Modernized edition · Full text · Free PDF/EPUB
Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons in Modern English
Want the file? The PDF/EPUB is free with an account.
Summary
- Author
- Grace Duffield Goodwin (1869 to 1926 AD), American writer and lecturer, president of the District of Columbia Anti-Suffrage Association
- Published
- 1913 AD, New York, Duffield and Company
- Source edition
- Goodwin's 1913 work, complete, in modern English
- Type
- Political handbook
- Length
- 15,000 words · 1 hours
What is Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons about?
Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons is Grace Duffield Goodwin's 1913 handbook against votes for women. Goodwin argues that “The ballot is not a right denied; it is a burden removed”, that suffrage would not cure the problems of industry, vice or property law, that sex is the dominant factor in the question, and that the suffrage states had shown no proof of the benefits claimed.
Read the full summary (10 points, key themes)Show less
How the argument unfolds
- 01
Introduction: the burden of proof. Those who seek a sweeping change must prove present evils and a sure remedy. Goodwin holds that women as a whole suffer no wrong that calls for overturning the nation's political machinery, and that the question is one of patriotism.
- 02
The ballot is not a right. There is no natural right to vote. The ballot is a responsibility laid on men, carrying jury duty and military service, and women are exempt because of their work for home and family.
- 03
Fundamental assumptions. Suffragists assume all women want the vote and that it will improve everything. Goodwin answers that only a small percentage want it and that a few capable women do more without it.
- 04
Foreign conditions. Australia, New Zealand, Scandinavia and Finland are no model for America, with its immigration and its recently enfranchised Black population, and the English militants are no guide to American law.
- 05
Four classes that constitute a menace. Black women in the South, foreign-born women, women of vice and the conscienceless woman politician would outvote the earnest minority.
- 06
Industry, vice and property. Wages follow economic law, the non-suffrage states have the better protective laws, vice persists in the suffrage states, and Massachusetts law already favors women over men.
- 07
Sex and sex antagonism. Motherhood, the nervous cycle and temperament leave women no surplus strength for politics, and a party of women against men would bring discord into the home.
- 08
Conditions in the suffrage states. Colorado, Utah, Idaho and Wyoming show weak labor laws, rising divorce and Mormon political power. A Colorado suffragist who had voted since 1893 says, “Frankly, the experiment is a failure.”
- 09
A suffrage platform answered. Goodwin replies to each of the eleven planks of the Woman Suffrage Party's 1911 New York platform, from representation and divorce to women judges and the English militants.
- 10
Conclusion. Women gain more by nonpartisan influence and by training their sons to honor the vote. Votes without force would be sovereignty without power, and the suffragists' methods condemn their cause.
Key themes
- The ballot as a burden. Goodwin treats voting as a duty laid on men, not a privilege kept from women: “It is conferred as a serious responsibility upon men who have fulfilled certain well-known conditions.”
- Protection over equality. Working women need special laws because they are future mothers, and equality would remove them. “They are in no way inferior to men; they are simply different from men”.
- Influence without the vote. Women who appear before legislatures with no party interest are heard more readily than voters would be. “Patriotism for a woman does not begin at the ballot box.”
- Proof from the suffrage states. The states where women vote are the test, and Goodwin finds no gain to match the cost: “The suffrage states must do better than this to show the non-suffrage states a reason why votes should be given to women.”
Reader questions (10)Hide the questions
Questions about Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons
Is there a modern English version of Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons?
Yes. This is Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons by Grace Duffield Goodwin in modern English. The language is modernized and the author's order and argument are kept. The full modernized text is free to read on this page.
Can I read Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons online for free?
Yes. The complete text of this modern English edition is on this page, with no sign-up or paywall.
Is there a free PDF of Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons?
Yes. The PDF and EPUB of this edition are free with an Updated Works account. Sign in with Google or an email link; no card is needed.
What is Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons about?
It is a handbook arguing against votes for women. Goodwin contends that the ballot is a burden from which women are exempt, that suffrage would not cure the problems of industry, vice or property law, that sex and temperament suit women for other work, and that the suffrage states had not proved the claims made for the vote.
When was it published?
It was published in New York by Duffield and Company in 1913 AD, seven years before the Nineteenth Amendment.
Who was Grace Duffield Goodwin?
Grace Duffield Goodwin (1869 to 1926 AD) was an American writer and lecturer who served as president of the District of Columbia Anti-Suffrage Association.
What are the ten reasons?
The ten chapters argue that the ballot is not a right, that the suffragists' assumptions are wrong, that foreign conditions are no basis for American action, that four classes of women voters would be a menace, that the vote would not help industry, vice or property rights, that sex is the dominant factor, that suffrage breeds sex antagonism, and that conditions in the suffrage states disprove the claims made for it.
Why does Goodwin say the ballot is not a right?
She holds that natural rights are rights to life and property, while the ballot is a man-devised instrument for expressing the popular will. It is a responsibility, with jury duty and military service attached, and women are excused from it because of their duties to home and family.
What does she say about the states where women already voted?
She finds that Colorado, Utah, Idaho and Wyoming lagged in labor laws for women and children, saw divorce rise and wages stay level, and gave the Mormon Church the balance of political power. She quotes a former Colorado suffrage worker who wished the women's vote abolished.
How long is the book?
The complete work runs to about 15,000 words, an hour or two of reading, in fourteen sections: an introduction, eleven chapters, a conclusion and a short note on membership figures.
Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons in Modern English · Full text
Introduction: The Burden of Proof
The demand for any sweeping and revolutionary change in existing conditions, whether political, industrial or religious, throws the burden of proof on the sponsors of such a change. Present evils must be clearly demonstrated, and the proposed remedies must hold out a reasonable hope of permanent betterment. The ardent supporters of the present demand for universal adult suffrage (the exact meaning of “votes for women”) are obliged to prove to American women their present evil condition, and to prove also that universal adult suffrage is the panacea.
The discussion in this book is concerned with answering the arguments of suffragists who claim the full rights of citizenship for all women. To fair-minded critics many of the arguments for limited female suffrage are plausible, and in some cases sound, such as those that call for a limited suffrage for women with educational and property qualifications. It must be remembered that twenty-six states in the Union have today some form of limited female suffrage. This suffrage, however, is of so little interest to the women concerned that the voting right is very rarely used. It is estimated that less than 2 percent of the New England women who are entitled and urged to vote on school matters ever take advantage of their opportunity.
Those who oppose the universal franchise for women put it to the men and women interested in this subject that suffragists do not advocate so sane a position as restricted suffrage. In this day of frenzied democracy, limited suffrage is not popular with men, much less with women. Suffragists desire full female citizenship with all the rights of men. It is against these wholesale claims that the anti-suffragists level their objections.
