book.
They were unlearned men. The ablest of them could not write correct English, no, not even in common words. Yet they would take it upon themselves to interpret the most difficult places of Scripture, and twist them any way to serve their own turn. For instance, when Mr. Cotton pressed Gorton with the words “Who can forbid water, why these should not be baptized…” (Acts 10:47), he interpreted it this way: who can deny that these have been baptized, seeing they have received the Holy Ghost? And so he granted that they had been baptized. He was driven to this shift in order to maintain his opinion that those who have been baptized with the Holy Ghost do not need the baptism of water.
Several days were spent, both by the Court and by the elders, in laboring to bring them to repentance, but all in vain. They continued obstinate. So the Court agreed to sentence them. But first it brought them out in public before a great assembly, and there, from their letters and speeches, laid this charge upon them: that they were found to be blasphemous enemies of the true religion of our Lord Jesus Christ and of all his holy ordinances, and likewise of all civil government among his people, and particularly within this jurisdiction. Then they were asked whether they acknowledged this charge to be just and would submit to it, or what objection they had against it. They answered that they did not acknowledge it to be just, but they fell into some quibbling speeches; and so they were returned to prison again. While in prison they behaved insolently toward their keeper and spoke evil of the magistrates, so that the keeper was forced to threaten them with irons to keep them quiet.
When all means had been used to reclaim them and had not prevailed, they were brought before the Court to receive their sentence, which was this. Gorton and six more of them were to be sent to separate towns, there to be kept at work for their living and to wear an iron chain on one leg. They were not to go beyond the limits of the town, nor by word or writing to maintain any of their blasphemous or wicked errors, upon pain of death, except in conference with any of the elders or with anyone else allowed by some magistrate to confer with them. And this was to continue during the pleasure of the Court.
Three of the company were set at liberty, because they had not set their hands to the letters. Two of them were freed on a small ransom, as prisoners taken in war; the third freely, because he was among them only in his master’s house, where they were taken. A fourth, who was found to be a plain, ignorant young man, was discharged as well, only bound to remain for a time in one of our towns; but he went away and never returned, contrary to his promise. There were two others who were brought in afterward (but not by force). One of them disclaimed having any hand in the letters and was discharged at once; the other was kept in prison a while, and afterward, upon his submission and so on, was released.
Gorton and the other six remained in their separate towns all that winter. Then, out of regard for their wives and children (who were likely to be in great distress through their husbands’ absence), they were set at liberty and banished, upon pain of death if they were found in any part of our jurisdiction.
After the Court had passed sentence of confinement upon them, we sent to fetch as many of their cattle as might defray the charges they had put us to, which amounted to about one hundred and sixty pounds. But the cattle did not come to so much, for we left each of them a part for the support of their families, and some of them had no cattle at all.
The letters follow.
Gorton’s First Letter
Mooshawset, November 20, 1642. To our Neighbors of the Massachusetts.
We lately received an irregular note, professing to come from the Massachusetts, with four men’s names signed to it as its principal authors, men who are among the chief of you, and we could not easily believe it to be genuine. This was not only because those who conveyed it to us are known to be men whose constant and professed acts are worse than the counterfeiting of men’s signatures, but also because we thought that men of your abilities and profession would never have prostrated their wisdom to such an act. But considering that causeless enmity you have against us, the proof of which every occasion brings forth, we cannot but conclude that there is no act so ill that that ancient mother will not bring forth her seed to it.
For we know very well that it is the name of Christ called upon us which you strive against. That is why you stand on tiptoe, stretching yourselves beyond your bounds to seek occasion against us, so that you might hide your sin, as Adam did, by persuading the world that it is not your desire to contend with us, but only to redress some civil breach in our conduct. Yet neither you nor anyone else (in the way of truth) can find anything with which to bring us under the censure of a disorderly course of walking among men. And as for the way of that ancient spirit of accusation of the brethren, we do not weigh it, knowing him to be a liar (or, in the abstract, a lie) from the beginning, yes, and the father of it too; which thing you cannot know, though it were told you.
Whereas you say that Robert Cole, William Arnold and others have put themselves under the government and protection of your jurisdiction, which is the occasion you have now found to contend: we wish your words were true, so that these men were to be found nowhere else, since they are nothing but the shame of religion, and the disquiet and disturbance of the place where they are. For we know that neither the one nor the other, with all their associates and confederates, has power to enlarge the bounds that King Charles limited to you.
Behold, therefore, in this act of yours a map of your spiritual state (to use your own phrase). For we know that the spirituality of your churches is the civility of your commonwealth, and the civility of your commonwealth is the spirituality of your churches, the wisdom of man being the whole accomplishment of them both. Of that tree you delight to eat daily (finding it fair and beautiful), to gain conformity with your maker.
In these dissembling subjects of yours, grossly profane among us but full of the spirit of your purity when they are with you, you may remember the brand you yourselves have set upon some of them. The cause of it was never yet removed, though the brand does not stay upon their backs. Nor was the cause of your committing them to Satan according to your law ever removed; for if it had been, you would do them wrong in not taking your vomit back into its former digestion again. Nor are we ignorant of the disgraceful terms they use and give out against you behind your backs. Their submission, therefore, can serve no other end than to satisfy their own lusts, which are not only conceived but in violent motion against their neighbors, who never offered them the least wrong. The mere proposal of amity is object enough for these men’s enmity.
Even so the passions of sin, which are by the Law, have force in your members. You go about with great labor and industry to satisfy them by your submission to the word of God: in your fasting and feasting, in contributing and treasuring, in retirement for study, and in bowing the backs of the poor, going forth in labor to maintain it; and in the spirit of that hireling you raise up your whole structure and edifice. In all of this you bring forth nothing but fruit unto death. Some labor for a price to give for the keeping of their souls in peace and in a safe state and condition, and some to have their bodies furnished with riches, honor and ease. As far as the Lord Jesus agrees with these things you mind him, and no further; no, you renounce and reject him. And with these things (according to your acceptance and practice of them) he has no fellowship at all, for they are the counsel and working of his only adversary, man being the one you depend upon, and not the Lord.
You cry out by way of elevation and applaud his ministers, while all the time you do not know what or who they are. You profess that they stand under a mediate call of Christ, though formerly they were called immediately by him. In this you show yourselves to be those who destroy the sacred ordinance of God. For if, in instituting his ministers, you make Christ to be something today which he was not yesterday, and that also in the time of the Gospel (to speak according to your Law, to be found in them both), you thereby affirm that he has been something to his ministers which he is not now. And to make the Son of God to have been what he is not now is to make a nullity of him, as though he were not at all; for he is the Lord that changes not, and not so much as a shadow of change is found in him. So you plainly crucify to yourselves the Lord of glory, and put him to an open shame.
So, as you do not know how Christ, keeping company with his Father in heaven, is found on the earth among the true worshippers, no more do you know how, keeping company with Nicodemus on the earth, he declares himself to be in heaven with his Father. On this foundation hangs the whole building of your doctrine concerning the sufferings of Christ. You annihilate the Cross, besides which the saints have no consolation, and you prepare no better a place than Purgatory for the honorable fathers of our Lord.
For you conclude that Christ died in the decree and purpose of God in the time of the Law, but actually only when he hung on the cross in the days of Herod and Pontius Pilate; that he was crucified in the types and shadows of the law, but in truth and substance when he appeared, born of the Virgin Mary. So you must also conclude that the fathers under the law were saved only in purpose and decree, in type and shadow, but actually and substantially only at the coming of Christ in the flesh. Deal plainly, therefore, with those who depend upon you for instruction (as your ancestors in the papacy have done), and proclaim a place of purgatory provided for them in the meantime, without which your doctrine has no foundation. For if you raise up a shadow without a substance, and the substance of him that dwells in light without a shadow, you play the part of wizards or necromancers, not the part of true natural philosophers, in the things of the Kingdom of God.
So as far as these men are from being honorable and loyal subjects, so far are you from being volunteers in the day of God’s power, and from yielding subjection to the beauties of holiness. Such also is your professed rule and government in the things that concern the Kingdom of our God. They are infinitely beyond, and out of the reach of, that spirit which has gone out among you, whose capacity can in no way comprehend the breadth of the land of Emmanuel, nor enter it within the veil. Therefore it cannot know those cherubim of glory, nor can it hear the voice of that living oracle which speaks only from off the covering mercy seat and is to be heard nowhere else. We speak nothing but what we know: these things are out of its jurisdiction. Therefore it is mute in declaring justice, nor does it speak any of that righteousness and glory which is comprised in another circuit than any you were ever yet made lords of. Long, therefore, may you boast of your jurisdiction before ever you attain to a jurisprudence in these things.
You tell us that we do you wrong by a pretended purchase. In this you are as much mistaken about the purchase as about the wrong. For what we are about to do is right, and our purchase is no pretense but a precedent, not only in this civil respect; it may also admonish all men to take heed how they depend upon false and self-seeking interpreters, when both they themselves and those that have the vision are ignorant of the contract and covenant of God.
That is why you teach that the spouse of Christ, upon her contract with her Lord, may conceive the seed of immortality and bring forth fruit unto God while the day of marriage, that great festivity and solemnization of the consolations of God, has not yet come. Witness your postponement of it, if not to the descent of Christ from heaven to the earth to reign for certain years, then at least to the calling of the Jews (whom you yourselves are, according to the flesh), and to the destruction of that man of sin whom you so stoutly maintain. What is this but to proclaim to all the world that audacious spirit of whoredoms, professing conception and bringing forth before the wedding day?
You conclude that your clients’ right arises out of four years’ possession. We have no such rule. If you mean the right of conquest (theirs being held only by that tenure), the true owners were never yet subdued; for that is the right they expect to enjoy by your means. Some of them committed part of their supposed right to us, professing that they did it so that they might have help to enjoy the rest. But when they saw that we would not be their abettors outside the covenant, much less against it, they fled to you for help. Their possession is a mere intrusion, as all the natives know, who have always cried out against them for it. And so may our countrymen also, whose eyes are not dazzled with envy, nor their ears open to lies, as we know yours are; otherwise you would have heard both sides speak before you judged.
But we profess a right held by no such interest, but upon the ground of covenant only, known in its nature: in the parties between whom it is plighted, in the possessor and the possessed, with the nature of all the fruit arising from their accord and concurrence, together with the distinct, harmonious, reciprocal and joint properties and operations of them both. Such is the tenure we hold and maintain before men and angels, and set against man and devil.
We do not hold it by taking up to ourselves certain offices and officers which we can teach children to be and to perform, and then at once concluding from this that we possess the Kingdom, crying out, Our peace offerings are upon us, this day we have paid our vows. But when that dark cloud which descended upon the Tabernacle becomes the light and glory of all Israel (nothing being acknowledged among them but what arises out of it), then, and only then, are the orders, as well as the men of Israel, derived from the true fountain, which no tongue can confess but it is salvation; and then, and not otherwise, is the heritage of our Lord in possession. Yes, even the wayless wilderness knows how to afford them a habitation, one which had its being before the hills and mountains were born, to which men begin to flee for refuge, to hide themselves from the presence of the Lamb. This is a possession into which no man can intrude himself. It is covenanted only with him, through an enlightened eye and a pierced ear, which man does not perform, nor can it be received from him.
For we know that the cloud of thick darkness which hides and covers the whole frame and fabric of the work of God is the clearing and evidencing of every point and particular of it. Yes, to us it is even that cloud of witness which testifies to us that the like works will appear whenever the world has occasion to make use of us.
It never shines but in the night, and it is never dark to Israel but in the day; but in the one and the other it is the only glory and safety of all the tribes. But how this is, you do not know; nor can you, with all your libraries, give the interpretation of it. You have lost it in the wilderness, and accordingly you have made the whole way and will of our Lord into the oldness of the letter, both to yourselves and to all who have an ear to listen to you. That is why the day of the Lord is a day of darkness and gloominess to you, but of joy and gladness to us. Yes, it lifts up our head only, and then our salvation is near.
For we know the worthies of David, doubled about the bed of Solomon, who expel all fear in the night, handling the sword with success and making the adversaries nothing but food to feed upon. So the time of your fears is the time of our courage and conquest. For when you fear error, schism, rents and confusions in church and state, then we know that the Messenger of the Covenant, the Lord whom we seek, is speeding his passage into his holy temple. For who (under the terrors of your spirit) may abide his coming, since he is like a refiner’s fire and fuller’s soap?
You invite us to your courts to fetch your equally balanced justice, on this ground: that you have become one with our adversaries, both in what they have and in what they are. And we know them to be such as profess the day of the Lord an unhallowed thing. Now if we have our opponent to bring his action against us, and not only that, but to be our counsel, our jury and our judge (for so it must be, if you are one with them, as you affirm), we know beforehand how our cause will end. We see the scale of your equal justice turned already, before we have laid our cause in it. And we cannot but wonder to see you carried so contrary to your own received principles.
For you do not know how to find Christ as a ruling and a teaching elder both in one person; therefore he is not complete among you by your own law, except in several persons. And you may thank tradition, or else you would know no more how to find both a king and a priest in him. And yet, in your way of tendering your justice to us, you know how to become one with our adversaries, so that if we deal with them, we deal with you, and if we have to do with you, we have to do with them also.
Yes, further, we know that the chief among you have professed that we are not worthy to live, and that if some of us were among you, we would hardly see the place of our abode any more. Now since they have brooded upon their law to take away life, they must all the more hatch it by taking away all means of life. Witness the prohibition laid upon us, that no powder should be sold to us for our money. And that was at a time when you could not think yourselves safe, in all your own self-provision and worldly equipment, unless you disarmed a company of poor Indians, whom Aaron, your Levitical sacrificer, has made naked, as he does all those who triumph in a calf, though it be the most costly and beautiful one that the jewels and earrings of learning, either in language or in art, can possibly bring forth. Your own alarms at mere rumors may testify to the truth of this.
So then, we are judged by your law before our cause is heard, or we ourselves are brought forth under its liberties. This is well pleasing to us, to have our condition conformed to that of Moses the man of God, who was dead in Pharaoh’s account before he was brought forth. And so it was with Christ our Lord also, in the days of Herod: he who is our life (at which you strike), and who makes all things, yes, death itself, living and advantageous to us.
We cannot but wonder that you should read the Scriptures and not find them fulfilled in and among yourselves, when they appear so plainly that he that runs may read them. What do you think of Herod? The Lord had delivered Peter out of prison, released him from those bonds, and brought him out of that thraldom which Herod had so cruelly imposed on him to gain the favor of the Jews; and this by a power supereminent, transcending the bounds of Herod’s authority, and by a wisdom surpassing the depth of his counsel and cunning to find out, together with his soldiers and champions. Then Herod at once goes down to Caesarea. And Herod is angry with them of Tyre and Sidon; that is, he bears them ill will, or has a secret grudge or perturbation of mind, shown in an overreaching and circumventing cunning to subdue them to himself so that he might rule over them.
Finding himself fall short in power and cunning to subject the word of God, in its messenger, so as to satisfy his own lusts in his lordship over it, he pursues with all eagerness to make himself a god by reigning over the bodies and estates of men, though they be only such as Tyre and Sidon can afford him to make subjects of. They come to him with one accord to offer themselves, yielding to his passionate and politic project. He sits upon the judgment seat in his royal apparel, making his oration of what power he has to protect them, and what wisdom and counsel to minister justice and righteousness to them (an office which belongs only to the Lord). The people cry out with a shout, “the voice of god and not of man,” the truth and substance of which cry is, this is the ordinance of god and not of man. Immediately the angel of the Lord smites him, and he who always acknowledged himself to be a worm and no man upon the earth consumes and eats up all his pomp and glory.
Even so those whom you account the shame and contempt of the people shall (through that angel of the covenant) waste and bring to nothing all those rhetorical (though earthly) orations that are made among you by your so learned, studious and experienced clergy. Take, for an illustration of your state as described above, the speech of your alderman Oliver in the matter of committing Francis Hutchinson to prison. When one of your church members wondered that Brother Winthrop would do it before the church had dealt with him, “Brother,” says he, “why, he is your god, man.”
Lend your eye still further, to see your practice paralleled and acted out in Pilate and the people. When Pilate offers Jesus to the people to be judged, they profess that they have such a law as puts no man to death. They are all for mercy and forgiveness while they are out of the judgment hall; but let Pilate enter there, and then it is nothing but “Crucify him, crucify him,” however false their accusations and witnesses may be. Even so, in your dealings with men in the way of your Jewish brotherhood, your law is all for mercy: to redress, to reform, and to preserve both soul and body. But only enter the common hall, and then, as Pilate asked, “Am I a Jew?” so you ask, “Do I sit or speak here as a brother? I think not. I am now in a higher sphere than a brother can attain to (though such are acknowledged co-heirs with Christ).”
Therefore if a witness is brought in and an oath taken, however untrue, your consciences are purged by law, and your power must have tribute paid to it as far as men’s names (to be branded with infamy), their estates (depriving women and children of necessities), and the precious lives of men can extend themselves to contribute anything to it. So the professed mercy and clemency of your law, which exercises censures only for amendment of life and recovery, comes to this issue: as much as in you lies, to send both soul and body down to hell forever, without redress and without any hope of recovery.
But your hour and the power of darkness are known for what they are: either to hold men’s persons in admiration for the sake of advantage, or else to seek every occasion against them, to brand them with every kind of reproach and ignominy. But as for the truth, taught daily in the Temple, you do not know how to stretch out your hand or exercise your ministry against it, lest it become leprous and you take it back again with loss, when it appears dried and withered.
And why do you reason among yourselves, saying that you exercise the power of your ministrations against none but such as are delinquents, and so clear the innocent and establish peace in all your borders?
We ask: what do you think of those two witnesses prophesying in sackcloth a thousand two hundred and threescore days, those two olive trees and two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth? Are these guilty and vile persons, out of whose hands (by the power of your ministries) you are delivering and releasing the world? Then indeed your ways are justifiable. But if these are the just, chosen and peculiar friends of God, yes, such that without them his truth and righteousness are not justified, nor his wisdom and holiness maintained and upheld in the world in the point of salvation by Christ, then your ways are wicked and to be abhorred. For in your professed course you are the ones by whom these are slain and put to death, and all your glory is to keep their corpses unburied in your streets.
And yet you do not know what you are doing, any more than you know what these witnesses are, of whom you are altogether ignorant; for your libraries never saw them, and you do not see except by their eyes. For these are two, and never more nor yet fewer, yes, always the same. They are olive trees, or else they are no witnesses; and they are also candlesticks, or else both the former fail, yes, are not at all. We must tell you what these are, or else we cannot declare how you kill them. For it is not our intent to open to you the house of the treasures, the silver and the gold, and the spices and the precious ointment, nor the house of our armor, because you take everything that comes from us as execrable and put it all to a profane use.
But these two witnesses are the life and death of our Lord Jesus; or, in the true language of heaven also, the strength and the weakness of Christ. For he was crucified through weakness, yet he lives by the power of God. This is the word of the Lord in Zerubbabel, “Not by an army, nor by power” (and so it deprives him of all strength), “but by a spirit,” before which the greatest mountain or loftiest hill in the world cannot stand, but becomes a plain, which he passes over with facility and ease. That is why he not only lays the top or headstone of all, but also the lowest in the foundation. And then only is the voice of shouting heard, “Grace, grace in the house forever”; and then the day of small things becomes the day of joy and triumph, yes, of dividing the rich spoils and prey of all the world. For then he that does but turn and lift up his eyes cannot look past that great flying book of the curse that has gone forth over the whole earth.
Without these two witnesses jointly uttering themselves in every particular Scripture that anyone undertakes to set forth, no evidence or testimony of God is given or brought in at all, but only a mere refuge of lies for the souls of men to betake themselves to. Without these two pipes of the olive trees emptying themselves into the bowl of the candlesticks, no unction or oil at all is found in them; and when that is lacking, the light of the sanctuary has gone out. So the light appearing among you is only the light of Balaam, whose eye was open, a word you may read either Shethum or Sethum, open or shut; for that opening is nothing else but the shutting up of the holy things of God. So in seeing you do not see, but share only in the light of that beast who puts the witnesses to death, as Balaam did in the sight of that dumb beast of his, whose eyes were opened to see the angel before him.
So while you think it is our wisdom to stoop to you for light, we never come among you without seeing ourselves under a regime of gross and palpable darkness; and we discern you very plainly, how you scrabble at the wall to find the door of Lot’s house, and cannot. We see also how you toil to climb up into the sheepfold another way, yes, so many other ways, and have no sight or discernment at all of us, the Door, by which whoever enters becomes a true feeder of the flock of God; yes, none enters in by it but the true Shepherd himself.
Most impious it is to put to death two such noble witnesses, who have power to shut heaven so that it rain not in the days of their prophesying, to turn the waters into blood, and to smite the earth with all manner of plagues as often as they will. Yet that spirit which is among you kills them, and in this way. One witness is the life or power of the Son of God, as above, which is infinite, not admitting of circumscription or containment, for the heaven of heavens cannot contain him. Yet you have not dared to grasp and environ that power in the heavens, and therefore you have resolved and concluded that he rules upon the earth in these days only by his deputies, lieutenants and vicegerents. By this you limit, and so destroy, the Holy One of Israel. For give him in one time or place what you afterward or elsewhere deny him, and you make a nullity of him to yourselves.
And in doing so you kill that other witness, namely, the death or weakness of the Lord Jesus. For you must have men who are honorable, learned, wise, experienced and of good report, or else they may not rule among you. Yes, and these things are of man and by man, as appears in that they hold office only on such terms that man may annul it and take it away again: witness your changes of officers, which constantly speak for us in this. Thus you have also slain the death or the weakness of Christ, who professes himself to be a worm and no man, the shame and contempt of the people.