We who sincerely and seriously oppose the program offered by the suffragists unite in asking them to prove the evil condition of American women as a whole, and to demonstrate the remedial effect of the ballot when it is granted to women. We admit that under existing conditions individuals and groups frequently endure injustice. Women in the industrial world, as a group or class, suffer under heavy wrongs; individuals who own property and pay taxes with no voice in public matters suffer a form of injustice. Suffragists and anti-suffragists alike are eager to see these wrongs righted, but they differ seriously as to the means to this end. Nevertheless, we submit the proposition that American women, judged not by the individual, the group or the class, but as a whole, are suffering under no wrongs that require for their redress the violent overturning of the entire political machinery of the nation.
The following pages are intended to present a brief outline of the objections of a large and rapidly increasing number of women to an experiment fraught with so much danger to the body politic, so much danger to the possession of the many immunities and privileges granted to women in many of our states, so much danger to women themselves.
We have no desire to confuse the issue by comparing our position with that of women in other countries. Few American women can speak intelligently about matters so purely local. We desire to act as American conditions demand, and we refuse to be stampeded by the oratory of women from England or elsewhere, who prove by daily misstatement that they are not informed about American conditions or American laws.
Many women of this country are accepting English statements of American conditions and declaring themselves suffragists without intelligently considering for themselves the political situation and the industrial and legal conditions now prevailing in their own country.
The suffragists ask for the ballot on the ground that they are “human beings.” Anything so obvious is outside the bounds of discussion, but anti-suffragists constantly emphasize the equally undeniable fact of sex differentiation, with its many limitations. What will do for a man “human being” will not necessarily do for a woman “human being.” There is no neuter gender in our thought. We hold that sex is a dominant factor in this question of duties and of abilities.
The suffragists also offer the argument that this is a “race movement,” a “world movement,” from which they should not be excluded. The anti-suffragists contend that in this question it is absolutely necessary to ask how any world movement is going to work out in practice when it comes to a definite demonstration in the limited area of America, confronted with inexorable American facts. Theories are much easier than demonstrations. By their exalted sentimentalism the suffragists are plainly and persistently disregarding the only things that concern us in laying out a political program for our own country. They are evading the only imperative issue, which is: “How will this program affect this country and the women who make up half of its population?”
This is not a world question or a race question; it is a question of patriotism. This is a note seldom or never sounded in this difference of opinion. Patriotism consists in finding out what is good for America by intelligent thought, and in doing what is good for America by devoted service. Only as patriotism is kept alight can all the nations of the world be served. The “man without a country” has never been a world force.
A large number of women are indifferent and uninformed, and it is to help present a fair statement of the anti-suffrage position to such women that this handbook has been prepared. Confused thought and unconsidered speech are the order of the day. It is highly desirable for us all to bring our brains into the discussion of the question, and to subject our emotions, our enthusiasms and our sympathies to the control of our reasoning powers. A large part of the suffrage movement at present, in its fervor and fury, represents the acme of hysterical feminine thoughtlessness and unrest. The remainder represents the impractical idealism of that class of men and women whose ardor carries them lightly over the many difficulties that are insurmountable for those who will be called upon in the future to apply these roseate dreams to the common tasks of practical politics.
“Idealists have always led the world, never the average man or woman,” say the suffragists. What they say is true; but even idealists must have followers, and idealists who can inspire the average follower with a lofty hope must have something worthwhile to present. Only a great cause can command a leader of vision and a discipleship of obedience. The cause of woman suffrage, though deeply interesting, is not supremely urgent, and is in no way comparable to the liberating struggles for religious and political freedom that the world has sometimes seen. In its application it is only a question of method, a discussion of ways and means: the best ways, the most effective means, of attaining undefined and half-understood political ends in a huge and ill-balanced democracy struggling under the present burden of an already dangerously large electorate.
The Ballot Is Not a Right
In early days, long before the war, the great question of slavery aroused the interest of a few far-sighted American men and women, and such men as William Lloyd Garrison and Wendell Phillips went as delegates to an international abolition conference held in London. With them were appointed several brilliant women, friends and counselors of those men: Lucretia Mott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and others. On reaching London, the women were refused official recognition, which so incensed Garrison that he rose and left the hall. When the party returned to this country, the Woman’s Rights movement was launched, and for a while it swept the land like wildfire. The women rightly felt that they should have been allowed to vote on this important issue.
The agitation, therefore, had its origin among noble and brilliant people for great moral ends. In the passage of time it has gradually gathered to itself a younger group of adherents. They have forced it far beyond its original purpose. They have failed to notice the growing complication of political problems, and they cannot be made to realize that the great issues on which the original demand was based have so changed today that what was once a question of the best way to handle a moral issue has now become a question of the best way to handle party politics. At the present time this question of woman suffrage is not a question of one clear-cut moral issue, nor a question of the theory of government or the philosophy of government, but simply and solely a question of politics. Given the highly specialized profession of politics, the “great game,” as it is now played in this country, will the entrance of women into the field make it better or worse? By doubling the electorate, and therefore, according to the law of averages, coming out with conditions very little changed, can we hope to do anything more than make an already difficult task more difficult?
“Educating by means of the ballot” is an experiment to be tried slowly, and not by throwing a mass of indifferent and inexperienced voters into our electorate. Those who steadily oppose this experiment consider it far too difficult and dangerous to be thrust upon a nation that has so recently won its title to be considered a world power. America is a vigorous young leader in the family of nations. It should not have its progress checked by rash ventures that touch the very foundations of its governmental life.
In considering this question fairly, we must understand that there is no such thing as a “natural right” to the ballot. Natural rights are rights to life, property, and the like; the ballot is a man-devised instrument for the peaceful expression of the popular will in government. It is conferred as a serious responsibility upon men who have fulfilled certain well-known conditions. Women are made exempt from the exercise of political responsibility in view of the duties toward home and family that they are performing for the benefit of the state. The ballot is not a right denied; it is a burden removed. The “imbecile and criminal” argument is nothing but cheap and superficial claptrap. Great confusion has existed on this point, but there is really no reason at all for anything but an acknowledgment of the facts.
Since the ballot is a responsibility, if we demand it and receive it, we must be prepared to accept all that it entails. The state, too, must be prepared to accept the difficulties and dangers that will arise from a sudden and great enlargement of the voting body.
We have been told, even by such men as the late Senator Hoar, that if women receive the franchise they may vote or not, as they wish. This is not the original conception of the duty of a voter. Men are never taught so. Everywhere they are urged to vote, and the pulpits of the land make the casting of a ballot a patriotic and religious duty. The late former Governor Utter of Rhode Island claimed that one of the greatest dangers will be the enlargement of the indifferent class, the busy, middle-class tradesman and housekeeper. Men of this type, he said, are already a great drag on elections, and always have to be brought to the polls by those interested in “getting out the vote.”
The ballot carries with it the duty of bearing arms in time of war, and of jury duty in times of peace. If women are granted the ballot, the governmental system will have to be reconstructed to free us from these duties, or we shall have to attend to them while doing our own distinctive and nontransferable tasks. Mr. William Allen’s frivolous argument in his Woman’s Part in Government, to the effect that any woman who can struggle with the crush at the Brooklyn Bridge can bear arms, is wide of the mark. Absence from home and children during prolonged jury service will not materially help the state. Women everywhere today are suffering from exhaustion of vital force, due to the incessant demands of a life crowded with claims outside the home, whether in social obligations and philanthropic or civic interests, or in the taxing strain of industrial life. Between these two comes the large percentage of American women, far larger than any other class, who need all their strength for necessary household tasks. The watchful and intelligent observer fails to see any surplus of strength to be spent in a man’s way for the good of the state. What he does see is the good of the state seriously menaced at its source by the inroads upon feminine vitality that will be made when political duties are added to those laid upon our shoulders, first by nature, second by a highly developed civilization. This applies not so much to those women who would be content merely to vote as to that large class which, in its natural desire for power and publicity, would inevitably “enter politics.”
The suffragists remind us that the political burden is not heavy for the average man; that he spends very little time and energy in governing his country. In every community, however, from village to city, there are men who “handle the politics,” and who give up their lives to it, degrading themselves as bosses and grafters, or wearing themselves out as reformers. The same number of women would in all probability do the same things, because every class of men has either a corresponding or a potentially corresponding class of women, and this proportion of women is too large to be needlessly sacrificed.
The “woman in politics” is not a menace of the future. She has appeared, and if she is a type, it is instructive to look at her and see where more politics will lead. Women in politics are like men in politics: so testify Judge Lindsey and General Irving Hale, both of Colorado. They are good, bad and indifferent, with the added emphasis of the tendency to the extreme inherent in all women. So a woman corrupt in politics has been shown to be worse than a man. A woman has been known, in order to gain political ends, to offer what is euphemistically, but quite clearly, described as the “new bribery.” That is an abyss of horror into which only the lowest will fall, but into which the lowest will fall, as they fell in the days of the Roman decadence. We cannot afford to have any woman so besmirched.
In considering this question it is well to observe all its aspects. The opponents of suffrage for women are deeply convinced that there are elements of danger for some women that all women should consider, and elements of danger for the state that should be a matter of consideration for both men and women, before we commit this country, unique in history and in composition, to an experiment in which there is undeniable danger both to government and to women.
A Difference in Fundamental Assumptions
The demand that women be allowed an equal part with men in the tasks of government is based upon two assumptions: first, that all women desire such a share of the political burden, or can be induced to desire it; and second, that all conditions will be greatly improved by granting suffrage to women. Were the premises correct, the conclusion would be obvious. Without a proper investigation of these assumptions, the conclusion that women must be enfranchised, and speedily, is made the basis of a propaganda that is everywhere arousing the opposition of thoughtful men and women. After a study of the assumptions, these men and women are unwilling, and intellectually unable, to be drawn to any such conclusion.
There are various estimates of the percentage of American women who favor suffrage for women. Mayor Gaynor of New York says “less than 2 percent.” Dr. Meyer, the bibliographer of the Library of Congress, thinks it less than 4 percent, which is the percentage given by the women of Massachusetts in the referendum of 1895. From time to time the treasurer of the National Suffrage Association has stated the number of dues-paying members of the National Association. The figures necessarily vary, but at best they represent a small proportion of the population of the country. In February 1912, Miss Ashley said that a “rough estimate” of the American women favoring suffrage is 3,000,000. Figures for the 1910 census give very nearly 92,000,000 for the population of continental America, and estimate about 46,000,000 of these as females. Miss Ashley’s estimate and the census figures probably include many under voting age, as suffrage has made remarkable strides in this country among very young women.
The only way to obtain figures for the number of women interested in a certain cause is to find them by means of those women’s clubs that have joined the National Federation, and to compute the attendance at meetings devoted to the cause. But such a claim, made by any organization, must necessarily be subjected to revision, as it cannot take into account the large number of women unconnected with clubs, or the large number of clubs that never consent to unite with a central organization. As for attendance, it is well to remember that not all who go to a meeting will necessarily feel bound to support its object.
Anti-suffragists ask that American women be considered as a unit, and that, so far as possible, the necessary reductions be allowed. It is evident, no matter what the basis of the percentage computation, that the suffragists make up only a handful of the entire number. Those who are sufficiently interested in the cause to pay the fee of a dollar a year have earned the name of “conscious suffragists,” the implication being that the rest of the 3,000,000 are unconscious suffragists. The women who do not desire suffrage are asking why so small a number should seek to thrust upon the majority, who are opposed, or indifferent, or completely ignorant of the matter, something that this majority does not desire. So radical a political change should be the result of nothing but a strong popular demand, which in this case is quite lacking.
The existing demand in America, aggressively as it is presented, has nevertheless been artificially stimulated by women from other countries. Such enthusiasm, such fervor, such excitement are contagious, and we were not properly quarantined by sound judgment; therefore we are suffering from a mild but irritating form of the international disorder.
The second assumption, that all conditions in the state will be greatly benefited by women’s exercise of the voting power, must be proved before it can be accepted. The fact that we have, as yet, no sufficient proof from the suffrage states is discussed in the chapter on conditions in the suffrage states. The anti-suffragists base their conclusion upon very different assumptions. The first is that the majority of women are opposed or indifferent, and that if they are swept in by misdirected enthusiasm, they will be a menace rather than an aid. The things that people do not wish to do, or that they are compelled to do, are always badly done. The second is that the state will be harmed and not helped by doubling its present electorate, adding to its present voting force a large number of unintelligent or careless voters and a small number of thinking and competent women. These women without the ballot are far more effective in dealing with matters of the public good than they would be if they were struggling to outvote an overwhelming number of people who have no concern whatever beyond their immediate convenience or interest. In moral power the small minority might be equal to many thousands; with the ballot each woman counts as one, and no more.
These are the opposite grounds on which women interested in this question are taking their respective positions. They are fundamentally different. We who are actively opposed to suffrage are willing to state as briefly and clearly as possible our reasons for the position that we hold and that we are forcing upon public attention today through our National Association Opposed to the Suffrage for Women. Although it is of very recent origin, the Association is growing with almost startling rapidity.