And these faithful and true witnesses, thus slain, you must of necessity deny burial, and keep them both in open view in your streets, or otherwise all your pomp and glory falls to the dust from which it came and on which it feeds. Nor can you otherwise send your presents to one another: your acts of justice, power to protect, wealth, honor and friends, with which you gratify each other. And where these are thus slain, and their corpses lie in open view, none of the Gentiles, peoples, tongues and kindreds allowing their carcasses to be put in graves, there is that great city which spiritually is Sodom and Egypt, where our Lord is crucified. But after three days and a half the spirit of life from God shall enter into them, and they shall stand up upon their feet, to the terror of you all.
And do not think that we inveigh only against the great ones of this world for doing this. For we know that the basest peasant has the same spirit as the greatest princes of this world, and the greatest of the princes of this world have the very same spirit with which the basest peasant has laid himself open in the view of all men. These, we say, are the two witnesses, if you can receive it. And what a dishonor it is to trade so much by means of witnesses, and yet not know what a true witness is! If you did know, you would not dare attempt the things you do. In doing them you cast reproach upon all the world, in that you profess yourselves a choice people picked out of it, and yet go on in such practices as you do, maintaining them as your only glory. Our Lord charges you not to swear at all, but it is your dignity to bring men to your seats of justice with nothing but oaths in their mouths. Why do you not balance the Scriptures on this point? That is:
“It hath been said of old, Thou shalt not commit adultery: but I say unto you, he that looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her in his heart already” (Matt 5:27-28). So also “it hath been said of old, Thou shalt not forswear thyself: but I say unto you, Swear not at all” (Matt 5:33-34). So if it is adultery to look in order to lust, it is also forswearing oneself to swear at all. If the one is adultery, the other is perjury; if one is admitted in some cases, so is the other. So in preaching the toleration, indeed the duty, of an oath, you preach the toleration, yes, the duty, of adultery itself.
So our Lord plainly proves to every man’s conscience not only the guilt but the folly and madness of the oath of man, showing how far it is from either installing anyone in office or proving any case. So he who concludes that he has honor and power because he has received the oath of man, or that he has knowledge and boldness to judge in a case from that testimony, without which he could not have it, is as vain in his thoughts as if he should conclude from it, “I have now altered the frame of heaven, which is no less stable than the throne of the great God; or demolished the earth, which is as firm as his footstool forever; or made a breach in the orders of Jerusalem, that choice and peculiar city of the great King, whose institutions no mortal breath can encroach upon.” It is as if he should profess his authority and skill to be such that he can make a hair of his head black or white, cause his age to wax old as a garment does, or renew it with the eagle at his pleasure. By this, in this point of swearing, man professes his folly to be such that he has become not only vain in his imaginations, but has risen to such pride and usurpation in them as to intrude himself into the royal prerogative of his Maker.
So however you boast of the ordinances of God, he tells you there is no more than yea, yea, and nay, nay, in them. For what is once nay is ever nay in the ordination of Christ, and what is once yea is ever yea with him and by his account, however man reckons, whose account shall be called over again. What is once curse is ever the curse, and what is once the principality and power of Christ is ever the principality and power of Christ, just as what is once the principality and power of darkness is ever the same, whatever hands it comes into for manifestation. Measure your kingdom, whether it is eternal, and your jurisdiction, whether it is unlimited. For he has given (him) the heathen for his inheritance, the utmost parts of the earth for his possession. He professes no kingdom of less extent, nor can he approve or acknowledge any who do, any more than light can approve of darkness, or the Lord Jehovah of the Lord Baal.
Be wise, therefore, and think well while it is called today. Harden not your hearts, as though you would make yourselves Meribah, nothing but strife and contention against the Lord. Rather kiss the Son (if it is possible), lest his wrath be kindled and you perish from the way forever. O blessed are they alone who hope in him!
So he who professes in this way, “It is yea, I am a pastor, but it was nay; at such a time I was none,” renounces that spirit of the true pastor, who is yet the only feeder of Israel, and professes only that spirit which pushes the weak with the horn and muddies with his feet the waters where the flock of God should drink. He with whom it is, “Yea, I am a ruler, but it was nay when I was none at all,” renounces the spirit of him who rules in righteousness, and professes the spirit of him who rules according to the god of this world, that prince of the power of the air, who is now working so effectually in the children of disobedience. So also he with whom it is, “Yea, I am a captain, or chief slaughterman, but it was nay; time was, I was none at all,” renounces that victory and slaughter made by the Captain and High Priest of our profession. (As he is a Lamb slain from the beginning, his victory and slaughter must be of the same antiquity.) Such a man professes himself to be a chief slaughterman, or superfluous giant, made in that host of the Philistines, standing ready to come out and defy the host of the living God.
Yes, it is evident that whatever is more than yea, yea, and nay, nay, not settling each upon its base, on which it stands forever without control, but able to remove, create or make void offices and officers at their pleasure, is of that evil. It is not of Jesus, the salvation of his people, but of Shedim, that waster and destroyer of mankind forever. Know therefore that it is the oath of God which confirms and makes good his covenant and promise to a thousand generations, and it is the oath of man which is the bond and obligation of that league and agreement made with death and hell forever. Be assured, it is not the tabernacle of witness that you have among you, brought in by Jesus into the possession of the Gentiles. It is Siccuth your king, or the tabernacle of Moloch, the star of your god Remphan, figures which you have made for yourselves, which you have taken up, and which you are bearing so stoutly upon your shoulders.
Now, to tell you what an oath according to God is (that the Scriptures are delivered upon no other ground or terms of certainty, wherever they are published) is a thing outside your jurisdiction; you cannot discern or judge of it. Therefore, according to our word above, we leave it to you as a parable, as all the holy word of our God is, as your conduct in all points, as in this one, daily declares.
In a word: when we have business in your jurisdiction, we know what it is to submit to the wise dispensations of our God; when you have business among us, in the liberties he has given us, we do not doubt that you shall find him judge among us, beyond and above any cause or thing you can propose to us. And let that suffice you. And know that you cannot maintain a jurisdiction unless you reject all inroads upon other men’s privileges; and so do we.
In the meantime we shall, as we think good, be calling over again some matters that you have taken up and had the handling of among you, to see what justice or equity we find has been exercised in them, and redress them accordingly. For we profess right to all men, and to do no violence at all, as you in your written order threaten to do to us. For we have learned how to discipline our children or servants without offering violence to them, and just so we know how to deal with our debauched, rude, even inhuman neighbors (or, if you will, Nabals) without doing violence, but rather rendering to them what is their due.
Nor shall we deprive a witness of his modest testimony because of the outcries and clamors of such a one as that ill-bred, apostate Arnold, that felonious hog-killer, when he is the party to be testified against, nor because of the oath of anyone interested in the cause. Nor shall we be forward to come so far to supply you with work at your request, until we know that you bear another mind than others of your neighbors do, with whom we have had to do in this country.
We have stooped under their pretended and devised laws, to the robbing and spoiling of our goods, the livelihood of our wives and children, thinking they had labored (though groping in great darkness) to bring forth the truth in the rights and equity of things. But we have found them to be a company of gross, dissembling hypocrites who, under the pretense of law and religion, have done nothing else but go about to establish themselves in ways that maintain their own vicious lusts, and we renounce their diabolical practice. They are such as have denied in their public courts that the laws of our native country should be named among them, yes, those ancient statute laws, and have cast us into most base, nasty and insufferable places of imprisonment for speaking according to the language of those laws. Meanwhile they have broken open our houses in a violent way of hostility (abusing our wives and our little ones) to take from us the volumes in which those laws are preserved, thinking by this to keep us ignorant of the courses they are resolved to run, so that the viciousness of their own wills might be a law to them. Yes, they have endeavored, and that in public statements, that a man accused by them should not have liberty to answer for himself in open court.
Dealings of the same nature we find in the place from which you style us your neighbors (on whose unbridled malice we find one higher than you putting a curb). And yet in your account and reckoning we are the parties who are still doing the wrong and must bear the guilt in your most mature sentence, in whomever the stain arises and abides. But the God of vengeance, to whom our cause is referred (and we never have to go seeking our protector and judge), will show himself in our deliverance out of the hands of you all, yes, of all the house of that Ishbosheth and Mephibosheth. Nor will he fail us in uttering and making known his strength, in which we stand, to serve in our generation and to minister in our course, today and tomorrow; and on the third day none can deprive us of perfection. For he has taught us to know what it is to walk today, and tomorrow, and the day following also, when a perishing estate cannot arise out of Jerusalem, though she is the only one (yes, none but she) that kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to her.
Behold, you who are looking for and foretelling so much of the coming of Christ, still driving the day on before you for certain years, which some (you say) shall live to see, and the rest shall reach only at the day of death: “You blind guides,” as your fathers have always done, so do you. Behold, we say, whenever he appears, your house (which you so glory in) shall be left to you desolate. It shall be turned into nothing but desolation and confusion, for Babel is its name.
Nor shall you see him to your comfort in the glory of his kingdom until you can say, “Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord” (Matt 23:39). That will be when the authority and power of man appears to you to be the building of Babel, and the name and authority of God alone to be that in which the blessing consists; and that in such a way as is nothing but a way of reproach in the eyes of all the world: that a King should ride into his chief city so strangely equipped, upon a borrowed ass, her trappings old, worn-out garments, and accompanied by none but poor, lowly, excommunicated persons. Your elders, scribes, Pharisees, lawyers and all the credible persons among you fully reckon such people to be not only accursed but also destitute and void of all law. When you can find “Hosanna in the highest” arising out of such contempt and shame, then, and only then, shall you sing to him with comfort.
In the meantime acknowledge your portion, which is to trust and stay yourselves on the name of man, and to delight and glory in his beauty, which shall fade as a leaf, and like the grass shall wither when it is fitting itself for the oven. Such is man, whose breath is in his nostrils, and the son of sorry man, in whom you delight to trust. His power and his cunning bring forth nothing else but what you shall see and hear in the country from which we were brought.
We are not ignorant of those shameful lies and falsehoods that have gone out against us, and the daily wresting of our words to cast contempt upon us, thinking to bow down our backs under ignominy and reproach. Nor are we ignorant of those straits and difficulties they have thrown us into in the things which concern this present life, which would have taken away the lives of many if our God had not been seen beyond and above what their thoughts could reach (as their own confession has witnessed). And they did it in such a way of painted hypocrisy and false gloss to the eye of the world that we might seem to it to be our own executioners.
We resolve, therefore, to follow our employments, and to carry and behave ourselves as we have formerly done, and no otherwise. For we have wronged no man, unless it be by laboring hard to provide for our families, and by allowing gross, idle and idol drones to take our labor out of the mouths and off the backs of our little ones, to lord it over us.
So if any shall go about henceforth to disturb or annoy us in our employments and liberties, which God has put or shall put into our hands, any who can claim no interest in us except by these courses, we know by sufficient proof that their business is nothing else but that ancient errand of Nimrod, that rebellious hunter after the precious life. And that errand of his shall no more be delivered to us in that covert cruelty and dissembling way of hypocrisy, but in direct and open terms of tyranny. We will not be dealt with as before; we speak in the name of our God, we will not. For if any shall disturb us, as above, secret hypocrites shall become open tyrants, and their laws shall appear to be nothing else but mere lusts in the eyes of all the world.
And why do you murmur among yourselves at this saying, thinking it is not a Christian expression? It is because you are ignorant of the cross of our Lord Jesus, not knowing what it is. That is why, while you inveigh against those who set up a statue of wood and stone to bow down to it, and who are so vain as to cross the air (to use your own expression) over the faces of infants when they sprinkle them with water, to just as much purpose, you in the meantime preach and set up Seghnirim for your cross, whom you fall down to so willingly. And lest you let the word pass without its being explained to all: it signifies horror and fear. That is the cross you hold and teach, by and through which you think to be saved; and it is a name given by our Lord to the devil himself, as our English translators render it. And the Lord never gives a name as an empty title, but according to the nature of the thing named.
So if he speaks, “I have said, Ye are gods” (Psalm 82:6), of any besides himself, it is to declare that there is not only the name but the very nature of the god of this world. And therefore he says they shall die, even as Adam, who aspired to and usurped the place of God, and fall also as one of the princes, even as one of those princes of Midian whose carcasses became dung for the earth. And he who gives that title to any but the true God (who made heaven and earth), in any other sense than as it declares a flat opposition against God, is re-enacting that ancient spirit of the serpent, “If ye eat, you shall be as gods,” to judge of good and evil, for which all men of that kind are set up.
Even so, when you tell the people that by sorrow, compunction, anxiety and trouble of mind they share in the sufferings of Christ, and that their comfort is to flow out of that condition, it is nothing else but to conclude the Son of God to be Belial, yes, to affirm him to be Seghnirim himself. This he receives at your hands in your ministries, for all your fawning upon him with a kiss. So if you will know how far you are from communicating in the death of Christ, take it in this parable: truly, as far as the weakness of God is stronger than man.
Countrymen (for we cannot but call you so, though we find your conduct toward us so much worse than these Indians’), we advise you to take things together, and what God has joined, let none dare to put asunder. So if you are ashamed of the cross in baptism, be ashamed of the baptism also, for as the cross is, so is the baptism. Your ancestors therefore go beyond you in this, in joining the crossing of the air and the sprinkling with the element of water together. But wherever baptism according to the word of Christ is, there the cross of Christ is also. They can no more be separated than his scepter and his kingdom can, for where the one is, there the other is also; and as they are coincident, so are they co-apparent.
So if ever you see the baptism of Christ truly in use and exercised upon anyone, you as truly see that person partaking and communicating in the cross and sufferings of the Lord Jesus Christ. And to see persons in such an estate, and to conclude that afterward they may be worthy of censure, yes, possibly even to an anathema maranatha, is nothing else but to conclude a total and final falling away from the grace of God, as your fathers have done before you. For there is no grace greater than the cross of our Lord Jesus.
Behold therefore, you despisers, the vanity and abomination of all your baptisms, how prejudicial they are to the cross of Christ. Be ashamed, and return in time, or he shall be a swift witness against you forever, when your repentance shall come too late. But you think the cross of Christ is found nowhere but in bowing the back under every burden, and cringing and crouching to the lust of every man. Otherwise his scepter is not fit, nor does it suit at all with your government, unless it is so servile that every man may serve his own lusts by it, to get wealth and honor, friends and allies, by setting bounds and limits to the holy Word of God, some in the way of one device, and some according to another. And as for anyone who will not either walk as a dumb beast (worse than Balaam’s ass) and say nothing, or else give a sense of the holy writings that maintains the devised platform: if mercy must be used, so as not to hang and burn them, yet banishment is ready and waiting for them. Therefore you shall know, by the rod of his power that comes out of Sion, that he will be ruler, even in the midst of his enemies.
As for us, whom you style your neighbors of Providence: you have said it, Providence is our stronghold; the neighborliness of the Samaritan is what we profess. And as for the lookings-on and turnings-aside of your priests and Levites, without either unction or tender compassion, all those slain and wounded in soul among you, finding no remedy, plainly testify to all men what the nature of your travels and your neighborliness is: that neither the oil of those two olive trees, nor the fatness of that vine which makes glad God and man, is to be found among you. Your speech to us in general, not using our names, though we know it is particular persons you aim at, plainly lets us see the word Elem revived and living in you, as it stands with its context in Psalm 58.
John Wickes
Randall Holden
Robert Potter
Samuel Gorton
John Greene
Francis Weston
Richard Carder
Richard Waterman
Nicholas Power
John Warner
William Waddell
Gorton’s Second Letter
From our Neck: Curo, September 15, 1643.
To the great and honored Idol General, now set up in the Massachusetts, whose pretended equity in the distribution of justice to the souls and bodies of men is nothing else but a mere device of man, according to the ancient customs and sleights of Satan, transforming himself into an angel of light, to subject and make slaves of that species or kind that God has honored with his own image. Read Daniel 3, in which (if it is not like Lot’s love to the Sodomites) you may see the visage or countenance of the State.
For we know the sound of all the music, from the highest note of the wind instruments, sounding, or set up by the breath or voices of men (to have dominion and rule as though there were no God in heaven or in earth but they, to do right to the sons of men), to the lowest tones of the stringed instruments, subjecting themselves to the hand or skill of the devised ministrations of men, as though God had made man to be a vassal to his own species or kind. For a man may as well be a slave to his belly, and make it his God, as to anything that man can bring forth, yes, even in his best perfection, since man can lay claim to no title or term of honor but what the dust, rottenness and putrefaction can afford; for that by right belongs solely to our Lord Christ. Woe therefore to the world because of the idols of it; for idols must needs be set up, but woe to them by whom they are erected.
Out of the abovesaid principles, which are the kingdom of darkness and of the devil, you have written another note to us, to add to your former pride and folly, telling us again that you have taken Pumham, with others, into your jurisdiction and government, and that upon good grounds (as you say). You might have done well to prove yourselves Christians before you mingled yourselves with the heathen, so that your children might have known how to put a distinction between yours and them in times to come. But we perceive that to be too hard a work for you to perform, even in the present time. But if you will share justice and government with that Indian, we advise you to keep him among yourselves, where he and you may perform that worthy work.
Yet upon a better ground we can inform you that he may not expect former courtesies from us. For now, by your note, we are assured of his breach of covenant with us, in this his seeking and subjection to you, which he has always denied before. Let him and you know, therefore, that he is to make other provision for planting his corn hereafter than upon Shawomet. For we will not harbor among us any such fawning, lying and cadaverous person as he is, after the knowledge of him that you have now in part given us. Only he shall have liberty enough to take away his corn, his dwelling or any of his implements, provided he passes away in peace and quiet. That might in no case be allowed if we lived by blood, as you do, whether through slitting of the nose, severing of the ear from the head, branding upon the back, suffocation of the veins through extremity of cold by your banishments in the winter, or strangling in the flesh with a noose.
But we know our course, professing the kingdom of God and his righteousness, renouncing that of darkness and the devil, in which you delight to trust. For without the practice of these things you cannot kiss your hand, bless the Idol, nor profess your vows and offerings to be paid and performed. O you generation of vipers, who has forewarned you, or forestalled your minds with this, but Satan himself: that the practice of these things is to flee from the wrath to come? Whereas the very exercise and performance of them is nothing else but the vengeance and wrath of God upon you already. For mankind, so harmoniously made in the image of God, has in the exercises of the kingdom become the torturer and tormentor, yes, the executioner of itself, while those of you who are of the same stock and stem work out, yes, and that with elaborate care, through the law of your minds, the death and destruction of one another. Meanwhile the same nature or subsistence, in the way of our Lord Jesus, saves both itself and others.
You tell us of complaints made by the Indians of unjust dealings and injuries done to them. Why do they not make them known to us? They have never to this day complained to us of anything done but they had satisfaction to the full, according to their own mind, as we often know by what they express to us. And yet the insufferable wrongs done to us by them still lie set aside. For we know very well that we have plenty of causeless adversaries, lacking no malice that Satan can inject. Therefore we suffer much, so that in the perfection and height of their plots they may receive the greater rebuke and shame for their baseness in the eyes of all the world.
To which end we have not only committed our condition to writing, but have also committed those writings into the hands and custody of such friends that they shall not be taken from them by any, or by all the governments of this country, as they formerly have been, so that our wrongs might not appear. Therefore never pick a quarrel against us in these things, for we know all your styles and devices. For now you lack such as old malicious Arnold, one of your low stringed instruments, to play his fiddle among us; and we are rid of your benediction also, sprung out of the same stock, to make rents and divisions for you to enter, to gain honor to yourselves by having patients to heal; and however long they lie under your hands, your surgery must be thought none the worse. Lacking these or such like of the English to betray into your hands the liberties God has given us, you now work by your helpers, these accursed Indians. But you are deceived in us. We are not a cup fitted for your so eager appetite, except that if you take it down it shall prove to you a cup of trembling, either making you vomit out your own eternal shame, or else making you burst asunder for air with your fellow confessor, as Judas Iscariot.
For Mr. Winthrop and his copartner Parker may not think to annex our purchased plantation to their island lying so near it. They come too late on that point, though Benedict has reported that Miantonomo, one of the sachems from whom we bought it, should lose his head for selling his right in it to us.
A minister also affirmed that Mr. Winthrop said to him that we should either be subjected to you or else removed from here, though it should cost blood. Know therefore that our lives are already set apart for the cause we have in hand, so we will lose nothing but what is set apart beforehand. Consider therefore what you would gain by fetching them, if it were in your power; for our loss would be nothing at all.
For we are resolved that, according as you put yourselves forth toward us, so you shall find us transformed to answer you. If you put forth your hand to us as countrymen, ours are in readiness for you. If you exercise the pen, we likewise become a ready writer. If your sword is drawn, ours is girt upon our thigh. If you present a gun, make haste to give the first fire; for we are come to put fire upon the earth, and it is our desire to have it speedily kindled.
As for your still pursuing us to come to your courts, to receive your parcels of justice: undoubtedly either God has blinded your eyes so that you do not see the answer we formerly gave on that point, or else you are most audacious to urge it upon us again. You may also take notice that we take it in more disdain than you would if we should urge you (yes, the chief among you) to come up to us and be employed at our pleasure in such works as we thought good to set you about. And as for your grant of freedom to us to come down to you and return in safety, we cannot sufficiently vilify this verbal and perfunctory offer of yours. For we know very well, by the verdict of your own conscience, that whatever wrongs have passed between us since our coming into this country, you have been the violent agents and we the sufferers. As for fearing, therefore, to come among you as people who have done wrong, the cause vanishes in us, and so must the effect also. And we cannot fear to come to you as to tyrants, which your grant must necessarily imply, knowing that he who is with us is stronger than he who is with you.