Foreign Conditions Are No Basis for American Action
Women who consider this matter are easily confused when the suffragists ask us to note the ever-growing popularity of universal suffrage in other lands. Australia, New Zealand, Scandinavia and Finland are all thrown into the discussion with a reckless disregard of one very obvious truth, a truth which makes all the rest of the argument of no avail. That truth is the simple fact that this is America, and that America is like no other country on the face of the earth. It has problems and dangers and difficulties peculiarly its own. A political step which might be quite desirable for Australia, where they beg for immigration, would be totally unsuited to a nation which receives hundreds of thousands of potential citizens from Europe every year, many of whom are integral parts of our body politic within five years. New Zealand has no population, running up into the millions, that was enslaved and enfranchised in the same generation. A canton of Switzerland has a somewhat different problem from the one that faces Rhode Island, with its 64 percent either foreign-born or the children of foreigners, or Georgia, with its Black people outnumbering white people by nine to one in some of the rural communities.
The problems of England are entirely her own. She is struggling for the right to do her own deciding, while threatened on one hand with a widespread and dangerous industrial disturbance, and harassed on the other by the insistent demands for the parliamentary suffrage on the part of stone-throwing, riotous, spectacular women, who incite one another to every frenzy of hysterical lawlessness. The women of England began by asking for better property rights and better divorce laws. Now they do not know just what their grievances are; all they know is that they want “Votes for Women.”
In America, many states have fair property laws for women, many have such legislation pending, and in no state in America do women need to throw stones or fire pistols to secure fair treatment.
The uniform divorce law, which would solve so many of our problems and prevent so much wrong and injustice, is making only slow progress, owing, among other causes, to the determined opposition of the very women who have the most to gain from its general enactment.
In no foreign country do conditions parallel our own. We have a large and unwieldy democracy, still scarcely beyond the experimental stage. Its success is not yet that assured and splendid vindication of our initial policy which it will undoubtedly become if we give it time and refuse to entangle it with further difficulties. Once and for all, women who are opposed to the extension of the suffrage decline to be stampeded by arguments which in no way apply to the political conditions in our own country.
Four Classes That Constitute a Menace
We are a nation of unsolved problems. Brains and time and patience are going into their solution. The problem of the Black American and the problem of the alien are ours alone. No other nation shows a condition in which these two difficulties exist side by side and press for solution at the same time. At present no one is bold enough to say that we are finding it easy to assimilate the sorrowful legacy of our own greed and inhumanity: the race of struggling children just “up from slavery,” confused and bewildered even yet by the sufferings of the past, the burden of the present and the blind ambitions of the future. Our Black Americans are not yet woven into the fabric of our common life, and they have not yet ceased to be a political menace. In the Southern states, white control is held only by the frankest bribery: the latest census bulletin by race gives Georgia 1,431,816 white people to 1,176,987 Black, and the population of South Carolina is 55.2 percent Black and that of Mississippi 56.2 percent. There it is proposed to add, for further exploitation and bribery, all the Black women, who are more helpless and ignorant than the men. This is said with full awareness of the numbers of Black men and women who are far beyond the average of their people. One has only to see the race close at hand to recognize its sterling virtues and its dangerous weaknesses: virtues of sympathy, patience, cheerfulness and loyalty; weaknesses of moral fiber and of mental grasp.
We have the problem of the immigrant, who has come here by the millions in the last decade. He comes from different political conditions, new to republicanism, new to responsibility, new to freedom, which in the exuberance of the second generation he misreads as “license.” He clings to his own, and in all our cities he makes a ghetto, or a Little Italy, or a settlement like that of the 50,000 Bohemians in New York, settlements that are not American in any particular. He populates the streets of the New England mill towns, until in Rhode Island one may walk perhaps two or three blocks without hearing a word of English. In five years he is a citizen; in five years he is expected, with the pressure of terrible toil upon him, to learn the language, the customs and the ideals of his future home, and to become a unit in its government. As a matter of fact, the majority toil incessantly, learn very little, are exploited by the ward boss, and know little and care less about the government of their adopted country. What we are doing to make him worthy of citizenship is only a drop in the bucket compared with his numbers and his need. We must put time and brains into the problem of the foreign man as a voter. How will it help to add the foreign woman? All who work among these people recognize how much more backward the foreign woman is than the foreign man. Many of the women live in this country for years without even learning the language. This is not true of the younger generation, which tends toward irreligion and lawlessness. The reaction does not set in until the third generation, as those who have lived and worked among them know well. The older and the younger foreign women, for very different reasons, would add greatly to the danger of the naturalized foreign vote. Since we are constantly receiving them, and since their quality is steadily deteriorating, we will have this to consider for many years to come. The suffragist proposes to double these two problems.
We have, in common with all countries, the problem of the woman of vice, numbered in our cities by the thousands. The suffragists tell us that these women will not vote, and that they will not register because they do not want publicity. But they are already registered on the lists kept by the police in many cities. They are not classed as criminals, only as potentially so. They would not shrink from registration, and the men who exploit them would see to it that they voted. Not long ago I said to a woman of this class, “Do you want to vote?” “Yes,” she replied. “Why?” I asked. “What would you do with the ballot?” “God!” she breathed, raising tragic arms above her head, “I’d sell it and take a vacation!”
Another problem in all countries is that of the intelligent, conscienceless woman. She exists, and she is the companion of the intelligent, conscienceless man who plays politics “for what there is in it,” here in America to an extent perhaps found nowhere else in the world. He is the man who makes the public shame of Philadelphia or Pittsburgh, or Denver, or San Francisco, or Adams County, Ohio. His is the shame of every American city and town that submits to the rule of the boss and the ring, that has political axes to grind and political trades to make.
Set against these four classes of undesirable voters among women would be the comparatively small number of earnest, intelligent women capable of handling public affairs. They would be overwhelmed by numbers.
The Ballot and Industry
When the suffragists carry the working girl a handbill that reads “Demand Votes for Women and have your wages raised,” they can rightly be charged with dangerous misrepresentation. The idea the workers receive, and which they have expressed when questioned, is that if they could vote at all, they could vote themselves shorter hours and higher wages. The suffragist takes no pains to explain to these girls the difficult and roundabout route that must be traveled before the man they vote for can secure a voice in legislation that will react upon the markets of the world and, by increasing or diminishing demand, raise or lower wages. Even then, wages will move only if all the heads of one industry can be induced to see the wage matter in the same light at the same time. There are many “ifs” between the ballot and a general raised-wage standard.
A truism that the suffragists calmly disregard is that wages depend on economic law. If there is no market for the goods, production must be curtailed and wages will be lowered; if there is a market, there may be good wages and overtime work. If many want the same kind of employment and there is sharp labor competition, wages will fall; if few, wages will rise. If cotton is infested with the boll weevil and is therefore high-priced, wages shrink, because the manufacturer cannot afford to lose at both ends of the scale. There are a thousand conditions governing the thousand and one manufacturing interests, or any other employment interest, and they make the wage question one that can never have a hard-and-fast decision.
Massachusetts is making an experiment of great interest with the minimum wage (already a law in England, passed by men only), because an investigation touching nearly 14,000 working women revealed that approximately half of those employed in candy factories and laundries received less than five dollars a week. The grave danger is that the enforcement of such a law will act by pulling down the higher wage standard, reducing the pay of the efficient worker while it raises the wage standard of others, many of whom are in the inefficient class. Proportionate wage-raising in any but large businesses would probably be impossible. It may be that some will not live so well in order that others may live better. The burden that it is desired to put on the shoulders of the employer will probably be slipped off, as usually happens, onto the shoulders of the workers themselves. This will be a shift; it is not certain that it will be a solution. If it should happen that the wages of skilled workers, deservedly high, are lowered in order that the wages of the unskilled may be raised, where will the justice be for the high-grade worker? These edged tools have an uncomfortable habit of cutting both ways.
In the majority of cases the labor unions could protect their men, but it would be at the cost of the employer’s entire independence. These labor unions, with all their mistakes and the glaring faults of many of their leaders, have come, and come to stay. In women’s trades, however, with which both suffrage and anti-suffrage women are concerned, the unions find organization extremely difficult. Many of the workers can neither speak the language nor grasp the idea presented.
Only one-fifth of our American women are in “gainful occupations,” and 32 percent of these are under twenty-one. Forty-five percent cease to be wage earners at twenty-five. They do not intend to make a lifework of their business, and so the element of impermanence enters. The girls expect to marry and have homes. As they do so, an endless procession of the unskilled and uninterested passes before the employer’s eyes. He is constantly training new and ignorant workers. The men are permanent, and they are paid for their permanence and their increasing skill. This is true of the New England textile mills, and it offers a fair standard for a general statement.
Now the question of equal pay for men and women, to be secured by the ballot, comes in. Men and women do not receive the “same pay for the same work,” because every employer knows that they seldom do the same work. Women’s work is put at a disadvantage by this unskilled procession of temporary workers. Witness the changes made by the removal of women from the offices of five great railroad systems. Women teachers in New York have won their fight to secure the same pay as men, but the salaries allotted to men were reduced from $900 to $750, and the salaries of women raised from $600 to $750. The sufferers were men, many of whom had families to support.
Men and women have been counted the country over as so many units: so many women teachers against so many men teachers, wages so-and-so. As a matter of fact, by far the greater burden of responsibility rests upon the men, as they fill the larger number of important positions, leaving the lower-grade work to women. When they are not doing the same work, why should they receive the same pay? When, as in Chicago, a woman is Superintendent of Schools and does her work as well as a man, or better than he, she should be paid in proportion, and examination will show that she is. It is the work that should count, its amount and quality, not its sex-stamp. In Utah, with the vote, teachers receive less than in New York without it, as Minnie Bronson, twice a special agent of the federal Bureau of Labor, shows in her discussion of teachers’ wages in The Wage Earning Woman and the State (1912).
In the New York shirtwaist strike of 1909–10, a noted suffragist told the strikers that the strike would have been unnecessary if they had had the ballot. Miss Bronson, at that time a special agent for the Bureau of Commerce and Labor in Washington, tells us these facts: 40 percent of the strikers were men; 60 percent of the remainder were under twenty-one; and 25 percent of all the women of voting age had not been in this country long enough to acquire a residence. How would the possession of the ballot have helped this situation? These women, under their grievous wrongs, do not need to be hustled into the voting body, where they will not know enough to help intelligently. They need the protection of laws made by an electorate as free as possible from corrupt and ignorant voters, an electorate with sense enough to elect men who understand the workings of economic laws in relation to labor conditions, if we are to hold to the American tradition of “representative government.” This may be slow progress and may provoke the impatience of many, but it will be far surer progress than trying to get a hopelessly cumbersome electorate to strive for an unassimilated mass of new legislation, legislation that refuses to take account of the other factors which must necessarily enter in and alter conditions.
The fact is that the more progressive states in the Union, which as yet are states of manhood suffrage only, are rapidly enacting legislation for the protection of women and children. All of these laws are “man-made”; therefore some suffragists have said that they “would not live under them.” Law, whether made by man or by woman, is as impersonal as religion. Neither bears the imprint of sex, and if a law is good, it does not matter at all who made it. The aim is good law.
These increasingly good laws have been greatly aided by the influence of women appearing before legislatures and committees, without the ballot, to urge impersonal ends. Their motives could not be impugned. The suffrage states are behind in the enactment of labor legislation affecting women and children, although Colorado now has good child labor laws. Thirty-one states now limit the hours of labor. As Miss Bronson shows in the same work, Colorado has an eight-hour law for women but no week-hour law and no law prohibiting night work, so it is of little real value. Thirty-nine states require seats for women at work; one suffrage state does not. Sixteen states, all non-suffrage, prohibit night work. In the two years from 1908 to 1910, 54 laws for women and children were enacted by the legislatures of 32 states, and these were all non-suffrage states. Miss Bronson says, “There are more and better laws for the protection of women wage-earners in the non-suffrage states than in states where women have the ballot. Possessing the ballot, the woman who works must stand on an equality with men, and ask no favors; must accept the conditions imposed upon her by the law of supply and demand, and give as much toil as he, although no increase in physical vitality will respond to this demand.” This is not equality of the sexes; it is “speeding up” the woman to the breaking point to make her reach man’s physical level. If he were reduced to hers, the work of the world would be seriously handicapped.
Women in industry must be taken care of, for the sake of the future of the nation. The way to take care of them is not to give them something which, while it makes them politically equal to men, puts them where they cannot ask for special privileges or special legislation without admitting their physical and industrial inferiority. They are in no way inferior to men; they are simply different from men, and because of this difference they must work under better and more comfortable conditions. When industrial favors are granted, they must be granted to women; when anyone is saved in this cruel industrial conflict, it must be women. The children of the next generation furnish the unanswerable reason. The world is only now awakening to the dangers of industrial life for women and for their children who are yet to be. It has not had time to grasp the situation. The rapidity with which every great country is now working in this field proves that it will be fairer to give men a chance to solve this problem, and to offer women all the safety in their power, before the men’s effort is crippled. It will be crippled by the hasty entrance into the situation of many women who will so complicate matters as to compel the men to turn from solving this difficulty and give all their time to the general readjustment that will be imperatively demanded.