Also, the earth is the Lord’s and the fullness thereof, and when and where he shall call, we will go; but not at the will and lust of sorry men, to play their parts with us at their pleasure, as they have done before and as it is plain you desire to do. For if your lusts did not prevail over you in that kind, you might well think that we have better employments than to trot to the Massachusetts upon the report of a lying Indian, or an English one either, as your agents and ordinary hirelings do.
But know this, O you… that so long as we behave ourselves as men, “walking in the name of our God,” wherever we have occasion to come, if any mortal man whose breath is in his nostrils dares to call us into question, we dare to give an answer to him or them. Nor shall we fail, through God, to give testimony, even in his conscience, of the hope that is in us, whether his question may concern the rise or succession of either priest or peer. In the meantime we sit in safety under the cloudy pillar, while the nations roar and make a noise about us. And though you may look upon us with the unopened eye of Elijah’s servant, thinking us as nothing to those who are against us, yet wherever the cloud rests, we know the Lord’s return to the many thousands of Israel.
In that you say our freedom granted to come to you takes away all excuse from us, we freely turn it back upon yourselves, as those who make excuses. Your laws and proceedings with the souls and bodies of men are nothing else but a continual art (like the horse in the mill) of accusing and excusing, which you carry on by circumstances and conjectures, as all the fathers have done before you, the diviners and necromancers of the world, who are gone to their own place and have their reward. But as for the true nature, rise and distribution of things as they are indeed, and as they shall remain and abide as a law firm and stable forever, we say, and can make it good, that you know nothing at all.
Therefore such as can delight themselves in preaching, professing and executing such things as must end as the brute beasts do (nay, take them away for the present and they have lost their honor, their religion and also their God), let such, we say, know themselves to be that beast and false prophet, and no man of God at all. In the meantime we look not on the things that are seen, but on the things that are not seen, knowing that the one are temporary and the other eternal. Nor do we think the better of any man for being invested in places or things that will in time wax old as a garment does, nor do we judge the worse of any man for the lack of them. For if we did, we would have to condemn the Lord Christ, as so many do at this day.
We demand when we may expect some of you to come to us, to answer and give satisfaction for some of these foul and inhuman wrongs you have done, not to the Indians, but to us your countrymen. Not to bring in a catalogue, as we might, take this one particular abuse you are now committing, in that you abet and back these base Indians to abuse us. Indeed Pumham is an aspiring person, as becomes a prince of his profession; for having crept into one of our neighbors’ houses in the absence of the people, and feloniously rifled it, he was taken coming out again at the chimney top. Socononoco also has entered one of our houses in the same manner with various of his companions, and breaking open a chest, stole out various parcels of goods, some part of which, as some of his companions have affirmed, are in his custody at this time. Yet we stand still to see to what good outcome you will bring your proceedings with these persons, by whom you are so honorably attended in the Court General, as you call it, and with whom you would honor us also, by having us come sixty or eighty miles to stand by you and them.
We could also tell you that it is nothing to these fellows to send our cattle out of the woods with arrows in their sides, as appears at this moment in one that has just now come home so; and it is well they come home at all, for sometimes their wigwams can receive them, and we have nothing of them at all. Yes, they can domineer over our wives and children in our houses when we are away from home about our necessary business, sometimes throwing stones, to the endangering of their lives, and sometimes violently taking our goods, making us run for them if we will have them. And if we speak to them to amend their manners, they at once boast that the Massachusetts is all one with them.
Let the villainy they do be what it will, they think themselves secure, for they look to be upheld by you in whatever they do, if you are stronger than those they have to deal with. And they look with the same eye you yourselves do, thinking the multitude will bear down all. And they persuade themselves (as well they may) that as you tolerate and maintain them in others of their daily practices, such as lying, Sabbath-breaking, taking many wives, gross whoredoms and fornications, so you will do also in their stealing, abusing of our children and the like.
For you have your diligent resident agents among them, who daily drive home this point: how hateful we are to you. They call us by other names of their own devising, and make them believe that we are not Englishmen, and are therefore the object of the ill will of all who are about us; and that if we have anything to do with you, the very naming of our persons shall lose us our case, be it what it will. This is all too evident by the case pending between William Arnold and John Warner. No sooner was the name of Mr. Gorton mentioned among you than Mr. Dudley disdainfully asked, “Is this one joined to Gorton?” And Mr. Winthrop, upon the same speech, unjustly refused the oath of the witness, calling him a hired false witness. Are these the ways and persons you trade by toward us? Are these the people you honor yourselves with? The Lord shall lay such honor in the dust, and bow down your backs with shame and sorrow to the grave, and declare such to be apostates from the truth, and falsifiers of the word of God only to please men and serve their own lusts, who can give thanks in their public congregations for their unity with such gross abominations as these.
We must needs ask you another question, from a sermon now preached among you: namely, how that blood relishes which you have formerly sucked from us, by casting us upon straits beyond our strength, we who had not been exercised in such kinds of labors, any more than the best of you in former times; by removing us from our former conveniences, to the taking away of the lives of some of us. And this when you are about your dished-up dainties, having turned the juice of a poor, feeble grape that perishes in the using into the blood of our Lord Jesus by the cunning skill of your magicians. That juice makes so many in the world mad and drunk, and yet a little sleep makes them their own men again; so it can heal and pacify the conscience for the present, but the least hand of God brings back the fears and terror again. Let our blood, we say, present itself together with it.
You hypocrites, when will you answer such cases as these? And we hereby promise you that we will never look a man in the face if you do not have a fairer hearing than we ever had among you, or can ever expect. And be it known to you all that we are your own countrymen, whatever you report of us, though the Lord has taught us a language you never spoke, and you cannot hear it either; and that is the cause of your alienation from us. For as you have mouths and speak not, so you have ears and hear not. So we leave you to the judgment and arraignment of God Almighty.
The joint act, not of the Court General, but of the peculiar fellowship now abiding upon Shawomet.
Randall Holden
This they acknowledged in Court, though only Holden’s signature was on it.
Postscript
We need not put a seal to this warrant of ours, any more than you did to yours. The Lord has added one to our hands, at the very conclusion of it, in that effusion of blood and horrible massacre now made at the Dutch plantation, of our loving countrymen, women and children. That is nothing else but the complete figure, in a short epitome, of what we have written, summed up in one entire act. And lest you should make it part of your justification, as you do all such like acts, provided they are not upon your own backs, concluding them to be greater sinners than yourselves, we tell you, nay; but except you repent, you shall likewise perish.
For we ask you, who was the cause of Mrs. Hutchinson’s departure from among you? Was it voluntary? No. She changed her phrases according to the dictates of your tutors, and confessed her mistakes, so that she might give you content to let her abide among you; yet you expelled her and cast her away. No less are you the origin of her removal from Aquidneck. For she saw that her children could not come down among you, no, not even to confer with you in your own way of brotherhood, but were clapped up and detained by so long an imprisonment. Rumors also were noised that the island should be brought under your government; and if it were, she was fearful for their lives, or else that they would have to act against the plain verdict of their own conscience, having had so great and evident proof of your dealings before. The island also was at such divisions within itself: some earnestly desired that it should be delivered into your hands, professing their unity with you; others denied it, professing their dissent and division from you, though for what they themselves do not know, but only out of their abominable pride to exercise the like tyranny.
From these and such like workings, which had their origin in you, she gathered to herself and took up this fiction (with the rest of her friends), that the Dutch plantation was the city of refuge. So she had gathered like things from your doctrines before, when she seemed to hold out certain glimpses or glances of light, more than appeared elsewhere, while there were such as approved it, in whom there might be some hope to exalt the instruments of it higher than could be expected from others. But you know very well that you could never rest nor be at quiet till you had put it under a bushel, that is, bounded and measured the infinite and immense word of God according to your own shallow, human and carnal capacities. However high the seats such capacities may get in your synagogues, synods and Jewish Sanhedrins, yet they shall never enter into the kingdom of God to be a doorkeeper there.
Do not therefore beguile yourselves in crying out against the errors of those so miserably fallen; for the things they held are no other than branches of the same root that you yourselves so stoutly stand upon. But know this, that now the axe is laid to the root of the tree, of which you are a part; and every tree that brings not forth fruit according to the law of that good thing which the Father knows how to give to those who ask it shall be cut down and cast into the fire.
Do not fill up your speeches or tales either (we mean your sermons, only we are not fond of the idolizing of words, any more than of persons or places). For you yourselves know that the word is no more than a noise or talk, just as you also know that your great and terrible word Magistrate is no more in its origin than Masterly, or Masterless, which has no great luster in our ordinary understanding. Therefore we look to find and enjoy the substance, and let the ceremony of these things vanish away like vapors. Though they gather themselves into clouds without any water at all in them, the Lord in the meantime is a dew to Israel, and makes him grow like a lily, casting out his roots and branches as Lebanon.
We say, do not fill up your talk, as your manner is, crying that she went out without ordinances. For God can raise up to Abraham, out of that stone which you have already rejected, not only children but also ministers and ordinances. You may remember also that every people and poor plantation formerly fleeced by you cannot reach to the hire of one of your Levites, nor fetch in one such dove as you send abroad into our native country to carry and bring you news.
Nor can you charge them on that point, for it was for protection or government that she went. And however it may be with hire in other respects, yet the price of a wife, joined with the safety of his own life, carried a minister along with them, of the same rise and breeding as your own, to add to the blood so savagely and causelessly spilled, with a company of such as you take pleasure to protect; for they are all of one spirit, even if they have no hands in the same act. We say their death is causeless, for we have heard them affirm that she would never heave up a hand, no, nor move a tongue, against any who persecuted or troubled them, but would only endeavor to save themselves by flight, not perceiving the nature and end of persecution, nor of that antichristian opposition and tyranny, the outcome of which declares itself in this so … and lamentable.
Winslow’s Note on the Letters
Note, good reader, that I had orders to publish these two letters of his not only word for word but letter for letter. But because their spelling was so bad that it would scarcely have been understood, I left it to be corrected by the printer, with no word to be changed. And the reason for the word left out above is that it was worn away and so soiled in the original that we could not read it. We thought it better to leave a blank than to put in a word of our own that was not theirs.
In the next place, I present you here with certain Observations collected out of both their letters by a godly and reverend minister, so that the reader may better understand them, and indeed test the spirits of these men, whether they are of God or not. These Observations of his are arranged under three heads, namely:
First, their reproachful and reviling speeches against the government and magistrates of Massachusetts, which Gorton in his book professes to honor so much, because their government is derived from the State of England. I therefore ask you to take all the more careful notice of it.
The second head of his Observations directs you to their reviling language, not only against that particular government and its magistrates, but against magistracy itself and all civil power.
And in his third head you are directed to take notice of their blasphemous speeches against the holy things of God. Because all these are of great concern, I beg the reader to take a little trouble to compare them with the letters of Mr. Gorton and his company.
Observations: The Magistrates
1. They say our magistrates laid their wisdom prostrate in sending letters to them, letters which they scornfully call an irregular note.
2. That our magistrates bore them causeless enmity, the proof of which every occasion brings forth.
3. They slyly call our magistrates the seed of the ancient mother, that is, of the enmity of the Devil.
4. That they know it is the name of Christ, called upon them, that our magistrates are striving against.
5. That our magistrates try to hide their sin, as Adam did, making the world believe that they do not desire to contend, but only to redress something in point of civil peace.
6. That our magistrates stand on tiptoe to stretch themselves beyond their bounds, to seek occasion against them.
7. That those who accuse them are accusers of the brethren, Satan being a liar and the father of it; and that our magistrates cannot know this, though they are told it.
8. That this act of our magistrates, in treating about their land, is a map of their spiritual estate.
9. That our magistrates delight daily to eat of the forbidden fruit (which they call man’s wisdom, and out of which our churches and commonwealth are formed) to gain conformity with their maker.
10. They scoff at our magistrates’ purity and godliness, telling them that Cole and Arnold, their dissembling subjects, are full of the spirit of their purity.
11. They do not say plainly that our magistrates are dogs, but they compare them to dogs taking their vomit back into its former digestion, by receiving Cole and Arnold under our jurisdiction.
12. That the whole structure and edifice among us (that is, the churches and commonwealth) is raised up in the spirit of a hireling; and that by submission to the Word of God in fasting, feasting, withdrawing for study, contributing and storing up treasure (that is, for church uses in the several churches), they do nothing else but bring forth fruit unto death.
13. That our magistrates do not regard the Lord Jesus any further than he agrees with riches, honor and ease; no, they renounce and reject him.
14. That our magistrates plainly crucify Christ and put him to an open shame, which the apostle in Hebrews 6 applies to the worst of men, who commit the unpardonable sin, and for whom men are not to pray.
15. That our magistrates are as far from yielding subjection to Christ as Cole and Arnold are from being honorable and loyal subjects. These two they call the shame of religion, the disturbance and disquiet of the place, dissembling subjects, and also debauched, rude, inhuman Nabals, ill-bred, apostatized persons, and felonious, with many more such speeches.
16. That the things of God’s kingdom are infinitely beyond the reach of our magistrates’ spirit, and they cannot hear the living oracle, and therefore they are dumb in declaring justice.
17. That the magistrates are Jews according to the flesh, and stout maintainers of the man of sin.
18. That they know our magistrates’ eyes are dazzled with envy, and their ears open to lies.
19. That our magistrates judge them before their cause is heard.
20. That in inviting them to their courts for their equal-balanced justice (as they scornfully call it), our magistrates thereby strike at Christ, their life.
21. That our magistrates are like Herod, whom God struck with worms for seeking to subdue Tyre and Sidon by overreaching and circumventing cunning; and like Pontius Pilate, and the people who outside the judgment hall are all for mercy, but inside it cry nothing but “Crucify him, crucify him,” however false the accusations and witnesses may be. “So,” they say, “in your dealings with men in the way of the Jewish brotherhood, your law is all for mercy, to redress, to reform, for the preservation of soul and body. But once a man enters the common hall, then if witnesses are only brought in and an oath taken, though never so untrue, your consciences are purged by law, and your power must have tribute paid to it, so far as to brand men’s names with infamy and deprive women and children of things necessary.”
22. That the professed clemency and mercy of their law is, as much as lies in them, to send both soul and body down to Sheol (that is, the grave and hell) forever, without redress or any hope of recovery.
23. That their hour and power of darkness is known, and what it is: either to have men’s persons in admiration because of advantage, or else to seek every occasion against them, with all manner of reproach and ignominy.
24. That their ways are wicked and to be abhorred, because in their professed course the two witnesses are slain by them and put to death, and all their glory is to keep their corpses unburied; and these two witnesses are the life and death of the Lord Jesus.
25. That the light appearing among them is nothing but the light of Balaam, so that in seeing they see not, but share only in the light of that Beast who put the witnesses to death.
26. They tell our magistrates that they never come among them without finding themselves in a reign of gross and palpable darkness, and that they can see the magistrates scrabbling on the wall for the door of Lot’s house.
27. That our magistrates do not know what a true witness is.
28. That the whole Word of God is a parable to them, as their conduct in every point daily declares.
29. That they will not come near our magistrates until they know that the magistrates are of a different mind from their neighbors. These neighbors they call robbers and gross dissembling hypocrites, who do nothing but try to establish such ways as may maintain their own vicious lusts, whose laws are pretended and devised, and whose practices (they say) they renounce as diabolical.
30. “You blind guides,” they say to our magistrates, “as your fathers have always done, so do you.”
31. “You set up Seghnirim” (that is, as they themselves interpret it, fear and horror, or the devil), “by and for which you hope to be saved.”
32. That our magistrates’ conduct toward them is far worse than that of the Indians, whom they themselves cry out against as thieves and robbers.
33. That they are despisers. “Behold, you despisers,” they say, “the vanity and abominations of all your baptisms.”
34. “You think,” they say, “that the cross of Christ is nothing but bowing down the back to every burden, and cringing and crouching to the lust of every man.”
35. They call the General Court the great Idol General, whose pretended equity in distributing justice is a mere device of man according to the sleights of Satan.
36. They tell the Court that it had written another note out of the kingdom of darkness and the devil, to add to its former pride and folly.
37. Because the Court took Pumham and Socononoco, Indian sachems, under its protection, they tell the Court that it might have done well to prove itself Christian before it mixed itself with the heathen; but this was too hard for it to do.
38. They advise the Court, in scorn, to keep the Indian with it, where he and the Court might perform that worthy work of distributing justice.
39. They tell the Court that it lives by blood.
40. They tell the Court that they renounce the kingdom of darkness and the devil, in which the Court delights to trust.
41. They call the Court, “O you generation of vipers.”
42. They tell the Court that they are not a cup fit for its appetite, but a cup of trembling, either to make the Court vomit up its own eternal shame, or else to make its members burst asunder with their fellow confessor Judas Iscariot.
43. That the Court is either blind or audacious in desiring them to come for its parcels of justice, and that they disdain to come to it.
44. They profess that they cannot vilify enough the Court’s promise that they may come down to it and return in safety, which they call a verbal and perfunctory offer.
45. They tell the Court that if its lusts had not prevailed over it, it might think they had better employment than to trot to Massachusetts, as its agents and ordinary hirelings do.
46. They tell the Court that its laws and proceedings with the souls and bodies of men are nothing else but a continual act of accusing and excusing, like the horse in the mill, which, they say, “you do by circumstances and conjectures, as your fathers also have done before you, the diviners and necromancers of this world, who are gone to their own place and have their reward.”
47. They accuse our magistrates of maintaining the Indians in their lying, Sabbath-breaking, gross whoredoms, stealing, and the like.
48. That our magistrates are hypocrites, having eyes and not seeing, ears and not hearing, mouths and not speaking.
Now if these men had returned a rational answer, it might perhaps have been fitting to return some short reply in a few marginal notes. But since both their letters are fraught with little else than mere railing and reproachful language, it may be enough to present them together in one view like this, so that the wise and prudent may take a taste of their spirits, and learn from what fire their tongues are so highly inflamed.
If our courts and magistrates had been to blame in anything, what a fair and easy way it would have been to convince them of it first, before reviling them so bitterly! But to cut and slash like this, and cast all this filth in their faces without proof or reason, argues a bold and insolent spirit, fitted to stir up tumults and confusions in the place where they live. If the magistrates had indeed given them any sore provocation to return ill language, there might have been some excuse. But alas, all the cause that can be given for most of this ill language is nothing but this: the magistrates wrote to them in a friendly way, to send some of their own number to clear up the differences between them and the Indians, and to show their just title to the land they possessed.
If they had kept this flood within its own banks, or had been only moderate in their reviling, it might have been overlooked. But they fly out into such extremity, on such small provocation, against their betters, as to call them idols, blind guides, despisers, generation of vipers, such as crucify Christ, men who serve their own lusts, hypocrites, the seed of the Devil, necromancers, Judases, men who live by blood, robbers and thieves, men without mercy, among whom justice is dumb, delighting in the kingdom of darkness and the devil, like Herod and Pilate in administering justice, whose eyes are dazzled with envy and ears open to lies, stout maintainers of the man of sin, whose ways are wicked and to be abhorred, worse than Indians, like dogs, and so on. This language speaks loudly of what country they belong to, and of what race they come.
Observations: Civil Power
If anyone should say on their behalf (as they themselves now do, for their own advantage) that this ill language is directed only against our particular government and magistrates, and not against all civil power itself, the contrary may appear in these particulars, notwithstanding their dark language, under which they sometimes seek to conceal it.
1. They expressly affirm that the office of ministering justice belongs only to the Lord. Therefore, they say (taking their instance from Herod), men make themselves gods by ruling over the bodies and estates of men; and this, as they themselves interpret it elsewhere, is only from the god of this world, and in flat opposition to God. They say that when the people received Herod to government and cried out that this was the ordinance of God and not of man, he was immediately struck by God for it. They also tell us that to set up men to judge of good and evil, which is what all men set up in that capacity are set up for, is re-enacting that ancient spirit of the Serpent: If ye eat, ye shall be as gods.
Now this strikes at all magistracy. For if the office of ministering justice and righteousness belongs to God only, then it belongs to no man, for that is to make gods of men. And if to judge between good and evil is to act over again the ancient spirit of the Serpent, then it is not only unlawful but diabolical to make any man a judge of what is right and wrong, good or evil.
Objection. Is it possible that any men should be so grossly blind and wicked as to abolish all ministration of justice and righteousness?
Answer. (1) These men seem to acknowledge some way of ministering justice, but the mystery lies in that word office. They would have no man set up in the office of magistracy, distinguished from other men, but would have such a power common to the brethren, so that a man may judge as a brother, but not as an officer. And therefore they slyly justify the man who, in the open face of the Court, called one of our chief magistrates Brother, and they condemn all our magistrates because not every man sits there to judge as a brother. Their reason seems to be drawn from this: that to be a brother, and consequently a co-heir with Christ, is a higher sphere than to be a civil officer, as their own words intimate. Now the rule of logic is plain, that what belongs to anything as such belongs to every instance of it. If the ministration of justice and judgment belongs to no officer, but to a man as a brother, then it belongs to every brother. And if to every brother, whether rich or poor, ignorant or learned, then every Christian in a commonwealth must be king, and judge, and sheriff, and captain, and member of Parliament, and ruler; and that not only in New England, but in Old, and not only in Old, but in all the Christian world. Down with all officers from their rule, and set up every brother to rule! The godly and wise may easily discern this to be the establishment of all confusion, and the setting up of an anarchy worse than the greatest tyranny.