Voting will not help a woman to do as much work as a man or as hard work as a man, or to receive the same wages as a man. Employers in all justice ought to pay for results, not pay the same price for differing grades of work because the law compels them to. The complex civilization that has forced women into industry is endeavoring to protect them in it, but the whole problem is new. Individual wrongs are so apparent that unthinking women would rush into the inevitably false situation by saying, “Give us the vote; we will vote shorter hours; we will vote equal pay.” In effect they would be saying: we will by our votes give women a harder time than they are having now; we will repudiate privilege with one breath and demand it with the next; and by our equality we will stamp inequality indelibly upon the industrial world.
“That is where it should be stamped,” say the anti-suffragists. In the very nature of the case, the conditions of industrial life bear hardest upon women. They are the potential mothers; they must have special privileges, and, we repeat, they must be specially guarded, or the men and women to come will be born mortgaged to disease, deformity and defeat. But what becomes of equality? It vanishes, with other false assumptions.
The Ballot and Vice
The suffragists claim that the ballot in the hands of women will cleanse our national life of the dread evils of intemperance and prostitution. If this were so, there would not be an anti-suffragist in America. The women who live by prostitution would thrust it out if they dared to face the simple question of starvation. Just as the claim that votes will raise wages betrayed confused thinking about politics and industry, so this claim betrays confused thinking about politics and ethics. Public sentiment, the result of an aroused public conscience, goes before the law and follows after it. No law can be made or enforced without such sentiment. The terrible weaknesses of human nature stand in the way of prohibition and of the abolition of the social evil.
These dread things still exist in the suffrage states, and several of those states have had from sixteen to forty-two years for experiment and proof. Our only sure knowledge of what can be done must be based on what has been done. If it cannot be done in small and sparsely settled communities (and we must do women the justice to suppose that they are unable, and not indifferent or unwilling), how is it to be accomplished in regions with dense populations and congested cities, where these evils are strongest?
The non-suffrage states are in many cases making a strong fight on both of these questions, and the church and the medical profession are being called on to help. Miss Jane Addams of Chicago, insisting that fear be used as a motive since higher appeals have failed, has offered the most sensible advice that has been given regarding the social evil. In effect, she proposes, as its solution, to take it out of the ethical realm, where it belongs but where apparently it can never be fought out, and hand it over to the boards of health. This sensible advice will never be followed, because of the many people in this country who are too much concerned with theoretical good and evil and their ideal treatment to be willing to take up a difficult problem by the first available handle.
The country is thoroughly awake to the evils of the white slave traffic. Laws relating to it are being made and enforced, and vice commissions everywhere are laying bare the conditions that each city and state must solve according to its own light. The problem of the unwilling victim is different from the problem of the willing participant. On many of these matters we always speak as if federal action were a possibility. As a matter of fact, action on all these questions depends on the states themselves. Let the suffrage states lead the way. Let them give us a practical demonstration of communities that have cleansed themselves by the votes of women. Let them prove their contention by abolishing these terrifying evils in Utah, Idaho, Wyoming, Washington, Colorado and California.
Let them begin their fight for purity by unmasking whatever impurity in the guise of religion still lingers in that long-suffering state where the violation of the old principle of separate Church and State has so long been a disgrace to our American ideals and traditions. Let them continue it in those other states where the Mormon Church holds the balance of political power. Let them free the women who live under the slavery of priestly control, a slavery no less to be feared because religious women yield to it willingly. For many years Mormonism has been branded as a direct menace to American institutions, and to marriage and the family as Americans understand these things. Hundreds of thousands of women petitioned against the seating of Senator Reed Smoot. Mormonism was on trial, and the unsavory testimony is on record in Washington. In the face of these facts we ask: where is woman’s powerful political influence, secured to her by the ballot, to be seen in the purification of those states in which she is the equal of man in affairs of state?
Property Rights and the Loss of Women’s Legal Protections
We are told that women need the ballot to secure their property rights; to protect their wages or their incomes; to enable them to share the guardianship of their children; to permit them to engage in gainful occupations and conduct independent businesses. We are told this chiefly by English suffragists, who are so touchingly unaware of our laws that they imagine us to be living under intolerable tyranny. Because they suffer injustice, they take it for granted that we do too. It is high time for us to understand and to state those laws which make the majority of American women quite content with their lot in this respect.
All American law is based on what is known as the English Common Law. It is an inheritance from the time when rough justice kept partial pace with rough conditions, when it was considered a great step forward to put a woman and all her belongings under the control of some one man, her husband or her nearest of kin, so that she might not be freely despoiled or stripped of her property at the will of someone whom she was physically unable to resist. The Common Law came with our fathers to America, and gradually, with changing conditions, it has been changed and enlarged until today very few of the old provisions remain in any of the states. Some states have made many changes, some few; but all are yielding gradually to the pressure of the times. The provisions which once protected a woman, and which were meant for her good and not for her harm, read today like the gravest injustice. Women who neither read nor think are grasping at the surface words, failing to recognize both the original meaning and the speed with which the new demands are stamping themselves on the legislation of today.
The laws of Massachusetts are so favorable to women that one is tempted to drop a sympathetic tear for the oppressions of the Massachusetts man. The volume called Woman Under the Law of Massachusetts, by Henry Sprague, offers instructive reading. Many of the women’s property-rights laws of Ohio and of Maine were framed on these Massachusetts laws, while New York and Pennsylvania, as well as other states, have many of the Massachusetts provisions. In many of the New England states the old rights of “curtesy and dower” are still in force, the dower right protecting a woman and the right of “curtesy” protecting a man. It is a fallacious argument for anti-suffragists to point out that these rights do not hold in the suffrage states, because there they have been replaced by other laws providing for the rights of both man and woman on an equal basis. All states are struggling to bring the laws relating to the property rights of women up to the standard of present-day conditions, but the impatience of the suffrage agitators will neither admit this nor give time for it to be rationally accomplished. A law is not made as quickly and easily as a loaf of bread or a baby’s dress. In this matter the non-suffrage states are far in the lead because they do not compel women to a legal equality with men. Many of them offer “immunities and privileges” which frankly assume that the woman is the weaker, and needs her material affairs looked after with care and generosity. She will, of course, be willing to surrender these many privileges and take her place as man’s financial equal in the eyes of the law if she is given the ballot, but it will bear very heavily on her all the same!
Here are a few of the provisions of the Massachusetts law, in which women are freed from certain “disabilities” (the poll tax, military and jury duty, and so on) and are granted certain “immunities and privileges.” The volume referred to above gives a complete list.
A woman is not “legally of age at eighteen,” as is always supposed, but at marriage, and a married woman of any age may sign a deed or make a will.
She holds her property free, provided she keeps it separate.
Her clothing and her ornaments are secured to her from the demands of creditors.
Life insurance money cannot be taken from her for debt.
A woman may engage in business and make contracts apart from her husband; she may be a “sole trader” under the act of that name.
Husband and wife cannot make valid gifts to each other in default of creditors, but a wife may receive up to $2,000 without liability, while her husband may not.
Homestead rights are all in favor of women.
A woman may hold her property as a single woman if her husband is in prison, or if she is separated from him for good cause. He may not do this.
A woman is under no legal obligation to provide for her family, no matter how large her income. Her husband is bound to support the wife, their children, and his stepchildren if he has ever in any way treated them as a parent, no matter how little he may have done so.
The wife may use her husband’s credit to its limit for “necessities,” and the court will take her unsupported word as to what constitutes a “necessity” for her. He has no such privilege.
The law compels a husband to supply his wife with money to maintain a lawsuit against him.
If she engages in illegal business, the law holds him responsible, and not her.
If she commits a “minor crime” and he is anywhere about, he is the one to blame, and Mr. Sprague adds, “recent statutes enlarging the rights and privileges of married women have not relieved the husband from his responsibility for his wife’s criminal and illegal actions.”
Parents are equal guardians of children, and a woman’s wages are entirely her own, free from taxation.
In these cases men and women are not “equal before the law,” as the suffragists want them to become; instead, women are specially favored. We now note this interesting fact. The women who are asking for the ballot are the very ones who are saying that these laws must not be changed in any particular, but that backward states should enact similar legislation. The idea, translated into everyday speech, seems to be, “We want to have our cake and eat it, too. We want a man’s rights and a woman’s privileges.”
Sex as a Dominant Factor
The work of the world, slowly differentiated through the centuries, has always shown in its general division this “rough justice” of which we have spoken. Only among primitive peoples did women do the work we now call “man’s work,” or share with man such labors as belonged to his place and time, a condition of things scarcely comparable to that of a highly civilized people in a highly complex social system. But women are now asking to go back to the old standards: to fight if necessary, to render judgments, to make laws. And they suggest that it is no more their business than it is a man’s to care for the children. They have made long scientific excursions to cite instances of sole paternal responsibility for offspring in the lower orders of nature.
And yet the fact remains that sex is the dominant factor in this problem. Until the end of all things, men and women are going to be fathers and mothers. By declaring, with one of the suffrage leaders, that “wifehood and motherhood are incidental relations,” the women who are carried away by this bit of insanity are hastening that “end of all things” to quite a noticeable degree. Colleges have occasionally declared marriage to be a lamentable end to a woman’s “career,” a sad falling off from the “higher life.” Talking will not change matters, nor will argument eradicate the fact that as long as the race has a mother, that mother will have to be a woman. And if a woman is not a mother, she has failed, either voluntarily or involuntarily, to do the only thing for which, in the original scheme of creation, she was intended.
Therefore the assuming of political duties, as many women must assume them if the franchise is granted to all properly qualified adults, must be not substitutional but additional. We cannot wholly, nor even in large measure, evade our own duties and responsibilities, and to these we must add the burdens and duties of men. There is nothing in a woman’s natural duty that a man can do as well as a woman. Yet, with amusing arrogance, women claim that they will easily be able to do the work in which men have been specially trained for centuries: to do this work as well as men, or better than men, and to do their own at the same time.
Let us just state frankly a few things that every woman knows. During all the vigorous period of a woman’s life she labors under distinct disabilities on account of her sex; it trips her up at every turn. Many women are in a constant state of rebellion because they absolutely must take some sort of care of themselves or be invalided out of the race. In carrying out political plans, in attending political conventions, in doing jury duty, a woman will be at the mercy of her nature. For one whole year, if a new life is to emerge, she is unfit to assume the added risk of overstraining her normally taxed nervous system. Maternity is an exhibition of a woman’s nervous system taxed to a normal limit, and normally entirely equal to the strain. But while pregnancy is not a pathological condition, it is the limit of nerve-tax. Presumably there are other children and a home. How much more ought a woman to do?
And for every woman, married or single, during the greater part of her life, there is the plain and unchangeable fact that she lives in a periodic nervous cycle, when the life-forces are normal, below normal, and normal again, and that during the below-normal period she is again very nearly at the nervous limit. Why pretend that these things are negligible? Every woman knows they are not, but she fears the derision of other women if she admits it. Where, then, is her surplus strength? Where is the extra force to be spent in political excitements?
Every student of industrial conditions, everyone who tries to wrestle with the new science of eugenics, recognizes that the danger to the working girl that transcends all other dangers is the danger to her motherhood, and that the paramount danger to the state in her industrial life is the loss of so many potential mothers. For the great wheels eat up the nerve-forces of a woman’s life; the standing and the treading are perilous to her feminine powers. The state should save the working women and the little children for purely selfish motives, if for no higher. It is ridiculous extravagance to let private greed exploit the headwaters of the stream of the nation. We conserve Niagara, and throw away young American girlhood. As a nation we appear to have no sense of proportion. But to save one part of our womanhood it is not necessary to sacrifice another. Earnest men, and intelligent, nonpartisan women who plead without the possibility of a suspected dishonorable motive, are awake to the situation. They will solve the difficulty if they are not handicapped by having the ballot thrust upon all women, who cannot accomplish with it the purely moral and humanitarian results that can be secured without it.
Francis Parkman recognizes and states another phase of the sex-danger: “Without a radical change in human nature,” he says, “of which the world has never given the faintest sign, women cannot be equally emancipated [with men]. It is not a question of custom or habit or public opinion, but of an all-pervading force, always formidable in the vast number of men in whom it is not controlled by higher forces.”
There is also a temperamental difference between men and women that makes an equal footing in political life all but impossible. Whatever woman may have had in the past, whatever she may be going to have in the future, at the present moment she has great temperamental disabilities.
The average woman has as much brains as the average man, and average persons are going to do the greater part of the voting. But woman lacks endurance in things mental; her fortitude is physical and spiritual. She lacks nervous stability. The suffragists who dismay England are nerve-sick women.
Woman possesses that peculiar trait which Havelock Ellis, in his volume Man and Woman, calls “affectability.” A woman’s sympathies are quicker, more easily roused and more dominant than a man’s; she is sensitive and emotional in a way that differs from his way. And as a woman’s affectability is her great source of strength in her own place in the world, so it will be her greatest danger and greatest source of weakness in political life. Not all women will enter political life; we have already recognized and stated that several times in this argument. But we propose to discuss the question from the standpoint of the many who are longing and intending to do so as speedily as they can. Dr. Reibmayr, the German biologist, claims that this life of feeling is the great source of world-strength as it emanates from woman, but that it can be checked and killed. How, then, will this contribute to the good of the state? If, however, “wifehood and motherhood are incidental relations,” and if “the highest good of the individual” is the only end and aim to be sought, as a suffrage authority tells us, the suffragists may carry their conclusions to the point of inaugurating government by feminine fiat.