(2) Although these men may make the world believe that they allow the ministration of justice and righteousness by men as brethren, yet some cakes of these men’s dough have been so far leavened and soured against all civil power that, when they were asked in our public courts how murderers, thieves and adulterers should be punished if there were no coercive civil power, they openly and bluntly answered before many witnesses that such persons must be left to the judgment of God. Not long afterward God himself sat as judge upon both of those who answered so: they were suddenly and barbarously slain by the bloody Indians in the Dutch plantation.
2. They exclaim against us for choosing men who are honorable, learned, wise, experienced and of good report, and for holding that otherwise they may not rule among us. This, they say, is of man and by man, and is putting the second witness to death, that is, the death or weakness of Christ; or, in plain English, it is a killing of Christ.
Now, however the application is made to our civil state, it manifestly strikes at all civil states in the world that choose any officers for rule and government and the administering of justice, even though those officers are as honorable, learned, wise, experienced and of good report as can be, and consequently most fit for government. And it says that in so choosing them they put Christ himself to death. So these men still harp on that string, to have every man judge as a brother, whether honorable or not honorable, whether wise or foolish, whether of good report or evil report; otherwise Christ’s weakness is slain.
3. They affirm that those who can create, make void and remove offices and officers at their pleasure are of that evil one (that is, the devil), and not of Jesus Christ, but of Shedim, that waster and destroyer of mankind forever. Their proof is drawn from that monstrous interpretation of “Yea, yea,” and “Nay, nay.” And they instance not only church officers but commonwealth officers, whether rulers or captains. Their words are these: “He with whom it is yea, I am a ruler, but it was nay when I was none at all, renounces the spirit of him that rules in righteousness, professing the spirit of him that is prince of the power of the air, who is working now so effectually in the children of disobedience. So also he with whom it is yea, I am captain, or chief slaughterman, but it was nay, time was that I was none at all, renounces the victory and slaughter made by the Captain and High Priest of our profession, professing himself to be a superfluous giant made in the host of the Philistines, to defy the host of the living God.”
By these speeches it is evident that they oppose not only the civil officers chosen among us here, but all who are chosen rulers, captains and officers, at any time and in any place, and who were not such before; and such, they say, are of the devil, the destroyer of man.
4. They say that men limit, and so destroy, the Holy One of Israel, whose life is infinite and without circumscription and containment (as they call it), if men acknowledge that Christ rules on earth only by his deputies, lieutenants and vicegerents, that is, by persons invested with civil authority and office, for so such persons are called by orthodox divines. And therefore they say that it is putting Christ to death when only wise, honorable, learned and experienced men of good report are chosen to rule. This is because they would have the power to rule common to all Christians, but the office of rule reserved to no one. And therefore they tell us that none shall see Christ come into his kingdom with comfort until the authority and power of man appears to be as the building of Babel, and the name and authority of God alone to be that in which the blessing consists. They mean that it is Babylonish building, which God disliked and confounded, for any man in office to rule and govern, because this is to limit the power and life of Christ (which is in every brother as well as in any officer), and so to kill the life of Christ.
So if any of them say that, although they dislike officers such as kings and others who come in by election, they do not dislike those who come in by hereditary succession, these are only words to suit their own ends for a time and to delude others. For if it is limiting the Holy One of Israel, and circumscribing and so destroying the life of Christ, which is infinite, to make him rule by his deputies and vicegerents on earth, then not only kings and princes, whether elected or not, but all other civil officers must be abandoned. For the life and power of Christ is limited in hereditary as well as in elective princes, in inferior as well as in superior governors, who are Christ’s deputies and vicegerents, and are therefore called in Romans 13:4 the ministers of God, either for good or for terror.
5. They call our General Court the Idol General, which, they say, is nothing else but a device of man, by the trickery of Satan, to subject and make slaves of that species or kind which God has honored with his own image. And they do not only speak thus of our courts as idols, but they cry out, Woe to the world because of its idols! For idols must needs be set up, but woe to them by whom they are erected. And their reason reaches to all civil power, for, they say, a man may as well be a slave to his belly and make that his god, as be a vassal to his own species or kind, or to anything that man can bring forth, even in his best perfection.
There are other evidences of their corrupt mind on this point in other passages of their letters, which they speak under more obscure clouds and allegories. But these may be a sufficient witness against them, before men and angels, that they abandon all civil authority, although, to serve their own turns with others or their own lusts, they say they do not. The apostle Jude long ago told us expressly of such persons, who despise dominion and speak evil of dignities. First, they do not only despise these or those particular persons or states that are invested with dominion, but they despise dominion itself and dignities themselves, and would have all that power abandoned. These he calls filthy dreamers, defiling the flesh (Jude 8), murmurers and complainers walking after their own lusts, their mouths speaking great swelling words (Jude 16).
And that it may appear still more fully that these men abandon all civil authority (although this secret they will not impart to all, but rather profess the contrary), there are writings in existence, to be shown if need be, between a prudent man in this country and one of the chief and most understanding of this peculiar fellowship (as they style themselves). In them this member of their fellowship stoutly maintains these three assertions: (1) that there are no ordinances; (2) that there are no relations, neither in the commonwealth between rulers and subjects, nor in the church between officers and brethren, nor in families between husband and wife, master and servant, father and son; (3) that there are no inherent graces in Christians.
By these principles the world may see what these men are about: as much as lies in them, to bring disorder and confusion into all states and families, and to open the sluice to all violence, injustice and wickedness. They do this by not only abandoning but reproaching and reviling all civil rule and authority on earth, which they therefore scornfully call a mere device of man and idols, and say is of the devil, the destroyer of mankind, and a crucifying of Christ in his life and death. And all this when honorable, wise, learned, experienced and well-reported persons are chosen and invested with civil power. Such persons, therefore, they would not have maintained; and for them, they say, it is as unlawful to administer any oath for the ending of civil differences as it is to lust after a woman to commit adultery.
Observations: Holy Things
1. Against the churches: they call them “devised platforms,” and say “that the wisdom of men is the whole accomplishment (or that which gives the whole being) of churches and commonwealth.”
2. Against the calling of ministers: they say “that to make their calling mediate and not immediate is to make a nullity of Christ, and to crucify Christ, and to put him to an open shame,” and “that such ministers are magicians.”
Now this casts reproach on all the ordinances and ordinary officers and ministers of Christ that either are or have been in the church at any time. For although the offices come directly from Christ, yet their call to exercise this office has always been held to come through men.
3. Against the word of God: they call the sermons of God’s ministers “tales,” or “lies and falsehoods.” Now if they had spoken this way upon proof against any particular sermons or persons, the accused might have spoken for themselves. But they revile all sermons without distinction as tales or forgeries. The doctrine generally taught here among us is no other than that which Paul preached at Ephesus for three years and more, namely, repentance toward God and faith toward the Lord Jesus (Acts 20). It is also no other than what agrees generally with the harmony of the confessions of all the Reformed churches. To call these tales is a word which the Lord Jesus will certainly remember unless they repent, for the sermons of the apostles of Christ, as well as the doctrine of all Reformed churches, are reproached by it.
4. Against the sacraments. First, as for baptism, they make not only the baptizing of infants but all our baptisms as abominable as the cross: “Behold,” they say, “the vanity and abomination of all your baptisms.” And they do not mean only all those baptisms that are in use among us, but those in any churches of the world at this day. For they acknowledge no baptism other than that which is spiritual. And so they say “that whenever you see the baptism of Christ truly in use according to the word of God, you do as truly see that party partaking and communicating with the cross and sufferings of Christ, for these are co-apparent.” Now communicating in Christ’s sufferings, in their meaning, is only spiritual, and therefore so are all baptisms.
Second, as for the Lord’s Supper, scarcely a greater heap of blasphemies in fewer words can come from the mouth of man against that blessed ordinance, in which Christ is so manifestly and sweetly present. For they call it “your dished-up dainties, turning the juice of a poor grape that perishes in the use of it into the blood of the Lord Jesus, by the cunning skill of your magicians, which does make mad and drunk so many in the world.”
5. Against repentance and humiliation for sin: here they speak somewhat obscurely, but those who know them may soon understand their meaning. Suppose it is this: that in the way of compunction and sorrow for sin a Christian is not to seek consolation and comfort from Christ, and that to do so is to make the Son of God Belial and Seghnirim, the Devil himself (as they interpret it). Then it is most gross blasphemy against not only the preaching but the practice of repentance and godly sorrow. The apostle rejoiced to see this sorrow in the Corinthians (2 Cor 7:9-10). James and Peter command and commend it (Jas 4:9-10; 1 Pet 5:6). And it is not Moses in the law so much as Christ in the gospel who has sanctified this way to find pardon of sin (1 John 1:9).
They also say, first, that our churches and commonwealth are formed out of the forbidden fruit, that is, man’s wisdom; second, that the whole edifice among us is raised up in the spirit of a hireling; and third, that by our submission to the word of God in fasting, feasting, withdrawing for study, contributing and storing up treasure (that is, for church uses, so much practiced in various churches), we do nothing but bring forth fruit unto death.
6. Against Christ Jesus himself: they condemn our doctrine for affirming that Jesus Christ actually died and suffered only in the days of Herod and Pontius Pilate, when he hung on the cross, and that he was crucified in truth and substance only when he appeared, born of the Virgin Mary. And for this doctrine we are condemned as wizards and necromancers.
Now what is this but to overthrow not only the being of Christ in the flesh, making him no other than one who actually suffered from the beginning of the world and shall do so to the end of it, but also to overthrow all faith and hope of salvation in that Messiah who was incarnate in the days of Herod and Pilate, and in his death and sufferings, and in that one perfect offering made then, once for all (Heb 10:14)?
The reader may therefore please take notice of this. When they were asked in open court what that Christ was who was born of the Virgin and suffered under Pilate, one of them answered that he was “a semblance, picture, or a shadow of what was and is done actually and substantially in Christians.” From this the meaning of their words may be gathered, which otherwise the wise reader might think to be nonsense, namely, “that they are wizards and necromancers who raise a shadow without a substance (that is, to make Christ to be slain in types since the world began), or who raise the substance of him who dwells in light without a shadow” (making no more of Christ than a semblance and shadow, as they themselves call it).
For further explanation of this, they affirmed in open court “that as the image of God in Adam was Christ” (for God, they said, had but one image), “so the loss of this image by man was the death of Christ.” And therefore it is no wonder if they deny that Christ died actually only when he was crucified under Pontius Pilate, because man sinned actually (which they make to be Christ’s death) long before. Meanwhile the reader may take notice, with a holy astonishment and horror, of the heavy curse of God in blinding these bold men with such a palpable and gross spirit of delusion and such mad frenzies. They will make man’s sin and fall, which is the cause of the perdition of men, to be the cause of the salvation of man. For that is what Christ’s death is, and they blasphemously make man’s sin to be Christ’s death.
For further proof that they make no more use of Christ and his death than has been said, their own interpretation of the slaying of the two witnesses seems to confirm it. For they make these two witnesses the life and the death of Christ in men. The life of Christ they call his strength, and the death of Christ they call his weakness, namely as it is and appears in weak, foolish, ignorant, inexperienced and ill-reported men. And therefore they blame us for killing Christ’s death (for it seems it is such a death as may be killed), in that we choose honorable, wise, learned men, and men of good report, for places of rule, excluding others.
Now some of these blasphemies might have been the better borne if they had let Christ and his death alone, and his word alone. But they call the holy word and sermons of salvation “tales”; they call the sacrament an abomination, maddening the world and making it drunk; they call the ministers of Christ who dispense word and sacraments necromancers and magicians; and they call those who hold and believe him who suffered under Pilate to be the Messiah and Christ, wizards. And they do all this in cold blood, in the open face of the court, obstinately refusing to alter a tittle of what they had written. Let the world judge whether Antichrist, that beast spoken of in Revelation 13:5-6, ever spoke greater blasphemies against God, his name, and tabernacle, and whether such men deserve to live who live thus to blaspheme. May not civil states that tolerate such men fear that sentence of God against them which was pronounced against Ahab for letting blasphemous Benhadad escape with his life, “thy life for his life” (1 Kgs 20:42)?
However far men’s charity may enlarge itself this way, yet let wisdom preserve us, and make the wise-hearted wary of such impostors. They do not lack their wiles to say and unsay as may best suit their advantage. For they can hold forth wholesome and orthodox truths at some times and to some persons, and lead them to believe that this is all they hold. But they have depths of abomination to give them to drink in such golden cups when they see their opportunity. They have hidden secrets which their young proselytes shall not see at once, much less others. For so they tell us “that it is not their purpose to open to every one the house of their treasures, the silver and gold, and spices, and precious ointment, nor the house of their armor, because they may take them all as execrable and put them to a profane use; nor can every spirit comprehend the breadth of the land of Emmanuel” (as they call it elsewhere), “nor know the cherubim of glory, nor the voice of the oracle from the mercy seat.” And indeed their uncouth, tumorous and swelling words (as Jude calls them, Jude 16), like swellings and tumors of the flesh, are the undoubted signs of a secret and seducing humor, by which they are fit to deceive the simple and infect the strong, if men are not watchful.
The Publisher to the Reader
The reason nothing is said here in reply to the great charge in his voluminous Postscript is that it has already been answered in a treatise printed earlier. But the chief reason is that many of the friends, children and kindred of the dead are held in good esteem among us, and I am unwilling to grieve them.
Next in order, gentle reader, you will turn your eye to the substance of a presentment which the Court at Rhode Island received from its grand jury. The jurors had been present when Samuel Gorton had so much abused their government in the face of the country, and in open court at that, so that their own eyes and ears bore witness to it. They, I say, presented these abuses to the Court as such as they judged could not be tolerated without ruin to their government. They therefore begged the bench to consider some punishment to be inflicted on the offender, for the sake of example as well as for other reasons.
So that you may see what gave rise to it, note that an elderly woman had a cow grazing in the field where Samuel Gorton had some land. When this woman went to fetch out her cow, Gorton’s servant girl fell violently on her, beating and grossly abusing her and tearing her hair about her head. The old woman complained to the deputy governor of the place. He sent for the girl, heard the case, and bound her over to the Court.
When the time came and the Court sat, Gorton appeared himself in his servant’s defense. He would not allow her to appear or make answer, but said expressly that she would not appear, and that if they had anything against her they should proceed with him. Some of the bench kindly tried to persuade him not to involve himself but to let his servant appear, yet he refused. When he could not be prevailed on, the action was called, and witnesses were produced, sworn and examined. That done, he moved for another witness to be called, a woman whom he believed, and the bench believed, to be honest and one who would speak the truth. Once sworn, she said, “Mr. Gorton, I can say nothing that will help your servant.” And indeed her whole testimony went against the girl and for the old woman’s case. At this he said openly, “Take heed, you wicked woman, that the earth does not open and swallow you up.”
Then he demanded of the Court whether he would have equity and justice in his case or not. The answer was that if he had any plea or evidence to produce in his servant’s case, it would be heard. He then named one Weekes, who could say something to the matter. Weekes was called and required to take his oath before he spoke. At this Gorton and Weekes both jeered and laughed, and told the Court they were skilled in idols and that this was one, and they stood stoutly to it for a long time. At this some of the Court reminded him how they had warned him beforehand against such behavior, fearing he would fall into some extremes.
At length the governor summed up what had been witnessed and committed it to the jury. At that point Gorton said the Court had perverted justice and twisted the witnesses, with a great many lofty and abusive terms. In the midst of his violence, throwing his hands about, he touched the deputy governor about the ears with the buttons of his handkerchief (it seems the deputy was sitting at a table with his back to him). The deputy said, “What, will you fall about my ears?” Gorton answered, “I do not know whether you have any ears or not. And if you have, I do not know where they stand. But I will not touch them with a pair of tongs.”
The governor repeatedly called on the jury to attend to the case, and was as repeatedly interrupted by him. At this many of their freemen who were present asked the Court not to put up with such insolence, declaring they were troubled that the Court had borne with them so long. For this, in brief, he was committed to custody. But when the governor told the marshal to take him away, he told the marshal to take away Coddington, which was their governor’s name. I thought it fitting to explain this, in case you should not understand it from the heads of the presentment that follows, which show him abusing each and every one of the magistrates in opprobrious terms.
Note, too, that when he was committed for his mutinous and seditious speeches, Weekes, Holden and the rest of his abettors blocked the way with such insolence that the governor was forced to rise from the bench and help carry out the order in person. In clearing the way he put Weekes in the stocks, and was forced to call out a guard of armed men to protect themselves and the peace of the place. They did this because of some earlier suspicions. Now, taking the occasion to search the houses of the party that stood with him, they found many of their guns loaded with shot. Because of this they were forced to keep their guard in place until, upon their banishment, these men were forced off the island.
It would take a whole book to relate every particular of his insolent behavior, but take note of only two or three.
1. When he was sentenced to be whipped and banished, he appealed to England. They asked, “To whom?” He said in a loud voice, “To King Charles.” They told him he would first receive his punishment, and afterward he might complain. To this he replied, “Take notice, I appeal to King Charles, Caelo, or Selah.” The man who was present told me he could not tell which of the two it was, but that the word was spoken in an extraordinarily high and loud voice.
2. After he had been so deservedly whipped, some of his faction said, “Now Christ Jesus had suffered.”
3. Although the weather was very cold, when the governor was going away after justice had been carried out on him, he ran a good way after the governor, dragging a chain on one of his legs, the upper part of his body still naked, and told the governor that he had only lent Gorton this, and would surely have it back again.
All this I had from a man of very good reputation who lived among them at the time and was an eye and ear witness to all these proceedings.
Next, good reader, take note that when he left that place well whipped, as I have said, and began his banishment, the place he went to (in a harsh season) was a town called Providence, where Mr. Roger Williams and various others lived. Because of the season, they received them with great kindness and courtesy. But the Gortonians repaid it all like Aesop’s snake, as you may read in the several letters of the chief inhabitants of that place. They raised a notorious faction there as well, to the great distraction and dismay of the inhabitants, as their sorrowful complaints in their own letters make plain. I present to you a true copy of them.
Testimonies Against Gorton
The Grand Jury’s Presentment of Gorton at Portsmouth
1. That Samuel Gorton, some days before his appearance at this court, said that the government was such as was not to be submitted to, because it had no true derivation, since it was altered from what it first was.
2. That Samuel Gorton insolently reproached the magistrates, calling them “Just Asses.”
3. That the said Gorton reproachfully called the judges, or some of the justices on the bench, “corrupt judges” in open court.
4. That the said Gorton called the court to account for making him wait on them two days previously, and said that now he would know whether he was to be tried in a hostile way, or by law, or in sobriety.
5. The said Gorton alleged in open court that he regarded the magistrates as lawyers, and he called Mr. Easton “Lawyer Easton.”
6. The said Gorton charged the deputy governor with being an abettor of a riot, assault, or battery, and declared that he would not touch him, no, not with a pair of tongs. Moreover he said, “I do not know whether you have any ears or not,” and also, “I think you do not know where your ears stand.” And he charged him with being a man unfit to make a warrant.
7. The said Gorton charged the bench with twisting the testimony, in these words: “I profess you wrest witness.”
8. The said Gorton called a freeman in open court “saucy boy” and “jackanapes,” and said that the woman who was under oath would not speak against her mother, even if she were damned where she stood.
9. The said Gorton affirmed that Mr. Easton did not behave himself like a judge, and that he himself was charged either basely or falsely.
10. The said Gorton said to the bench, “You intrude oaths, and go about to catch me.”
11. The said Gorton, being reproved for his misconduct, held up his hand and, with the most extreme speech, shook his hand at them, so that the freemen present said, “He threatens the court.”
12. The said Gorton charged the court with acting the second part of the Plymouth magistrates, who, as he said, condemned him in the chimney corner before they heard him speak.
13. The said Gorton declared in open court that he would maintain the quarrel of another, namely his maidservant.
14. The said Gorton, being ordered to prison, imperiously resisted the authority and made open proclamation, saying, “Take away Coddington, and carry him to prison.” The governor said in reply, “All you that own the King, take away Gorton and carry him to prison.” Gorton replied, “All you that own the King, take away Coddington, and carry him to prison.”
William Dyer, Secretary.
Roger Williams’s Letter to Mr. Winthrop Concerning Gorton
Providence, the 1st of the 8th month, 1640.
Mr. Gorton, having foully abused high and low at Aquidneck, is now bewitching and bemadding poor Providence. He does it both with his unclean and foul censures of all the ministers of this country (for which I myself have withstood him in Christ’s name), and also by denying all visible and external ordinances, in the depth of Familism. Against this I have disputed and written a little, and shall, the Most High assisting, to the death. As Paul said of Asia, so I say of Providence: almost all suck in his poison, as at first they did at Aquidneck.
A few others and I oppose his admission as an inhabitant, and to the privileges of the town, without his confession and reformation of his uncivil and inhuman practices at Portsmouth. Yet the tide is too strong against us, and I fear (if the Framer of hearts does not help) it will force me to little Patience, a little isle next to your Prudence. May Jehovah himself be pleased to be a sanctuary to all whose hearts are perfect with him. In him I unfeignedly desire to be
Your Worship’s true and affectionate,
Roger Williams.
A Letter from the Inhabitants of Providence
Providence, this 17th of November, 1641.
To the Honored Governor of Massachusetts, together with the Worshipful Assistants, and our loving neighbors there.
We the inhabitants of the town above named, having fair occasion, have thought it fit and necessary to give you true intelligence of the insolent and riotous conduct of Samuel Gorton and his company, who came from the island of Aquidneck and still continue as sojourners among us. With them are John Greene and Francis Weston, two who have long stood in opposition against us, and against the fairest, most just and honest ways of proceeding in order and government that we could rightly and truly use for the peaceable preservation and quiet subsistence of ourselves and our families, or of any who should have fair occasion to go out or come in among us. Also six or seven of our townsmen, who were in peaceable covenants with us, now cut themselves off from us by their declarations, and have jointly, under their hands, openly proclaimed that they take the side of the aforenamed companies. And so they intend, for anything we can gather, to have no manner of honest order or government, either over them or among them, as their writings, words, and actions most plainly show.
It would be tedious to relate the numberless number of their upbraiding taunts, assaults, and threats, and the violent kind of conduct they daily practice against all who, either with care or with counsel, seek to stop or withstand their wicked, licentious courses. Yet to commit a few of them briefly to your moderate judgments, lest we ourselves should be thought in some way blinded in the occurrences of things, here enclosed is a true copy of their writing, which Francis Weston gave us on the 13th of this present month. They also set up a copy of the same on a tree in the street. This writing was given instead of satisfaction for fifteen pounds, which the said Francis Weston was found liable to pay, or to make satisfaction in cattle or commodities, by way of arbitration by eight men orderly chosen, with all the causes and reasons that could be found duly and truly examined and considered jointly together.
But on the 15th of this present month we went orderly, openly, and in a warrantable way to attach some of the said Francis Weston’s cattle and drive them to the pound, to make him, if it were possible, make satisfaction. Samuel Gorton and his company, getting notice of this, came and quarreled with us in the street and made a tumultuous hubbub. For our part we had beforehand armed ourselves above all with patience, to suffer peaceably as much injury as could possibly be borne, to avoid all shedding of blood; and yet a few drops of blood were shed on either side.
And after the tumult was partly calmed, and we went on in orderly fashion into the cornfield to drive the said cattle, the said Francis Weston came running furiously with a flail in his hand, and cried out, “Help, sirs, help, sirs, they are going to steal my cattle!” And he kept on crying so until Randall Holden, John Greene, and some others came running and made a great outcry, hollering and crying, “Thieves, thieves! Stealing cattle, stealing cattle!” And so the whole number of their desperate company came riotously running, and with much striving in the driving they hurried away the cattle. Then they presumptuously answered that they had made a rescue, and that such would be their practice if any men, at any time, in any case, attached anything that is theirs.
To relate fully even the least part of their words and actions of this kind, the time and paper would scarcely be profitably spent. Nor need we advise your discretions what the sad outcome of these disorders is likely to be, if their bloody currents are not either stopped or turned some other way. For it is plain to us that if men continue to resist all manner of order, and the orderly answering of one another in cases of difference, they will soon practice not only cunningly keeping things back from one another, but also openly and publicly taking whatever they can come by, in a disorderly way, justly or unjustly, according to their own wills. First they will plead necessity, or the maintenance of wife and family; but afterward they will boldly maintain licentious lust. Like savage brute beasts, they will put no manner of difference between houses, goods, lands, wives, lives, blood; nor will anything be precious in their eyes.
If it may therefore please you, of gentle courtesy and for the preservation of humanity and mankind, to consider our condition and lend us a neighborly helping hand, and to send us such assistance (our necessity urging us to be troublesome to you) as will help us bring them to satisfaction and ease us of our burden of them, at your discretion, we shall evermore acknowledge it as a deed of great charity. We shall take it very thankfully, labor diligently in the best measure we can, and constantly endeavor to repay your loving kindness, if you should have occasion to command us, or any of us, in any lawful design. And if it pleases you to send us a speedy answer, we shall take it very kindly, and be ready and willing to satisfy the messengers, and ever remain
Your loving neighbors and respectful friends,
Joshua Winsor, Benedict Arnold, William Mean, William Hawkins, Robert West, William Field, William Harris, William Wickenden, William Reynolds, Thomas Harris, Thomas Hopkins (his mark), Hugh Bennit, William Carpenter.
William Arnold’s Letter to the Five Men of Providence
Providence, the 25th of the 3rd month, 1641.
To the rest of the five men appointed to manage the affairs of our town aforesaid.
This is further to give you to understand that I not only approve of what my neighbors before me have written, directing their reasons to a serious consideration with us concerning Samuel Gorton and his company, but I also say this much: it is evident, and may easily be proved, that neither the said Samuel Gorton nor his company are fit persons to be received in and made members of such a body, in so weak a state as our town is in at present.
My reasons are these.
First, Samuel Gorton has shown himself a railing and turbulent person, not only in and against those states of government from which he came, as is to be proved, but also here in this town since he has sojourned here. Witness his proud challenge, and his upbraiding accusations in vilifying and opprobrious terms of and against a member of our town compact. He most wrathfully and shamelessly reviled him, disturbed him, and meddled with him while he was employed and busy about other private business, having no just cause so to revile and abuse him. He also said to him, in a base manner (and that concerning another state), that they were like swine that held out their noses to suck his blood, and that now he and the rest of his company would go and wallow in it too. These are indeed insufferable words. He also spitefully called him “Boy,” as though he would have challenged him to the field. Such inhuman behavior does not befit a man who should be thought fit, by any reasonable men, to be received into such a poor, weak state as we are in at present.
Secondly, another of his company, one who is much esteemed by him, behaved openly in a scornful and deriding manner. Seeing one of the five men chosen by the town and entrusted with the town’s affairs coming toward him in the street, he asked someone who stood by him who that was. The other answered him that it was one of the five men appointed for managing our town’s affairs, or words to that effect. “Yes,” said he, “he looks like one of the five.” These words import not only a scorning and deriding of the person of whom he then spoke, but also a despising and scorning of our civil state, as it were trampling it underfoot, as they had done to other states before they came here, states of greater strength than we are. For this reason I cannot see such persons to be fit to be received into such a state as our town is.
Thirdly, I cannot find these men to be reasonable men in their suit to the town to be received in as townsmen. They have already had a plain denial of their request, and that by the consent of the major part of the town, or very nearly, etc., and still they will not accept that answer. Their coming to our town, too, has thrown the town into an uproar, almost the one half against the other, a condition in which no town or city can well stand or subsist. This declares plainly to us that their intent is not good. Their staying so long here among us is in hope of getting the victory over one part of the town, and especially over those who laid the first foundation of the place and bought it almost with the loss of their lives and their whole estates; and afterward of trampling them under their feet, as some of their words hold forth, or else of driving them out into the same condition, to seek out a new Providence and buy it with the same hardship with which they first bought this place. These and many other like reasons that may be shown declare that they are not fit persons to be received into our humble and weak state.
Fourthly, he is so well known to be the ringleader in the breach of peace, and has been so notoriously evil as to be a trouble to the civil states where he has lived, states of far greater force than we are, especially that state which has its commission and authority from the higher powers. What then may we expect if he could get himself in with and among so many as we see are daily ready to tread us under their feet, and among those of his whom he calls friends, etc.? Surely, first a breach of our civil peace, and next the ruin of all such as are not on his side, as their daily practice declares. Therefore they are not fit persons to be received into our town, etc.
Objection. It may be objected, as some have blasphemously said, that we are persecutors, and persecute the saints, in not receiving them into our town fellowship, etc.
Answer. To this I answer that not the least show of any persecution of those persons can be proved, either by us or by any other among us, to our knowledge. For (1) they have quiet abode among us, with no one molesting or troubling them or anything they have. (2) It cannot be proved, except by their own report, which has been disproved, that they were sent out for religion from the places they came from; nor are they meddled with here for any such matter. Rather, they themselves in their bravado are more ready to meddle with others. (3) They themselves and others of their followers have rather been troublers and persecutors of the saints of God who lived here before they came, and are only waiting for their opportunity to make themselves manifest in what they intend. Therefore it cannot truly be said of anyone that any persecution is offered to them by us, even if it could possibly be said of them that they are saints.
Objection. But it may be further objected, as some have said, that we do not give them the liberty of men, nor show them the compassion of mercy by giving them the means of livelihood among us.
Answer. To this I say: (1) There is no state but will in the first place seek to preserve its own safety and peace. (2) We cannot give land to any person by virtue of our combination unless we first receive them into our state of combination, which we cannot do with them, for the sake of our own and others’ peace, etc. (3) Whereas their necessity has been so much pleaded, it is not known that they ever sought to find out a place where they might accommodate themselves and live by themselves, with their friends and such as will follow after them, where they may use their liberty to live without order or control, and not trouble us, who have taken that same course for our safety and peace. That course they neither approve nor like. They would rather, like beasts in the shape of men, do whatever they think fit in their own eyes, and they will not be governed by any state. And seeing they only linger out the time here in hope of winning the day, to make up their pennyworths by gaining advantage over us, we have just cause to hear the complaints of so many of our neighbors who live orderly in the town among us and have brought in their complaints, with many reasons against them. We have just cause not to admit them, but to answer them as persons unfit to be received into our humble state, etc.
Now if these reasons, and much more that has been truly said of them, do not satisfy you and the rest of our neighbors, but they must be received into our town state, even to our utter overthrow, etc., then according to the order agreed upon by the town, I first offer my house and land within the bounds of the town to the town, to buy it from me; or else I may, and shall, take liberty to sell it to whomever I can, for my own advantage, etc.
William Arnold.
Winslow’s Answer to Gorton
When I first agreed to the country’s request that I come over to answer the complaints of Samuel Gorton and his company, and to give an account of the just and righteous proceedings of the country of New England, in its several parts, against him, I little thought then that I would appear in print. Gorton has been a common disturber of the peace of every society he came into: witness, first, New Plymouth; second, Rhode Island; third, Providence; and lastly Massachusetts, the most eminent of them.
But when I came into England I found a book written by Mr. Gorton called Simplicity’s Defence against Seven-Headed Policy; or, A True Complaint of a Peaceable People, Being Part of the English in New England, Made unto the State of Old England, against Cruel Persecutors United in Church Government in Those Parts. I then considered myself bound in duty to remove the many gross and public scandals it puts forward. They have caused great amazement to many tender consciences in the kingdom who are not acquainted with his proud and turbulent conduct, and who do not see the lion under his lambskin coat of simplicity and peace.
The Lord knows how unwilling I was to engage in this personally. And I trust he will also guide me in answering Gorton’s book, so that I will be far from bitterness. It is true that there was a time when his person was precious in my eyes. Therefore I hope and desire only to make a righteous and just defense against the many unworthy things he has published, boldly, ignorantly, proudly and falsely, to the great dishonor of God, wronging and slandering his churches. The Lord Jesus Christ will not leave that unpunished.
I know the world is full of controversies, and it is my great grief to see my dear native country so engaged in them, especially one godly person against another. It is my present comfort that I do not come to accuse anyone, but to defend New England against the injurious complaints of Samuel Gorton and his company. Yet it often happens that men unavoidably wound others in defending themselves from the violent assaults of those who draw on them, which otherwise they would never have done. So if Mr. Gorton receives any such hurt (which cannot be avoided), he is an accessory to it, by forcing me to defend the country. If I did not, I would be unfaithful.
I know the world is too full of books of this kind. Therefore, although I am here without many things that I have, or could procure, at home, which would serve well for an account of the recent and present state of New England, I shall now only give answer, as briefly as may be, to the injurious complaints he makes of us. And though his title, his preface and every leaf of his book may justly be found fault with, I shall answer clearly to matters of fact, such as he charges the several governments with. In this way any impartial reader may easily discern how grossly we are abused, and how just and righteous the sentences against him were for disturbing the civil peace of every society he came into, in such a manner as no government could possibly bear. As for the blasphemies for which he was proceeded against in Massachusetts, they came in incidentally, by his own doing, without anything else leading to them.
And first, he accuses us, on the first page of his book, of going over to “suppress heretics.” It is well known that we went there for no such end, and we never declared any such end. We went to enjoy those liberties which the Lord Jesus Christ had left to his church, so as to escape the episcopal tyranny and the heavy burdens the bishops imposed. To those sufferings the kingdom, by this ever-to-be-honored Parliament, has borne and does bear witness, as religious and just. And we went so that we might also hold forth that truth and ancient way of God in which we walk, which Mr. Gorton calls heresy.
Next, on the same page, he charges us with “affectation of titles” and so on. To this I answer: either we must live without government, or, if we have governors, we must give those we so call such titles as suit the offices and places they hold in church and commonwealth: governors and assistants, pastors, teachers, rulers, deacons, and the like. These are the highest titles we give.
On his second page he charges Massachusetts with uniting with other colonies “to the end they might bathe themselves in blood and feed themselves fat with the lives of their brethren,” and so on. This is a notorious slander. It is true that Massachusetts, New Plymouth, Connecticut and New Haven (I mean the several colonies there) entered into a civil combination and are called by the name of the United Colonies. This was brought about by a general conspiracy of the Indians against the whole body of the English settled there, together with the troubled condition of England, from which we could expect no help at that time.
But at that very time Mr. Gorton and his company fell into more than ordinary familiarity with the Narragansett Indians, who were the principal contrivers of the villainy. Where they could not draw others to their side by force or flattery, they did it by large gifts and the like. I could prove this by many testimonies of Indians living many hundreds of miles apart from each other. And in that design, had not the finger of God in great mercy prevented it, I would have been the first to fall. But I forbear to relate that here, since what I am doing now is only an answer to his invective.
Next, on the same page, he tells us that on his landing he found “his countrymen at great variance at Boston in point of religion.” But if he had not helped to blow the bellows, the flame might never have been so great.
And he says that Mr. Williams was banished from there for differing from us, though he was a man of good report, and so on. In answer, first take notice of this. I know that Mr. Williams (though a man lovely in his conduct, and one whom I trust the Lord will yet bring back) held forth in those times the unlawfulness of our letters patent from the King, and so on. He would not approve of our nation’s flag. He denied the lawfulness of a public oath, as being needless for the saints and a profanation of God’s name if tendered to the wicked, and so on. And truly I never heard that he was dealt with for anything but these and similar points. I am sorry, for the love I bear to him and his, that I am forced to mention it; but God calls me at this time to clear away these aspersions.
On page 3 he mentions the proceedings of Massachusetts against Mr. John Wheelwright and others. I could wish, had it been the will of God, that those differences had never arisen. But the main difference concerned a petition in the form of a remonstrance, which the government took as very offensive. But Mr. Wheelwright and they are reconciled, he having given satisfaction, and so on.
On the same page he wrongs the doctrine of our churches, which is well known to be sound. But he also tells us on the same page of their being denied “cohabitation,” and of “whippings, confinement, imprisonment, chains, fines, banishment.” I confess all these things befell him, and most justly. For he was bound over for his good behavior at Plymouth and broke his bonds in the face of the court. He was whipped and banished at Rhode Island for mutiny and sedition in the open court there. He was also factious at Providence, though his party grew greater than Mr. Williams’s better party, as appears by the sad letters of Mr. Williams and his party to the government of Massachusetts for help and advice. And afterward he was banished from Massachusetts. All this appears in another place of this book, with the just causes of their proceedings annexed to it.
Lastly, on this page, he tells us of the hardship which he and the rest of his mutinous companions, such as Weekes, Holden and others, endured for several nights together. That was just in the sight of God and man, for extreme evils must have extreme remedies. And yet it is well known that it is not a full day’s journey from Rhode Island to Providence. And though a stranger would think he was forced at that time to go to Narragansett Bay among the Indians, he did not leave Providence until they were as weary of these mutineers as either Plymouth or Rhode Island had been before them.
And because he often mentions the hard measure he received at Plymouth, and keeps presenting it as if difference in religion had been the ground of it, I thought it good to let the reader understand here what the ground of his troubles there was, so that all men may know what religion this man is of: for the tree is best known by its fruit.
The first complaint that came against him, for which he was brought before the authorities, was made by Mr. Ralph Smith, a minister. Mr. Smith, being acquainted with Gorton, received him and his family into his house with much humanity and Christian respect, promising him as free use of it as he had himself, and so on. But Mr. Gorton became troublesome. Means were used to remove the offenses Mr. Smith had taken, but to no purpose, and he grew still more insolent. So Mr. Smith asked him to provide for himself elsewhere. But Gorton refused, saying he had as good an interest in the house as Mr. Smith had. And when he was brought before the authorities, he stood stoutly to maintain it, to our amazement. But he was ordered to leave and make other arrangements by an appointed time.
Not long after, a woman of his acquaintance came to Plymouth, and several people came to the Governor with complaints against her, she being a stranger, for unworthy and offensive speeches and behavior. Thereupon the Governor sent to her to learn her business, and so on, and commanded her to depart. He ordered the seaman who had brought her to take her back to the place she came from on his next voyage there. But Gorton said she should not go, for he had use for her, and so on.
Thereupon the Governor (it being during a session of the court) sent for him. Gorton had hidden her, stood in justification of what he had done, and refused to obey the command of the court, which had seconded the Governor’s order. So he was committed until he could procure sureties for his good behavior until the next court, which was a General Court, where he was to answer for this contempt.
When the time came and the court sat, Gorton was called. But the Governor, being weary from speaking to other cases, asked one of his Assistants, who had been present at his commitment and knew the whole matter, to declare it. This Assistant had no sooner stood up to show the country why Gorton was under bond, namely the great affront he had given the government, than Gorton stretched out his hand toward the Assistant’s face and said with a loud voice, “If Satan will accuse the brethren, let him come down from Jehoshua’s right hand and stand here.” And that done, he turned himself in a seditious manner to the people, with his arms spread wide, and said, “You see, good people, how you are abused! Stand for your liberty, and let them not be parties and judges,” with many other abusive speeches of that kind.
Thereupon several elders of churches who were present, asking leave of the Governor to speak, complained of his seditious conduct and requested the court not to tolerate these abuses but to inflict the punishment they deserved. And yet, notwithstanding all this, all we did to him was to take the forfeit of his bonds for good behavior. Indeed, since he was low and poor in his estate, we took no more than eight or ten pounds of it, lest it lie too heavily upon his wife and children.
But he had either to get new sureties for his behavior until the next General Court, or until such time as he left the jurisdiction, or else lie in prison until he could. Now he, knowing his outrageous passions, which he could not restrain, procured sureties but immediately left Plymouth and went to Rhode Island. There, upon complaining of our persecutions, he found immediate relief. Yet soon afterward he abused them in a greater measure, and had a heavier, yet too light, punishment inflicted on him. And all this was for breach of the civil peace and notorious contempt of authority, without the least mention of any points of religion on the government’s part, just as before.
On page 4 Mr. Gorton further accuses us that they were deprived of and taken away from their quiet possessions, and so on. His conduct at Plymouth and at Providence, when he first settled there, was such that neither of the governments dared to admit or receive him to live among them, but refused him as a pest to all societies.
Again, on the same page, he accuses Massachusetts and Plymouth of having denied that Gorton’s company were within our government, “but when we perceived the place to be a refuge for such as were oppressed, then,” and so on. It is true that Plymouth allowed Mr. Williams and his company to settle at Providence, and has never molested them to this day. But it refused Gorton and Weekes and the rest, upon Weekes’s solicitation when I was at Providence, for the reasons mentioned before, and so on.
As for the particular stories he tells of Robert Cole, William Arnold, and Benedict his son, I pass them over, since I am not well acquainted with their cases; but I see he writes with a venomous pen. Only take notice that he would make it a great crime in them to trade on the Sabbath (as indeed it is), when he himself at that time denied the keeping of it holy.
On page 5 he complains that gunpowder was traded to the Indians and denied to Gorton’s company.
Answer. If it was traded to the Indians, for my part I do not approve of it, since it is against the express law of the country, and a large penalty is attached. But there was good reason to refuse it to people who held such familiarity with malignant Indians, especially during the time of their confederacy against us.
On page 6 he speaks as if he had been under some sentence of Massachusetts at the time of the warrant he specifies there. How truly it is copied I do not know; but I am sure that at that time he was personally under no sentence of theirs.
On page 7 he accuses magistrates and ministers of bringing in all the accusations that came in against them. Who but public persons should take notice of public insolence? And as for Mr. Collins’s story, I know nothing of it, but I believe it is misreported, like the others.
On page 8 he declares that he dared not live under a foreign prince, meaning the Dutch, having never been false to his King and country, and so on, with many ignorant, swelling words; as if it were treason against one’s prince to live under a foreign state, even an ally. And on the same page he would lay the death of Mrs. Hutchinson, who was mother-in-law to Mr. Collins, on us. Yet they went to the Dutch not from Massachusetts but from Rhode Island, which is not under Massachusetts and where she had lived some years after her removal from the Bay; and she went of her own accord. There they were killed by the Indians.
On page 9 he shows how they bought lands from Miantonomo, prince of those parts.
Answer. First, he was not the prince of that part, as was proved publicly in Massachusetts, he himself being present. Second, he had no proper right to it, as is shown in full elsewhere.
On the same page he begins a long letter full of railing blasphemies, which continues to page 31. And though it is not set down exactly as it was sent, yet I wonder at God’s providence: for Gorton has fallen into the snare he laid. This letter was brought against him to accuse him of blasphemy before a Committee of Parliament, who called in his book and referred him to the House, and so on. But I forbear to show his folly here, since that is referred to another place, and his wickedness is revealed there.
On page 32 he says the government of Massachusetts had no pretext for anything against them but religion. And yet the whole matter, as told in his own way as well as in what we now print, shows that it was done on behalf of two Indian sachems, namely Pumham and Socononoco. They placed themselves under the protection of Massachusetts and complained of violence offered them by Mr. Gorton and his company. For it is our practice, in capital and criminal cases alike, to do them the same justice we do one another; and when we walk by the same rules of righteousness toward them, they have the less cause to take offense at us.
From page 33 onward there are many letters, and I cannot believe all that is in them. Therefore I remain suspicious of his honesty in printing them.
On page 37 he puts forward conversion as the reason Massachusetts sent men to them; to that end, he says, they sent a minister. It is true that there was a gracious young man, one Mr. John Bulkley, then a student but in no ministry, who went to teach the company they sent to guard their own commissioners and to bring in Gorton if need required. But I dare not believe what he affirms. And as for the copy of a letter that he fathers on the commissioners sent by the government of Massachusetts, I conclude that it is set down from memory rather than accurately. For I have by me some attestations, to make use of elsewhere, which seem to hold forth the contrary; and so I do not credit it.
On pages 38 and 39 he relates how their wives were frightened by men leveling their muskets at them, and so on, and suffered such hardships as caused death, and so on. This also must be false, for honest men have sworn that there was no such leveling of muskets, and that their wives came freely and familiarly to them, both before and after they were taken. So also he affirms that our men would allow no parley except in private, or else they would dispatch them within a quarter of an hour. I will never believe this, because I know the men to be men who fear God, who dared not proceed as he relates.
On pages 40 and 41 he also charges the commissioners and soldiers with breaking covenants during the treaty, “as, breaking open their houses, desks, killing their cattle,” and so on. All of this is false, for oath has been made to the contrary, which I shall make use of in due time and place before my Lord of Warwick, Governor in Chief, and the rest of the honorable Committee for Foreign Plantations. The oath is that, whereas by agreement they were to have two houses for their company, which was about forty men, they used only one, and did none of the things laid to their charge.
On page 45 he would make Pumham and Socononoco the natural subjects of Miantonomo, their prince; but this was disproved. And on the same page he says that the magistrates suggested to the people that there was “fear of some combination between the Indians and them.”
Answer. I dare not say that you had a hand in the depths of their conspiracy. But this, I think, you dare not deny: that Weekes, one of your boldest champions, lent Miantonomo a suit of armor, in which he was taken in battle against Uncas, who was under the protection of the English United Colonies; and for this Uncas put him to death. And in your own book you show more familiarity with them than becomes you.
But here it will be necessary for me to show you the ground of this war. There was a people called the Pequots, a bold, warlike people, who had been at war with the Narragansetts for many years and were too strong for them. They were also somewhat estranged from this Uncas, who was sachem of a people called the Mohegans, near the head of a river that falls into the sea at Pequot. The chief sachem of this people of Pequot was called Tatobam, a bold man. The Narragansetts and these Pequots strove over which should be greatest.
This Tatobam envied the English, and was the first stirrer and contriver of this general plot, that they might all join together to destroy the English. But the Narragansetts refused to join with them, knowing that if that were once done, the next ruin must be their own. Afterward, when the Pequots had subdued many small peoples and one as great as themselves, and some English had settled nearer to them than the main body of our plantations (though without wrong to Tatobam or to any of his people), he attacked Captain Stone’s bark and killed its company, and after this killed several straggling English.
This stirred up the English to take revenge. The Narragansetts, and Uncas, sachem of the Mohegans, seeing this, offered their service to join with the English, because it was against their common enemy. The Narragansetts did no considerable service compared with the Mohegans, who did as much as could be expected. The Narragansetts rather gathered up the spoil, to the great offense of the English and the Mohegans, seldom engaging in any fight. The English killed and destroyed this people utterly, so that those who were left utterly deserted the country; and the English won it and now possess it.
After this victory Miantonomo, sachem or lord of the Narragansetts, and Uncas, lord of the Mohegans, showed no good blood toward each other. The English at Hartford, where the government of Connecticut is held, hearing of it, brought them together and made a peace and threefold covenant between the government of Connecticut, the Narragansetts and the Mohegans. It was signed by the Governor of Connecticut, by Miantonomo, sachem of the Narragansetts, and by Uncas, sachem of the Mohegans. The covenants ran to this purpose: to confirm their league between the English and them, and with each other, and to hold forth a league of perpetual peace between them. And in case any difference should arise between these two Indian sachems or their people, the party offended should complain to the Governor of Connecticut, who was to mediate and to determine the controversy between his two friends and their people. And in case the injury were great, and the party in the wrong would not stand to the aforesaid award and determination, then it should be lawful not only for the wronged party to right himself by force of arms, but for the English party also to assist the innocent in that way. And to this they all signed as before.
The Narragansett sachem never regarded this covenant; the Mohegan sachem always faithfully observed it. But Miantonomo of Narragansett now had thoughts of carrying on the Pequots’ design and destroying the English (the Pequot nation having been rooted out by God’s just judgment, as I said before). He traveled far and near to draw all the Indians in the country into this horrid confederacy with him. But Uncas would not be won, though Miantonomo wanted to marry his daughter; instead he always acquainted the English with Miantonomo’s workings.
At length an inferior sachem, subordinate to Narragansett, insulted Uncas and his men. Uncas complained to the English; they sent a message to this inferior sachem; he slighted their warning and went on his course. Uncas then asked leave to make war on him, without asking for any aid. Still the English warned the other party of the evil they were likely to bring upon themselves, until at length they declared that they had had peace enough, and that now it was time for war. The English then gave Uncas leave to take his revenge. He did so, and the others were beaten.
Now Miantonomo prepared an army of above a thousand men, and came suddenly upon Uncas without any respect to covenants, and caught Uncas at a disadvantage, with no more than three hundred men; by this means they beset him on every side in his fort, which stands on a point of land between two rivers. Miantonomo so dispersed his men to prevent their flight that Uncas, making a desperate sally with almost his full force, routed the other side, slew nearly a hundred, and forced them to flee. But Mr. Weekes, one of Samuel Gorton’s company (as I am credibly informed), had lent the great sachem a complete suit of armor; and having it on in the fight, he was not able to flee as fast as his men, and was taken by this means.
Yet such was Uncas’s respect for the English that he held Miantonomo until he had sent to the English, namely to the Right Worshipful George Fenwick, Esquire, who lived nearest to him, to know what he should do with his prisoner. Fenwick advised Uncas to follow the Indians’ own custom, and to deal with Miantonomo as if Uncas had never consulted him, or as if there were no English in the land to consult. Upon this Uncas resolved to kill him at once, according to their custom.
But no sooner had the Narragansetts got home, having lost several sachems, captains and chief men in this fight, than they sent to Mr. Gorton and the rest, who sent a note to Uncas, with a command by the bearer that they should not put him to death, but use him kindly and return him. The messenger either said, or they supposed, that this came from the Governor of Massachusetts, and it much daunted Uncas and his men. But to clear up everything, Uncas and his men consulted the gentlemen of Connecticut, who advised Uncas to keep Miantonomo prisoner, and to consult the Commissioners of the United Colonies, of which Connecticut was a part, whose meeting would be held before long, in its regular course, in Massachusetts. Uncas followed this counsel, and asked the Governor of Connecticut (Miantonomo also desiring it) to keep the prisoner safe for him until then; and so Miantonomo was brought to Hartford.
And many gifts were sent to the prisoner, which he bestowed as befitted him: some on the man who took him, some on Uncas, some on his wife, some on Uncas’s brother, who was a great captain, and some on others from whom he had received kindnesses. And this was all the ransom that was paid, for no ransom was so much as proposed by the Narragansetts, nor set down by Uncas.
But when Uncas consulted the Commissioners, they considered how many ways besides open hostility Miantonomo had sought the life of Uncas, by poison, secret murder, witchcraft and the like, and advised Uncas to put him to death, since Uncas could never be safe while Miantonomo lived, so restless was Miantonomo in plotting against his life. And therefore they wished Uncas to proceed with him according to their own custom toward prisoners of war, which is to put them to death. He proceeded according to this advice, knowing now that none of the English would intercede for him. And upon this Uncas went to Hartford and demanded his prisoner, and led him to a house of his own, outside the limits of the English, and there killed him. An Englishman or two were present to prevent their accustomed cruelties: not only cutting off the heads and hands of their prisoners when they are dead, and making bracelets of the fore-joints of their fingers and so on, but torturing them while living with the most inhuman cruelties.
After this the Narragansetts would have made war on Uncas in revenge for Miantonomo’s death, but we forbade them. And at our next meeting of commissioners, to consult about the public welfare of the United Colonies, because the Narragansetts pleaded that Uncas had taken a ransom for his life and his life as well, which the other side denied, we sent for Uncas, and sent to the great sachems of Narragansett to come also, or to appear by commissioners. They sent four commissioners with full authority to treat, and there we found neither ransom nor the least show of ransom in any measure. And so a truce was agreed on: if Uncas broke it, we were then freed from our engagement to defend him any further, for they desired no more; and if the Narragansetts broke it, then it should be lawful for us, the United Colonies, to take part with him, and so on.
But the truth is this. Before they had such near neighbors among the English as Gorton and the rest, and until Miantonomo’s government, they were the most numerous and the most peaceable of all the Indians. Yet now they were changed, as if they had not been the same people, and had their tutors, secretaries and prompters to suggest to them their own greatness and our weakness, as his book bears witness. So much so that I am confident that if the Gortonians (for I take the term from his own book here, never having heard it before) are allowed to live so near them, it will in a short time be our ruin, or these Indians’ (which we do not desire).
I thought it good to insert this narration thus briefly, so that the reader might understand the ground of his many charges. I call God to witness that I know of not the least falsehood related in it, though many things worthy of a history have been omitted for brevity’s sake. But I am now writing an answer, not a history, and therefore I am this brief. But to return.
On page 47 of his book, see how he scoffs at the Sabbath, as if there were no other ground for our religious observance of it than Mr. Cotton’s judgment. And on page 48 he is full of many scoffs, as if he and his Gortonians would not shoot, and did not shoot, at all; whereas I have testimony on oath to prove that they also shot at the other side. But the truth is, I heard some say that their powder was so damp and moist that they could not fire a gun without great difficulty, which I well believe might be the reason they shot no more than they did.
On page 49 he charges Captain Cooke with breach of the articles. And yet I have it attested on oath that there were none agreed on. They only desired that they might not go bound, which was easily granted, since they behaved themselves quietly. And as for their cattle, I never heard that the number was anywhere near so great. When I asked the Governor of Massachusetts about them, he declared that they did not amount to half the cost of the expedition.
And if anyone asks by what authority they went out of their own jurisdiction to do such an act, let him know this. Consider Gorton’s former seditious and turbulent conduct in every place he came to: Plymouth; Rhode Island, a place of the greatest liberty; and Providence, the very place that relieved him in his great extremity. Consider his desperate alliance with such dangerous and powerful enemies, and at such a time of conspiracy by those same Indians. Add to this the wrongs done to the Indians and English under the protection of that government of Massachusetts, who complained and desired relief; and further, his notorious contempt of all civil government, as well as of that particular one; and his blasphemies against God, needlessly displayed in his proud letters to them, one of which he has printed, and the other I have published for him herewith. All these things considered, you will see in them cause enough why they proceeded against him as a common enemy of the country.
And against him as such a one, the said Commissioners, then meeting together in Massachusetts in their regular course for the welfare of the whole, upon just complaint ordered and thought it fit that the government of Massachusetts should call them to account, and proceed with them as far as stood with righteousness and justice. And by their declaration you may easily see that they went no further. For by refusing a safe conduct to come and answer to the matters against them, Gorton’s company needlessly forced this expense upon Massachusetts, part of which Massachusetts made them bear, as I related before. So here, I suppose, is cause enough besides blasphemy for their proceeding against them.
On page 51 he charges New England ministers with praying in the streets. But take notice: I have been there these twenty-six years and more, and never heard of such a practice until I now read it in his book.
On page 52 he says that the Governor, to satisfy the people, said “we were apprehended for various gross opinions…”
Answer. You may see in the section before last that there was cause enough. And yet as for opinions, let me tell you that you held that the image of God after which man was created was Christ, and that when Adam fell, Christ was slain, and so on. And as for your opinion concerning churches, Mr. Williams told me, by way of sad complaint, that you denied that there were any true churches of Christ in the world; and denied also baptism itself, and the Lord’s Supper, the Sabbath, and magistracy as an ordinance used among Christians. And as for the Lord’s Supper, you held that it is only a spell, the ministers necromancers, and the communicants drunk with the juice of the grape, and so on. As for this last passage mentioned here, the reader shall have it at large in a second letter sent by him and his companions to the government of Massachusetts. He kept that letter out of his book, though he claims to have printed everything.
On page 53, as he abuses others, so he abuses Mr. Cotton and Mr. Ward, affirming that Mr. Ward put himself into a passion and stirred up Carder to recant, and so on. He treats this as no discredit to Carder, because Mr. Cotton, he says, ordinarily preached something publicly once a year which he recanted the next year. But Mr. Ward being in town, a man well known and of good reputation, I showed him the book. He thanked me, and returned this answer to it verbatim:
Samuel Gorton having made me a margin note in the 53rd page of his book, I hold myself called to make this answer to it. I cannot call to mind that I ever knew or spoke with such a man as Richard Carder, nor that I ever had any speech with any prisoner at a window; nor should I need to in New England, where there is liberty enough given for conference with prisoners in more free and convenient places. This I remember: that one Robert Potter, who went in the same ship with me to New England, and expressed on the way so much honesty and godliness as gained my good opinion and affection toward him, I hearing that he was taken with Samuel Gorton’s blasphemous notions and conduct, and therefore now imprisoned with him, I went to visit him. And having free speech with him in the open prison yard, he, shedding many tears, might perhaps move me to express my affection to him, which Samuel Gorton calls passion. After some debate about his new opinions, I remember I used a speech to him to this effect: that he would do well and wisely to make such acknowledgment of his errors as his conscience would permit; telling him that Mr. Cotton, whom he had so much reverenced in Old England and New, had given him a godly example of that kind, by a public acknowledgment on a solemn fast day with many tears: that in the time when errors were so stirring, God leaving him for a time, he fell into a spiritual slumber; and had it not been for the watchfulness of his brethren the elders, and so on, he might have slept on; and he blessed God very cordially for awakening him, and was very thankful to his brethren for their watchfulness over him and faithfulness toward him. In this he honored God not a little, and greatly rejoiced the hearts of his hearers; and therefore it would be no shame for him to do the like.Concerning Mr. Cotton, were I worthy, I would presume to speak that now of him which I have said more than many times of him elsewhere: that I hold him such an eminent worthy of Christ as very few others have attained to; and that I hold myself not worthy to wipe his slippers for matters of grace, learning and industry in the work of God.For the author, Samuel Gorton: I myself and others far more judicious take him to be a man whose spirit is stark drunk with blasphemies and insolence, a corrupter of the truth, and a disturber of the peace wherever he comes. I entreat him to read Titus 1:13 with a humble heart, and that is the greatest harm I wish him.Nathaniel Ward.
So much for the answer and testimony of that reverend and grave divine, in which the reader may see how Mr. Gorton abuses all men, casting mire and dirt in the faces of our most deserving instruments.
On page 54 he accuses Mr. Wilson and Mr. Cotton of stirring up the people against them, and so on.
Answer. What they pressed in their sermons I was not present to hear. But this I can affirm: from the time of their release to my departure from New England, which is not much above two months, I have heard many precious, godly men affirm that Samuel Gorton and his company needlessly belched out such blasphemy in their writings and conversation that they thought God was offended with the country for giving them the liberty they had. And that you may better see his conduct: it being the custom of the country to let their prisoners come to hear the Word preached, Mr. Gorton and the rest were there. After Mr. Cotton had ended his sermon on a Sabbath day, Gorton asked leave to speak, and with Mr. Cotton assenting to it, the Governor, who was present, gave him leave. Then, with a loud voice, before the whole congregation, which was very large, he declared “that the ministry of the Word, sacraments, censures and other ordinances of religion in the hands of ministers are like the silver shrines of Diana in the hands of the craftsmen of Ephesus…” And if the truth of this is questioned, I have testimony on oath to make it good.
On pages 55, 56 and 57 many things might be objected to. First, on page 55, the great respect he shows to that government because it derives from the State of England. What that respect amounted to, you may see in full in certain Observations by a godly divine attached to this book, upon his own two contemptuous and blasphemous letters, or rather books, in which there are forty-eight separate aspersions cast on them. Secondly, on page 56, his appealing from their justice, when their charter enjoins no such appeal.
On pages 56 and 57, as to the questions as he has set them down, and his account of the time allowed him to give his answer, I question whether he has dealt fairly there, because he is so often found at fault.
To pass by his answer and his long explanation of himself on page 58, and to come to page 59 and following, and so to the rest of his answers to the questions, up to page 64, I answer this. I do not know whether he states things rightly; yet this I know, as it is attested by reverend persons: that he then maintained “that God made man after his own image; and that God has but one image, and that is Christ; and this was the incarnation of Christ, his self-emptying by which we are saved.” And when it was objected that we are not saved by the incarnation of Christ but by the death of Christ, “True,” says he, “therefore Adam fell, and so destroyed God’s image, and that was the death of Christ.” When it was objected again that Adam’s fall was not our salvation but our condemnation, whereas the death of Christ was our salvation, and that therefore Adam’s fall could not be the death of Christ, he would by no means either retract or explain his statement (though much urged to do so) so as to agree with the principles of the Christian religion. Being further asked what he then thought of that Christ in whom we believe, born of the Virgin Mary, and who suffered under Pontius Pilate, he answered “that that Christ was a shadow, and but a resemblance of what is done in me and every true Christian.” And now judge, good reader, whether this is like what he mentions, or whether it was a trifle not worth mentioning. But if he will be so unfaithful as to omit it, I dare not.
As for his sentence, on page 64, I do not know whether it is rightly set down; and the same goes for the charge on page 65, in which I dare say he wrongs the ministers by saying “they stirred up the people to famish them.”
As for his long and tedious letter to Mr. Green, from page 66 to page 74, I pass it by, as he says Mr. Green did. But on page 74 he would make it an aspersion on Mr. Endecott that he said “that God had stirred them up to go out of their own jurisdiction to fetch them from their own places.” Take notice: although the place lies literally within the line of the Plymouth government in their grant, yet the Indians before mentioned had subjected themselves to Massachusetts. So the commissioners for Plymouth, as well as those for Connecticut and New Haven, meeting together at their ordinary time and place, upon the manifold complaints and reasons mentioned before, appointed and ordered that it should be so, as appears by the copy of their act:
At a meeting of the Commissioners for the United Colonies of New England, held at Boston the seventh of September, 1643.Whereas complaints have been made against Samuel Gorton and his company, and some of them weighty and of great consequence; and whereas the said Gorton and the rest have been formerly sent for, and now lately by the General Court of the Massachusetts with a safe conduct both for their coming and return, that they might give answer and satisfaction wherein they have done wrong: if yet they shall stubbornly refuse, the Commissioners for the United Colonies think fit that the magistrates in the Massachusetts proceed against them according to what they shall find just; and the rest of the jurisdictions will approve and concur in what shall be so warrantably done, as if their commissioners had been present at the conclusions; provided that this conclusion do not prejudice the government of Plymouth in any right they can justly claim to any tract or tracts…
By this order it appears that they were stirred up and allowed by Plymouth itself, as well as by the rest, as before, to send for and deal with them as the common disturbers of the peace of the country.
On page 76 he complains of the Governor’s last order for breaking the order of the court. Yet take it as he relates it, and any man of understanding will easily see on the other side of the same leaf that they were still bound to the rest of the articles of their confinement, which they were now well on the way to breaking. And as for that little island called Rhode Island that they were forced to shelter in, take notice that it is thirty miles around, very fruitful, and plentifully abounding with all manner of food the country affords, and has two towns, besides many great farms well stocked.
On page 79 he complains of us for calling them Gortonians, and of the Indians for calling them Gortonoges and not Englishmen, with many affected, foppish vanities, phrases and terms I never heard before; and yet I have lived in New England from the beginning, now above twenty-six years. I could wish he did not study and affect these things, but I much fear he does.
On page 80 he tells a cock-and-bull story of Miantonomo being slain as he marched, which is false; for he was put to death, and in a house, not on a march. And is it any wonder that two Englishmen were present to see the manner of their proceeding in so weighty a matter as one prince putting another, his perfidious enemy and captive, to death? Especially when they were required by the Commissioners to forbear their accustomed torments and to give him honorable burial, which they did, and received thanks from the Narragansetts for those particulars. Now if anyone would know how it was done: it was only with one blow of a hatchet on the side of the head, as he walked calmly in the room (expecting no less), which fully dispatched him at once. And so much for answer to this charge.
To pass over what he says on page 81 about Miantonomo’s death, as having been answered before, and to come to page 82 and following, where he mentions a consultation held among the Indians to put themselves under the subjection of the State of England, and so on:
Answer. We did indeed hear of this desperate plot by this unfaithful people. They had been in covenant with the several governments long before, but never observed any one article further than it might further their own design, which was to be absolute lords of the country, even with the ruin of us all. And truly, had he not published this and the following discourse, we could never have proved it, though we heard of it from both English and Indians. And however Miantonomo died, the plot lives and continues to this day. Now though I dare not say, nor do I think, that Gorton’s company join with the Indians in aiming at the ruin of all the English, yet they join with them in many of their councils, contrive the Indians’ defiant answers in writing, and act as their secretaries. Who does not know that the Indians cannot write? And who cannot tell their own answers from those that come through your hands? And if the State of England (which God forbid) should establish your joint propositions and theirs, then their plot would be accomplished. For they might, and would, work our ruin freely, while we might not take up arms against them except by virtue of a warrant or writ from here, procured upon our complaints made here. That would take six months in the ordinary course of procuring and returning it, while in one of those months all our throats might be cut, and those hopeful beginnings, so much favored by our gracious God until now, would be well on the way to being overthrown.
Indeed, we heard further, and for my part I believe it, that for the better accomplishment of this, Samuel Gorton and some of his company had persuaded the Narragansetts to send the King a very large present of beaver and otter skins, which they were to bring in, and accordingly did. But the Englishman who reported this says besides that if Gorton could find favor with the Parliament, he would rest there; but if they frowned on him, he did not doubt that he would obtain what was fitting from the King. But the times would not allow him to publish this also; otherwise, I see, we should have had it all. And take notice of this: that (as the same report testified) at his departure he advised them by no means to make war with us, the United Colonies, but to come to terms, however dearly it cost them. But he assured them that at his return he would come strengthened with such authority, and so many of his friends, that the Narragansetts and themselves would not need to fear anything the rest of the English could do. And that we heard these things from credible testimony, and that they are not feigned by me, I take the Searcher of the heart to witness; yes, I say further that I believe them to be true.
His glorious, seemingly well-deserving acts follow on page 82 and onward to page 89. But note that Weekes, Holden and Warner (though I know the last least, but am sure of the other two) were his strong assistants in his former seditious and mutinous conduct both at Rhode Island and at Providence, and were therefore fit commissioners, as he terms them, for accomplishing such a design. And on page 85 note, first, their compliance with the Narragansetts, and his false report in saying that Miantonomo’s ransom was taken and his life also, which is most false, as I made clear in my former relation. And as for the King’s being our judge and theirs, as on page 86: know that the Indians care no more for the King than they do for us, whom they would destroy if they could.
And on page 88 take notice of the Gortonists’ complying and joining with them: first, by calling them their “fellow subjects”; and secondly, by speaking of the Maukquagges (whom we ordinarily call Mohawks) as being “the most fierce and warlike people in the country, where,” says he, “we are furnished with 3,700 guns, men expert in the use of them…” Now these, like the Swiss, indeed serve for hire, and the Narragansetts, being rich, have hired them to assist them in their war. But though the Gortonists, it seems, claim a share with the Narragansetts in their strength against us, yet these people are neither so many men, nor have so many arms. Still, they have too many, and are very expert in them, being continually supplied by the French and Dutch. Their aim is chiefly at the fur trade, and by this means they not only rob us of what should help to maintain our plantations, which are growing up into a nation, but furnish the Indians with all manner of arms. I wish to God, and humbly beseech this High Court of Parliament, that it would take this into serious consideration and treat with their several ambassadors about it, as a thing unreasonable in itself, which has been pernicious to French and Dutch alike, and may be destructive both to them and to us, if some due course is not taken.
But to return from my humble request to the State to my answer to Samuel Gorton. Although this is a most unworthy boast of his, yet I trust the State will make such use of it as never to allow this desperate crew to live so near our malicious enemies the Narragansetts. And I trust that they will not only uphold the sentence of the Massachusetts government against them, but hinder the said Gorton’s return there, by forbidding him to set foot on that land of New England which he has filled with so many troubles in every part where he has been.
On page 91 he charges Plymouth with joining Massachusetts to frustrate their government, set up by virtue of their new charter. It is true that we wanted Massachusetts to have that territory, and to give the State a reason for their proceedings, knowing, as I said before, that Mr. Gorton’s journey was for evil and not for good. But they, being taken up at that time with weightier concerns, neglected it. Plymouth, however, did then petition the right honorable Robert, Earl of Warwick, the Governor in Chief of the English plantations in America, and the rest of that honorable committee joined in commission with him, that we might enjoy the ancient limits of government granted in our letters patent. And we showed at the same time that their charter, as to the limits now granted in it, was contained within our line of government; and I trust I shall now receive an answer.
It is true also that we sent Mr. John Browne, furnished with the following instructions, to declare to all who were concerned in that newly erected government as follows, by commission given at New Plymouth, November 8, 1644:
1. That a great part of their supposed government is within the line of the government of New Plymouth.
2. That we assuredly knew that this ever-to-be-honored House of Parliament would not, nor will, when they shall know of it, take from us, the most ancient plantation, any part of the line of our government formerly granted, it being contrary to their principles.
3. To forbid them, and each and every one of them, to exercise any authority or power of government within the limits of our letters patent.
4. To certify them that Coweeset is not only within the said limits, but that the sachem of it and his sons have taken the protection of this our government; and therefore to forbid them to enter upon any part of his or their lands without due order and leave from our government.
Now these instructions were signed by the Governor. And Mr. Browne, going to Rhode Island for this purpose, came very opportunely when a public meeting had been appointed for your new magistrates and people. But, as he reported, it was for a most vile end: namely, to take into consideration a new distribution of the lands formerly given out, as if some had too much and some too little, and all regard for persons and their estates was to be laid aside. And note here that Mr. Coddington, Mr. Brinton and others, whom we at Plymouth had particularly in view when we commended them to that place, abhorred their course and stayed away from their meetings. They looked upon themselves as persons in great danger, and bemoaned their condition to various friends of theirs, being now overwhelmed with cares and fears as to what the outcome of things would be. And note that now also Mr. Samuel Gorton, who before had suffered so much at the hands of authority for his evil doing, and had come to deny it and preach against it, being now called to office by these inhabitants, accepted it and became a magistrate among them, and so on.
But whereas he suggests that Mr. Browne had only delivered his message (according to his instructions) in a private way from house to house, in this he wrongs him. For he did it publicly in the place of their assembly, and they were so daunted at it that they broke up and did none of the business intended for that day, as Mr. Browne related it. But some would have had him imprisoned, others punished, others sent to the Dutch and so to England. Yes, Mr. Gorton himself told Mr. Browne’s son that his father had done what he deserved to die for, and that if he were in any other place it would cost him his life. So fit for government were these men, that they judged a peaceable claim of right, made without any further disturbance or stir, to deserve this!
Nor indeed have we stirred any further than this, ever resolving to rest in the determination of the right honorable the Governor in Chief and the rest of his honorable assistants of that committee entrusted with the affairs of the English plantations abroad. We assured ourselves that whatever might proceed either from misinformation or from lack of due knowledge of what was formerly done would be rectified upon the first information and complaint made. Such were our thoughts of them, and the justice we expected, and still hope to receive, from them. And so much in answer to that complaint.
On page 92 he casts another gross aspersion upon us, in saying, “There was distance and alienation of affection between Plymouth and the Massachusetts at their first coming, each thinking, I am holier than thou; and as if we were now united on purpose to scatter them.” The world knows this to be most false. Never did a people agree better, maintaining both religious and civil communion with each other, and helping and being helpful to one another on all occasions. This is so well known that if he did not have more than ordinary boldness, he would not dare to affirm what he does. Nor did the men of Plymouth come from Amsterdam, as he reports, but from Leyden, a people with whom many of that church of Amsterdam would hardly allow communion. But slander from his pen does no one any harm, or at least it will do none wherever this answer follows it. And as for his account of the manner of the Indians’ mourning for their prince’s death: truly, had he died a natural death, it is their manner to mourn in that way not only for their great sachems, who are princes, but for ordinary men, women and children, as he well knows or might know.
On page 93 he further complains of Plymouth and Massachusetts for offering to go out against the Narragansetts to cut them off by the sword, and so complains also of Captain Standish and others.
Answer. I told you before how the Commissioners for the United Colonies, meeting at Hartford in their regular course (their meeting always begins the first Thursday in September), sent for both the Narragansetts and Uncas, who appeared, and a league was agreed on. But the Narragansetts broke it again, and made war upon Uncas needlessly. The United Colonies admonished them again and again. And when no admonition or persuasion would serve, we were then forced to call the Commissioners together at an extraordinary season for the purpose. They found it fitting to take up arms on behalf of Uncas our confederate, which, by the agreement of the Narragansetts themselves, made several times at various meetings, we were bound to do, and it was made lawful for us to do. Upon this the Commissioners, agreeing as before, sent out their warrants to their several particular governments, and accordingly forces were raised at a day’s warning. But before this, instead of listening to righteous counsel, they threatened the English as well, saying they would make heaps of our dead bodies and cattle as high as their houses, burn our homes and plunder our goods; and they used our messengers very discourteously, and so on.
And as for Captain Standish, this I heard him relate. Being at the place of rendezvous before the Massachusetts forces came, he observed that some of the inhabitants of Providence received the Indians into their houses on familiar terms, though these Indians had also put themselves into a posture of arms; and the place was within a mile of Seekonk, or Rehoboth, where Captain Standish lay. He sent to Providence and required them to lay aside their neutrality and declare themselves on one side or the other. For once the war had begun, he would not bear with their conduct in entertaining, furnishing and relieving the common enemy, but would disarm them, and so on. And whether necessity did not drive him to this course, let the reader judge.
And as for the five hundred pounds: it is true their hearts failed them to see the Plymouth forces appear, and those of Massachusetts, both horse and foot, on their march on one side of their country under Mr. Edward Gibbons, who was chosen General of the United Colonies. With them came the help of Woosamequin, whose constancy to Plymouth is well known, and of Pumham and Socononoco, who answer to Massachusetts, with all their men, awaiting the English word of command. And on the other side of their country were the forces of Connecticut and New Haven, with all the strength of Uncas, waiting only for the word from the Commissioners to fall on. Now, I say, they were daunted, especially because it came upon them so suddenly, and they lacked Mr. Gorton and his friends, who had not yet come. Upon this they resolved to go to the Commissioners in Massachusetts and come to terms. They signed new articles: to keep the peace not only with the United Colonies but with Uncas, Woosamequin, Pumham and Socononoco, and others of our confederates, including all the English in the land; to make satisfaction for wrongs done to Uncas; and to pay five hundred pounds to the United Colonies for the charge they had put us to, which indeed would not nearly have made it good, even if they had paid it. But as at other times, so now, notwithstanding their hostages, they abused us grossly: first, by sending false persons as hostages; secondly, by breaking all their other covenants. And at last they came to a resolution that they would rather give the money (which is a bead of their own making, as current as coin in all that part of America) to the Mohawks at once, to cut us off, than pay it according to covenant.
And so, contrary to my resolution, I see a necessity for larger answers than I intended; and indeed otherwise I should be speaking riddles and not satisfy the reader. And yet, were this a history, I have many remarkable passages which here, for brevity’s sake, I must omit. And if any think that we needlessly engage in the troubles between the Indians:
1. Let them know that if we did not keep up relations with some of them here and there, they would soon all join together against us.
2. The quarrel between Uncas and the Narragansett arose from his cleaving to us. For the great sachem Miantonomo would have married Uncas’s daughter, and since then Pessachus, who succeeded him, would have married Woosamequin’s daughter, and all out of cunning, to draw them away from us; so that indeed we are compelled to it.
3. We are not without hope in time of bringing them to the knowledge of Jesus Christ, as will appear by a small treatise of that kind.
But I want the reader to take notice of this one thing. That great prince Miantonomo, whom he so much admires, had offered violence to Woosamequin (who was under the protection of Plymouth), and, missing his person, returned only with the plunder of his goods. Upon Woosamequin’s complaint to Plymouth, that government alone, it being before the Union, sent Captain Standish with a few men, not above twenty. He sent a message over the bay of salt water that parts Woosamequin from them, telling them either to make restitution of his goods so injuriously taken, or else to expect him to fetch them with a vengeance, to their cost. Upon this they sent over every particular that could be demanded, even to a wooden dish, and patched up everything again. But this was before any malignant English had settled so near them and held counsel with them; before those English had slandered us to them, reporting us to be base and low, out of favor with the King and State, and so on. These are things very unworthy, abominable to be named, except that in defending the abused governments of the country I am forced to deal such blows at these proud and turbulent enemies of the country.
Next, on page 94, there is what he relates of Mr. Williams: namely, that when the messengers who were sent to the Narragansetts in that troublesome time took him with them, Mr. Cotton reportedly preached that, Mr. Williams “being one cast out of the church,” “it was all one to take counsel of a witch, and that those that did it were worthy to die.” Upon which Mr. Wilbour, one of the messengers, “was ready to die,” says he, “for fear he should have been hanged.” I cannot believe this, for these two reasons:
1. Because all who know Mr. Cotton know his moderation, wisdom and piety to be such that such an expression was not likely to drop from him.
2. The strictest government in New England that I know of takes no advantage in law against a man’s person for his being excommunicated; so much so that if he holds an office, he holds it nevertheless. And I know this to be practiced, and therefore his report is unlikely.
But that the messengers were directed to another man as their interpreter, I know; and that some took offense at their practice, I know also, but on different grounds, which I forbear to mention, since I am now to answer Mr. Gorton and not Mr. Williams.
On page 93, which is the last page in his book that I shall need to answer, the thing he brings against us is an answer to a doctrine that one of their wives reportedly heard delivered in Massachusetts when she came to visit them, from Matt 24:29, and alluding to Heb 12:26-27. Briefly, this doctrine there delivered “should make the doctrine of the Apostles and the churches in their times to be but darkness; that the ministry of the Apostles was and should be removed…” I desire the reader to turn to it. But be assured that, through God’s mercy, by means of the late Bishop of Canterbury’s persecutions of the godly here, we are so excellently furnished with shining lights of the gospel that no such blasphemous trash as this could be delivered there. And we have so many able hearers that if it had been delivered by anyone, the Lord withdrawing his presence from him, it would immediately have been objected to and published to the world. But I am confident that if such a thing was heard there, it came either from one of their own company or from disciples made by them. And therefore I will pass by the answer also, as not concerning any difference between him and us, and so too the rest of his writings to that end. And I could wish that he were not, like Narcissus, so much in love with his own shadow, lest it prove his ruin; for no other matter is needed against him than his own words and writings to render him odious to the State here, as well as to New England, from where he came.
Why New England Was Planted
And now that I have finished what I consider necessary concerning Mr. Gorton’s scandalous and slanderous books, let me briefly answer some objections that I often meet with against the country of New England. The first one I meet with concerns the rise and foundation of our New England plantations. A recent writer has alleged (though by a great mistake) that division or disagreement in the church at Leyden was the occasion, indeed the cause, of the first plantation in New England. For the author says, or words to this effect, that when they could no longer agree together, one part went to New England and began the plantation at Plymouth. He makes that plantation the mother, as it were, of the rest of the churches, as if the foundation of our New England plantations had been laid upon division or separation. Nothing could be more untrue. For I am persuaded that no people on earth ever lived more lovingly together, or parted more sweetly, than we of the church at Leyden did. We did not part rashly, in a troubled and divided mood, but upon joint and serious deliberation, often seeking the mind of God by fasting and prayer. We not only found his gracious presence with us, but his blessing upon us from that time to this very moment, to the indignation of our adversaries, the wonder of strangers, and our own exceeding comfort, as we see such effects of our prayers and tears before our pilgrimage here is ended. And therefore take brief notice of the true cause of it.
It is true that that poor persecuted flock of Christ was driven to Leyden in Holland by the malice and power of the late hierarchy of bishops, there to bear witness in their practice to the kingly office of Christ Jesus in his church. There they lived together ten years under the United Provinces, with much peace and liberty. But our reverend pastor, the late Mr. John Robinson, and our grave elder, Mr. William Brewster (both now at rest with the Lord), considered among many other inconveniences how hard the country was where we lived; how many spent their estates in it and were forced to return to England; how grievous it was to live outside the protection of the State of England; how likely we were to lose our language and our name of English; how little good we did, or were likely to do, to the Dutch in reforming the Sabbath; how unable we were there to give our children such an education as we ourselves had received; and so on.
They, I say, out of their Christian care for the flock of Christ committed to them, reasoned in this way. God might be pleased to show us some place (though in America), and to give us so much favor with the King and State of England as to have their protection there. There we might enjoy the like liberty. There, if the Lord favored our endeavors with his blessing, we might show our dear countrymen by our example (for they were no less burdened than ourselves) where they might live and comfortably subsist, and enjoy the like liberties with us, being freed from antichristian bondage. They might keep their names and nation. And we might be a means of enlarging not only the dominions of our State but the Church of Christ as well, if the Lord had a people among the natives where he should bring us, and so on. In this way, in their grave wisdom, they thought we might glorify God more, do more good to our country, provide better for our posterity, and live to be more refreshed by our labors, than we could ever do in Holland where we were.
Now after mature deliberation they imparted these private thoughts of theirs to the brethren of the congregation. After much private discussion the matter came to public debate, until at length the Lord was solemnly sought in the congregation by fasting and prayer to direct us. And as he moved our hearts more and more to the work, we sent some men of good abilities over into England to see what favor or acceptance such a thing might find with the King. These men also found God going along with them. They got Sir Edwin Sandys, a religious gentleman then living, to take the matter up. He procured Sir Robert Naunton, then principal Secretary of State to King James of famous memory, to put it privately to his Majesty that he should give way to such a people (who could not live so comfortably under the government of another state) to enjoy their liberty of conscience under his gracious protection in America. There they would endeavor the advancement of his Majesty’s dominions and the enlargement of the gospel by all due means.
His Majesty said this was a good and honest proposal, and he asked what profits might arise in the part we intended (for our eye was upon the most northern parts of Virginia). The answer was, “Fishing.” To this he replied with his usual oath, “So God have my soul, it’s an honest trade; it was the apostles’ own calling…” But afterward he told Sir Robert Naunton (who took every opportunity to further it) that we should confer with the bishops of Canterbury and London, and others. Upon this we were advised to rest upon his first approval and not to entangle ourselves with them. This led our agents to go to the Virginia Company, which asked in its court what our purposes were in going. When these were related, they said the thing was of God, and granted a large patent. And one of them lent us three hundred pounds interest-free for three years, which was repaid.
When our agents returned, we further sought the Lord by a public and solemn fast for his gracious guidance. And upon this we came to the following resolution. First, it was best for one part of the church to go at the start and the other to stay, namely, the youngest and strongest part to go. Second, those who went should offer themselves freely. Third, if the larger part went, the pastor was to go with them; if not, the elder only. Fourth, if the Lord should frown upon our proceedings, then those who went were to return, and the brethren who remained there were to assist them and be helpful to them. But if God should be pleased to favor those who went, then they also should endeavor to help over such as were poor and old and willing to come.
These things being agreed, the larger part stayed, and the pastor with them for the present. But all intended to follow after, except a very few who would rather we had stayed. The smaller part, with Mr. Brewster their elder, resolved to enter upon this great work (but take notice that the difference in number was not great). And when the ship was ready to carry us away, the brethren who stayed once again solemnly sought the Lord with us and for us, and we further engaged ourselves to one another as before. They, I say, who stayed at Leyden feasted those of us who were to go, at our pastor’s house, which was large. There we refreshed ourselves after our tears with the singing of psalms, making joyful melody in our hearts as well as with the voice, for many of the congregation were very expert in music. And indeed it was the sweetest melody that my ears ever heard.
After this they accompanied us to Delfshaven, where we were to embark, and there feasted us again. And after prayer offered by our pastor, in which a flood of tears was poured out, they accompanied us to the ship, but were not able to speak to one another for the abundance of sorrow at parting. We alone went aboard, the ship lying at the quay, ready to set sail with the wind fair. We gave them a volley of small shot and three pieces of ordnance, and so, lifting up our hands to each other and our hearts for each other to the Lord our God, we departed. And we found his presence with us in the midst of the many hardships he carried us through. And if anyone doubts this account, the Dutch at Delfshaven, as I hear, preserve the memory of it to this day and will inform them.
But making land at Cape Cod, which is in New England, and standing to the southward for the place we intended, we met with many dangers, and the mariners put back into the harbor of the Cape. This was on November 11, 1620. There, considering that winter had come, the seas were dangerous, the season cold and the winds high, and being well furnished for a plantation, we began to explore and settled at Plymouth. There God was pleased to preserve and enable us, and we who went spent a thousand pounds in sending for our brethren who were left behind, and in providing for them there until they could reap a crop from their own labors.
And so, good reader, I have given you a true and faithful account, though a very brief one, of our proceedings. In it you see how a recent writer, and those who informed him, have wronged our enterprise. And truly, what I have written falls far short of what it was, for I have left out many circumstances for brevity’s sake. Such were the large offers the Dutch made us, either to move into Zeeland and live there with them, or, if we would go on such adventures, to go under them to Hudson’s River (where they have since made a great plantation, and so on), and how they would freely have transported us and furnished every family with cattle, and so on. Such too were the English merchants who joined with us in this expedition, whom we have since bought out. All this is fitter for a history than for an answer to such an objection (and I trust that history will be accomplished in good time). By all of it the reader may see that there was no breach between those of us who went and the brethren who stayed, but such love as is indeed seldom found on earth.
And as for the many plantations that have come over to us upon hearing of God’s blessing upon us, it is falsely said that they took Plymouth for their precedent as fast as they came. I confess it is true that some of the chief of them, coming over to be freed from the burdensome ceremonies then imposed in England, consulted with us about how they should arrive at a right form of worship. To that end they asked us, since God had honored us with laying the foundation of a commonwealth and settling a church in it, to show them what our practice was grounded on. And if, upon due search, they found it was built upon the Word, they would be willing to take up what was of God. Accordingly we showed them the practice of the primitive church as our warrant, taken out of the Acts of the Apostles and the epistles written by those apostles to the several churches, together with the commandments of Christ the Lord in the gospel, and our other warrants from the book of God for every particular we did. When they had well weighed and considered these, they too entered into covenant with God and with one another to walk in all his ways revealed, or as they should be made known to them, and to worship him according to his will revealed in his written Word only, and so on.
So here also you may see that they did not set the church at Plymouth before them as their example. Rather, the primitive churches were and are their pattern and example and ours alike, and these alone are worthy to be followed, since they had among them the blessed apostles, who were sent directly by Christ himself and enabled and guided by the unerring Spirit of God. And truly this is a pattern fit to be followed by all who fear God, and no man or men are to be followed further than they follow Christ and them.
Robinson’s Farewell
I have thus briefly shown that the foundation of our New England plantations was not laid upon schism, division, or separation, but upon love, peace, and holiness; yes, upon such love and mutual care of the church of Leyden for the spreading of the gospel, for the welfare of each other, and for their posterity to succeeding generations, as is seldom found on earth. I have shown also that the earliest churches are the only pattern which the churches of Christ in New England have in their eye, and that they do not follow Luther, Calvin, Knox, Ainsworth, Robinson, Ames, or any other, further than these follow Christ and his apostles. Having done so, I am earnestly requested to clear up another gross mistake, which caused many, and still causes many, to judge the more harshly of New England and the churches there. For, they say, “The church of Plymouth, which went first from Leyden, were schismatics, Brownists, rigid Separatists, and the like, having Mr. Robinson for their pastor, who made, and to the last professed, separation from the other churches of Christ… And the rest of the churches in New England, holding communion with that church, are to be reputed such as they are.”
In answer to this aspersion: first, the doubt might easily be resolved, and the aspersion removed, by anyone who knew Mr. Robinson, whether from his doctrine as he daily taught it; or from reading his Apology, published not long before his death; or from the practice of that church of Christ under his government; or from the wholesome counsel he gave, at their departure and afterward, to that part of the church which went for New England.
As for his doctrine (and I lived three years under his ministry before we began the work of plantation in New England), it was always against separation from any of the churches of Christ. He professed and held communion with both the French and Dutch churches, and even offered it to the Scots as well, as I shall show more particularly a little later. He always taught how wary people ought to be in separating from a church, and that until Christ the Lord had departed wholly from it, no one ought to leave it, but only to bear witness against the corruption that was in it.
But if anyone objects that he separated from the Church of England and wrote at length against it, I acknowledge that he did write at length against it. Yet let me tell you, he approved of hearing the godly ministers preach and pray in the public assemblies. Indeed, he allowed private communion not only with them but with all who were faithful in Christ Jesus, in the kingdom and elsewhere, upon all occasions. Yes, he honored them for the power of godliness above all others in the world who profess religion. Indeed, I may truly say his spirit clung to them, since he was so well acquainted with the integrity of their hearts and their care to walk blamelessly in their lives. This was no small motive to him in persuading us to remove from Holland, to a place where we might probably not only continue English, but also have and maintain such sweet communion with the godly of the English nation as, through God’s great mercy, we enjoy this day.
It is true, I confess, that he was more rigid in his course and way at first than toward his latter end. For he strove for peace and union, so far as might agree with faith and a good conscience; and as for schism and division, there was nothing in the world more hateful to him. But the government of the Church of England as it then stood in the episcopal way, the liturgy and prescribed forms of prayer of the church at that time, yes, its constitution as a national church, and so consequently the corrupt communion of the unworthy with the worthy receivers of the Lord’s Supper: these things he never approved, but witnessed against them to his death. And they are witnessed against to this day by the church over which he was pastor.
And if the Lord would be pleased to stir up the hearts of those in whom, under him, the power of reformation lies, to reform that abuse, so that a distinction might at last be put between the precious and the vile; so that particular churches might be gathered by the powerful preaching of the Word, and only those admitted into communion whose hearts the Lord persuades to submit to the iron rod of the gospel: oh, how sweet then would the communion of the churches be! How thorough the reformation! How easily would the differences between the Presbyterian and Independent way be reconciled! How would the God of peace, who commands love and good agreement, smile upon this nation! How would the subtle underminers of it be disappointed, and the faithful stirred up to sing songs of praise and thanksgiving! Indeed, how would the God of order be glorified in such orderly walking of the saints!
And as the two parties have fought together for the liberties of the kingdom, ecclesiastical and civil, so may they join together in preserving them (which otherwise, it is to be feared, will not long continue), and in the praises of our God, who has been so good to his poor distressed ones, whom he has delivered, and whom he will deliver out of all their troubles. But I have made too great a digression and must return.
In the next place I should speak of Mr. Robinson’s Apology, in which he makes a brief defense against many adversaries, and so forth. But because it is available in both Latin and English, is inexpensive, and is easy to obtain, I shall forbear to write of it, and only refer the reader to it for the differences between his congregation and the other Reformed churches.
The next thing I would have the reader take notice of is that, however the church of Leyden differed in some particulars, it made no schism or separation from the Reformed churches, but held communion with them as occasion arose. For we always placed a large difference between those who grounded their practice upon the Word of God (though differing from us in the exposition or understanding of it) and those who hated such reformers and reformation, and went on in antichristian opposition to it and persecution of it, as the late lord bishops did. These, in deed and truth (whatever their pretenses were), would not have Christ rule over them. But as they often stretched out their hands against the saints, so God has withered the arm of their power, thrown them down from their high and lofty seats, and slain the chief of them, as well as the hierarchy, so that this chief might become an example to all who rise against God in his Sabbath, in the preaching of his Word, in his saints, and in the purity of his ordinances. And I heartily desire that others may hear and fear by it.
As for the Dutch, it was usual for those of our members who understood the language, and who lived in London or occasionally came over to London, to take communion with them, as one John Jenny, a brewer, long did, with his wife and family, and others; and this without any offense to the church. So also any who had occasion to travel into any other part of the Netherlands regularly did the same.
And at the time when Arminianism prevailed so much, our pastor, Mr. Robinson, at the request of the most orthodox divines, such as Polyander, Festus, Hommius, and others, disputed daily against Episcopius (in the academy at Leyden) and others, the grand champions of that error. And he was held in as high regard among them as any of their own divines. So much so that when God took him away from them and us by death, the university and the ministers of the city accompanied him to his grave with all their customary solemnities. They bewailed the great loss, and not to that particular church alone of which he was pastor; indeed, some of the chief of them sadly affirmed that all the churches of Christ sustained a loss by the death of that worthy instrument of the gospel.
I could also cite various members of their churches who understood the English tongue, joined the communion of our church, and went with us to New England, such as Godbert Godbertson and others. Indeed, at this very moment another, called Moses Symonson, is admitted into church fellowship at Plymouth in New England, and his children also to baptism as well as our own, because he is the child of one who was in communion with the Dutch church at Leyden. And other Dutch are also in communion at Salem, and elsewhere.
And as for the French churches, to show that we held and still hold communion with them, take notice of our practice at Leyden: namely, that one Samuel Terry was received from the French church there into communion with us. Also the wife of Francis Cooke, being a Walloon, holds communion with the church at Plymouth to this day, as she came from the French church, by virtue of the communion of churches.
There is also one Philip Delanoy, born of French parents, who came to us from Leyden to New Plymouth. Coming to the age of discernment, he also asked for communion with us; and having proved that he was descended from such parents as were in full communion with the French churches, he was admitted on that ground by the church of Plymouth. Later, upon moving his home to Duxbury, where Mr. Ralph Partridge is pastor of the church, and upon letters of recommendation from the church at Plymouth, he was also admitted into fellowship with the church at Duxbury, which is six miles distant from Plymouth. And so, I dare say, if his affairs lead him, he may pass from church to church throughout New England.
For the truth is, the Dutch and French churches are each a people distinct from the world, gathered into a holy communion, and not national churches. Indeed, they are so far from it that I truly believe not one person in six there is of the church. So the difference between them and us, if moderately weighed, is so small that we dare not for the world deny communion with them.
And as for the Church of Scotland, although we have had the least occasion offered to hold communion with them, yet this much I can and do affirm. A godly divine came over to Leyden in Holland, where a book was printed, in the year 1619 as I take it, showing the nullity of the Perth Assembly. We judged him to be its author, and he was hidden in Holland for a season to avoid the rage of those evil times. His name I have forgotten. This man was very familiar with our pastor Mr. Robinson, and used to come to hear him on the Sabbath. After the sermon had ended, when the church was about to partake of the Lord’s Supper, this minister stood up and asked that he might, without offense, stay and see the manner of his administration and our participation in that ordinance. To this our pastor answered in these very words, or to this effect: “Reverend sir, you may not only stay to behold us, but partake with us, if you please, for we acknowledge the churches of Scotland to be the churches of Christ…”
The minister replied to this purpose, if not in the same words: that for his part he could comfortably partake with the church, and willingly would, but that it was possible some of his brethren of Scotland might take offense at his act. This he wished to avoid, because of the opinion held of us by the English churches with which they were in communion. He thanked Mr. Robinson, however, and asked for that reason only to watch us.
I was earnestly requested to publish these things to the world by some of the godly Presbyterian party. They believe the world to be ignorant of our proceedings, and judge in charity that if these had been known, some recent writers and preachers would never have written and spoken of us as they did, and still do as they have occasion. But what they ignorantly judge, write, or speak of us, I trust the Lord in mercy will pass by.
In the next place, as for the wholesome counsel that Mr. Robinson gave that part of the church of which he was pastor, at their departure from him to begin the great work of plantation in New England: among other wholesome instructions and exhortations, he used these expressions, or words to the same purpose. We were now before long to part from one another, and the Lord knew whether he should ever live to see our faces again. But whether the Lord had appointed it or not, he charged us before God and his blessed angels to follow him no further than he followed Christ. And if God should reveal anything to us by any other instrument of his, we were to be as ready to receive it as ever we were to receive any truth by his ministry. For he was very confident the Lord had more truth and light yet to break forth out of his holy Word.
He also took occasion to bewail most sorrowfully the state and condition of the Reformed churches, which had come to a full stop in religion and would go no further than the instruments of their reformation. For example, the Lutherans could not be drawn to go beyond what Luther saw; whatever part of his will God had further imparted and revealed to Calvin, they would rather die than embrace it. “And so also,” he said, “you see the Calvinists: they stick where he left them.” This is a misery much to be lamented. For though they were precious shining lights in their times, yet God had not revealed his whole will to them; and were they now living, he said, they would be as ready and willing to embrace further light as that which they had received.
Here also he put us in mind of our church covenant (at least that part of it) by which we promise and covenant with God and with one another to receive whatever light or truth shall be made known to us from his written Word. But at the same time he exhorted us to take heed what we received as truth, and to examine, compare, and weigh it well with other Scriptures of truth before we received it. “For,” he said, “it is not possible the Christian world should come so lately out of such thick antichristian darkness, and that full perfection of knowledge should break forth at once.”
Another thing he commended to us was that we should use all means to avoid and shake off the name of Brownist, which is a mere nickname and brand to make religion, and those who profess it, odious to the Christian world. “And to that end,” he said, “I should be glad if some godly minister would go over with you, or come to you, before my coming. For,” he said, “there will be no difference between the nonconforming ministers and you when they come to the practice of the ordinances outside the kingdom.” And so he advised us by all means to endeavor to unite with the godly party of the kingdom of England, and rather to study union than division; that is, how near we might possibly unite with them without sin, rather than in the least measure to seek division or separation from them. “And do not be loath to take another pastor or teacher,” he said, “for that flock that has two shepherds is not endangered, but secured by it.”
There were many other things of great and weighty consequence that he commended to us. But I thought good to relate these things at the request of some well-wishers to the peace and good agreement of the godly, who are at present so torn apart about the settling of church government in the kingdom of England. My aim is that both sides may truly see what this poor despised church of Christ, now at New Plymouth in New England but formerly at Leyden in Holland, was and is, and how far they were and still are from separation from the churches of Christ, especially those that are Reformed.
It is true that we profess and desire to practice a separation from the world, and from the works of the world, which are works of the flesh, such as the apostle speaks of (Gal 5:19-21; 1 Cor 6:9-11; Eph 2:11-12). And as the churches of Christ are all saints by calling, so we desire to see the grace of God shining forth (at least in appearance, leaving secret things to God) in all whom we admit into church fellowship with us, and to keep out such as openly wallow in the mire of their sins, so that neither the holy things of God nor the communion of the saints may be leavened or polluted by them.
And if any who joined us in the past, either when we lived at Leyden in Holland or since we came to New England, have professed a separation from the Church of England along with the declaration of their faith and profession of holiness, I have at various times, in both the one place and the other, heard either Mr. Robinson our pastor or Mr. Brewster our elder stop them at once. They showed them that we required no such thing at their hands, but only that they hold forth faith in Christ Jesus, holiness in the fear of God, and submission to every ordinance and appointment of God, leaving the Church of England to its own people and to the Lord, before whom they should stand or fall, and to whom we ought to pray to reform what was amiss among them.
Now this reformation we have lived to see performed and brought about in good measure this day by the mighty power of God, and I hope the Lord Jesus will perfect his work of reformation, until all is according to the good pleasure of his will. By all this I desire the reader to take notice of our former and present practice, notwithstanding all the injurious, scandalous, and taunting reports that have been passed on us.
And suppose these things will not satisfy, and we must still suffer reproach, and others for our sakes, because they and we walk in this way. Our practice is, for all we know, wholly grounded on the written Word, without any addition or human invention known to us. We take our pattern from the primitive churches as they were regulated by the blessed apostles in their own days, who were taught and instructed by the Lord Jesus Christ, and had the unerring and all-knowing Spirit of God to bring to their remembrance the things they had heard. I say, if we must still suffer such reproach, notwithstanding our charity toward those who will not be in charity with us, God’s will be done.
Those Who Differ in Religion
The next aspersion cast upon us is that we will not allow anyone who differs from us ever so little to reside or live among us; no, not even the Presbyterian government, which differs so little from us. To this I answer that our practice testifies to the contrary. For it is well known that Mr. Parker and Mr. Noyes, who are ministers of the church at Newbury, are of that way, and are known to be so, as far as it can be exercised in a single congregation. Yet they have never been troubled or disturbed in the least, and they have and find as good respect from magistrates and people as other elders in the Congregational or primitive way. It is known also that Mr. Hubbard, the minister at Hingham, has declared himself for that way. Indeed, and this is more than I ever heard of the other two, he turns away no child that is offered to him for baptism (although this liberty does not rest on a Presbyterian foundation), and yet the civil state has never molested him for it.
The only thing that happened was this. A synod was held in the country last year, which the magistrates called, requesting the churches to send their elders and such others as might be able to hold forth the light of God from his written Word, in the case of some doubts that had arisen in the country. Mr. Hubbard came to the last sitting of that assembly, which was adjourned to the eighth of June next. There he was requested, in all meekness and love, to be present at that next sitting and to show the light he went by in baptizing all who were brought to him, since in this he set aside the practice of the churches. He promised to take it into consideration, and they were content with his answer.
So also it is well known that before these unhappy troubles arose in England and Scotland, there were various gentlemen of Scotland, groaning under the heavy pressures of those times, who wrote to New England to learn whether they might freely be allowed to exercise their Presbyterian government among us. And the answer was yes, they might. They sent over a gentleman to look for some fit place, and their agent was shown a river called the Merrimack, near Ipswich and Newbury aforesaid, which he liked well. There we have since settled four towns, and more may be settled for all I know, so that there they might have had a complete presbytery. That was where they intended to come. But meeting with many setbacks when they were halfway across the seas, they gave up their intentions. And as I have heard, these were many of the gentlemen who first set on foot the late Covenant in Scotland. By all this it will easily appear how we are wronged here by many, and how harshly, as we hear, our brethren have been treated for our sakes, by people who even claim our example as their precedent.
And last of all, not long before I came away, certain discontented persons demanded that liberty in open court in Massachusetts. It was freely, and as openly, offered to them, and they were shown the former practices I have mentioned. But they were told not to expect that we should provide them ministers and so on for the purpose. If they got such men themselves, they might exercise the Presbyterian government at their liberty, walking peaceably toward us, as we trusted we should do toward them. So if our brethren here are restrained while they walk peaceably, the example must not be taken from us; it must arise from some other principle.
But will it not be objected: “Though you deal this way with the Presbyterian way, yet you have a severe law against Anabaptists. Indeed, one was whipped in Massachusetts for his religion. And does your law not banish them?”
Answer. It is true that the Massachusetts government has such a law, to banish, but not to whip, in that case. And when certain men desired some mitigation of it, this answer was given in my hearing: “It is true, we have a severe law, but we never did and never will execute the rigor of it upon anyone. We have men living among us, indeed some in our churches, of that judgment, and as long as they carry themselves peaceably, as they do so far, we will leave them to God, having ourselves performed the duty of brethren toward them. And as for the one who was whipped among us, it is true we knew what his judgment was. But had he not carried himself so contemptuously toward the authority God has entrusted us with, and in so high and public a measure, we would never have censured him in that way. And therefore he may thank himself, since he suffered as an evildoer in that respect. But the reason we are loath either to repeal or to alter the law is this: we would have it remain in force to bear witness against their judgment and practice, which we take to be erroneous.”
“And yet nevertheless,” said the Governor to those who presented the request, “you may tell our friends in England, where some of you are going, that since the motion comes from those who we know move it in love to us, we will seriously take it into consideration at our next General Court.” So you may see, good reader, that things of this kind are reported in the worst light.
Furthermore, in the government of Plymouth, to our great grief, not only does the pastor of one congregation set aside the administration of baptism to infants, but various members of his congregation have fallen away with him. And yet all the means the civil power has taken against him and them is to stir up our elders to meet with him and see whether by godly conference they may be able to convince and reclaim him, as in mercy they had once done before, by God’s blessing upon their labors. The only other step was at the synod mentioned above, where two men were ordered to write to him in the name of the assembly and to request his presence at their next meeting, to hold forth the light he goes by in setting aside the practice of the churches. They promised that if it proved to be light, they would walk by it; but if it appeared otherwise, they trusted he would return again to unity of practice with them. And as for the other two governments, of Connecticut and New Haven, if either of them has any law in force against such people, or so much as needs a law of that kind, it is more than I have heard of.
For our part (I mean the churches of New England), we are confident, through God’s mercy, that the way of God in which we walk, and according to which we perform our worship and service to him, agrees with the rules our blessed Savior has left on record by the evangelists and apostles. It also agrees with the practice of those primitive churches mentioned in the Acts and regulated by the same apostles, as appears not only in that gospel history but in their epistles to the various churches mentioned there. Yet nevertheless, if any through tenderness of conscience are otherwise minded, we never turn a deaf ear to them, nor become harsh, though we have the stream of authority on our side. Indeed, even if by every means we cannot reclaim them, we know that “the wisdom that is from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality, and without hypocrisy, and the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace, of them that make peace” (Jas 3:17-18). And if any who differ from us live in keeping with this rule in their lives and conduct, we do not exercise the civil sword against them.
But as for such as Gorton and his company, their wisdom seems not to be from above, as appears in that it is full of envyings, strife and confusion (Jas 3:15-16). In this they are such as the Apostle Jude speaks of: earthly, sensual, devilish; men who “despise dominion, and speak evil of dignities” (Jude 1:8). These “are murmurers, complainers, walkers after their own lusts, and their mouth speaketh great swelling words” (Jude 1:16), being “clouds without water, carried about of winds, trees whose fruit withereth, without fruit, twice dead, plucked up by the roots, raging waves of the sea, foaming out their own shame, wandering stars, to whom” (without repentance, which I greatly desire to see or hear of in him, if it may stand with the will of God) “is reserved the blackness of darkness for ever” (Jude 1:12-13). These, I say, are to be dealt with by another rule, and are not to be tolerated. They suffer as evildoers, and are a shame to the religion which they profess in word but deny in their lives and conduct. Every tender conscience abhors such men, and will justify and assist the “higher powers God hath ordained” (Rom 13:1) against such carnal gospelers. For the higher powers “bear not the sword in vain” (Rom 13:4), but execute God’s vengeance on such, since the civil magistrate is “the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath on him that doth evil.” And therefore a broad difference is to be put between such evildoers and those tender consciences who follow the light of God’s Word in their own persuasions (though judged erroneous by the places where they live), so long as their walk accords with the rules of the gospel, by preserving peace and holding forth holiness in their conduct among men.
This much I thought it good to make known, because we of New England are said to be so often held up as an example. And if any will take us as a precedent, I desire that they may truly know what we do, rather than what others ignorantly or maliciously report of us. I am confident that no one will ever be a loser by following us, so far as we follow Christ. That we may do so, and our descendants after us, may the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, and our Father, accept in Christ whatever is according to him; reveal, pardon and reform whatever is amiss among us; and guide us and them by the assistance of the Holy Ghost for all time to come, until time shall be no more. May the Lord our God still delight to dwell among his plantations and churches there by his gracious presence, and go on blessing, to bless them with heavenly blessings in these earthly places, so that by his blessing they may not only grow up into a nation but become an example of good to others. And let all who wish well to Zion say, Amen.
Finis
Keep this book
Free PDF/EPUB
It stays free to read here. Choose how you would like to take it with you.
One free account opens 400+ books and saves your place on every device. Google sign-in or an email link. No card.
Theme
Typeface
Size
Save your place
A free account remembers where you stopped, on your phone or at your desk, and adds the PDF/EPUB to your library.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Log in
Readers like you keep these books free
Every edition takes real work to modernize and record. One gift funds the next classic, with no subscription.
Supporters receive
All 153 audiobooks, now and future
The whole ebook library as one download
Support the work
Copied words
Take the whole book with you
Your passage is on your clipboard. If you want the full text to quote, print or read offline, the PDF/EPUB is free with an account.
Get the free PDF/EPUBGoogle sign-in or an email link. No card.
You are reading The Danger of Tolerating Levellers, free
Readers like you keep these books free
Every edition takes real work to modernize and record. One gift funds the next classic. No subscription.
- All 153 audiobooks, now and future
- The whole ebook library as one download