We who oppose this thing consider the relationships of wife and mother to be of supreme importance, and the highest good of the individual something to be subordinated to the highest good of the whole.
Sex Antagonism
The two great points on which the world differs are politics and religion. As yet these have not entered the home. Men and women seldom quarrel over religion, because the men are content to leave decisions about religious affairs to their wives. The wives in return have been willing to leave politics to their husbands, and so two fruitful grounds for disagreement have been avoided in domestic life. When women enter politics actively, as many will and must if woman suffrage is to make any impression upon political life, another source of discord will quickly appear. Mrs. Sarah Platt Decker of Colorado, a strong and able suffrage leader, recommended a “Woman’s Party.” Under such a plan, women are not to enter politics as impersonal units, voting the tickets of the existing parties. Instead, chaos is invited in the form of another party distinguished by sex alone: Woman versus Man. Its advocates seem to have overlooked the “human being” contentions. It is no more conceivable that all women, just because they are women, could be induced to think and vote alike than that all men could. And if they could be so induced, they would be unworthy of power. It would show them to be unthinking sheep.
The common suffrage expressions “tyrant man” and “oppressed woman” are calculated to arouse antagonism toward men in the hearts of women. Unable to understand the causes of their individual or their group wrongs, such women would solve the question by making man responsible. Man becomes a vague and terrifying specter, conceived as invariably hostile to woman and as making laws to injure her, to exploit her, to deprive her of her rights. In this view, “man-made laws” are aimed at the subjugation of women, and the existence of old, forgotten statutes of the outworn Common Law of England in some of our more backward states proves that men keep them there with malevolent intent. As a matter of fact, those statutes remain because men have not yet been everywhere aroused to the need for changing them, and reform legislation that changes them or casts them aside is proceeding with great rapidity. They remain through indifference and ignorance, hardly through tyranny and malevolence.
American women are better treated than any women under the sun, class for class, comparing our great country with others of the same rank; it is idle to argue when the countries are not comparable. The women of New Zealand may be better treated than the women of the East Side of New York, but not better than American women as a whole. The slurs, the innuendoes, the savage denunciations that a few American women have seen fit to heap upon the heads of all American men are a cause of regret and shame to the majority, who recognize that the American man, in his desire and effort to protect the women of his country, is ahead of any man in the world.
All questions of social and industrial betterment are being eagerly discussed by men, and special attention is being given to the condition of the American working woman and her child. They are comparatively recent factors in the industrial problem. Because matters cannot be adjusted in all their many bearings in a very brief time, women, characteristically impulsive and impatient, are claiming that the American man does not care and that he will not help. A simple sense of justice and fair play should be enough to restrain such silly and superficial judgments. If men are able, by exercising their lawmaking power, to adjust all industrial difficulties, why did the strikers and employers of Lawrence, Massachusetts, come to Washington to present their grievances to Congress?
The anti-suffragists want to give men time to cope with these huge, new, interdependent problems; to try to understand their difficulties; to state no hasty and unconsidered conclusions; to utter no rash judgments; and to see to it that justice is done in presenting these matters to large groups of women who are unable to investigate for themselves. Let us take two typical questions that will show the difficulties in the way of hasty, good-natured, “blanket” legislation.
1. How can short working hours and steady employment be secured, with justice to the employer, in seasonal trades?
2. How far is it justifiable to forbid a certain amount of child labor in the face of the facts presented by Dr. Karl Pearson of the Galton Laboratory of National Eugenics in London, who gives statistics to prove that the restrictive child labor laws in England have always been followed by a declining birth rate? We are well aware that the poor man everywhere considers his child an asset. Here in America a man will speak of his big family and add with pride that they “all have their working papers.” If the child is not an asset, it is a liability, and a very few such liabilities will be enough for a man earning six dollars a week in a Massachusetts woolen mill. Men who legislate must face the difficulties that arise between these two aspects of the case. Shall we have child labor, with its terrible and far-reaching consequences, or shall we further imperil a birth rate already seriously threatened? Snap judgments on such complicated questions are of little use. The facts have a persistent way of getting underfoot to be noticed. The anti-suffragists stand solidly opposed to child labor in any form, but they wish to be fair to the present lawmakers and their difficulties.
Sex antagonism is an easy flame to fan. The feelings of men and women toward each other are always made hotter by that deep incomprehension which lies at the base of all dealings between the sexes. Sex leaps unexpectedly into all relations between men and women; it intrudes itself into the conversation and the attitude of mind; it proves to be both the basic attraction and the fundamental source of difference. It can no more be disregarded than the operation of any other natural law can be set aside. To ignore it is not to eradicate it. When sex enters, it is easy, as the children of New York’s East Side say, “to throw a hate,” and to create bitterness and anger where harmony should exist. The entrance of woman into politics will by no means break up all homes, but it will assuredly offer one more cause of sex antagonism.
Conditions in the Suffrage States
Many of the conditions existing in suffrage states have been touched upon in a previous chapter. A few points are noted here.
The suffrage states are the experiment stations in which we are justified in looking for proof of the good accomplished by the votes of women. As of 1913, these states are Colorado, Utah, Idaho, Wyoming, Washington, California, Kansas, Oregon, Arizona, the territory of Alaska, and Illinois (limited). In Colorado, women have voted for nineteen years; in Utah, sixteen; in Idaho, sixteen; in Wyoming, forty-two.
Night work for women is not prohibited in Colorado, Idaho, Utah or Wyoming. This fact makes ineffective any eight-hour law like the one passed in Colorado, which applies only to women in “standing occupations.” To be effective, an eight-hour law must be reinforced by two other laws: one regulating night work, and one specifying a legitimate limit on weekly hours. There is no time limit set on women’s work in Idaho, Utah or Wyoming, unless such legislation was enacted too late to be included in the latest legislative index.
General Irving Hale of Denver says, “Women average about the same as men on all questions, a little better on questions involving morals.” But “a little better” and “about the same” are insufficient reasons for the greatly increased expense and the added cumbersomeness of a doubled electorate. Dr. Helen L. Sumner, a suffragist, in her book Equal Suffrage, an investigation of conditions in Colorado in 1909, proves no more. Mrs. Francis W. Goddard, president of the Colonial Dames of Colorado, said in December 1910:
I have voted since 1893. I have been a delegate to the city and State conventions, and a member of the Republican State Committee from my county. I have been a deputy sheriff and a watcher at the polls. For twenty-three years I have been in the midst of the woman suffrage movement in Colorado. For years I believed in woman suffrage and have worked day in and day out for it. I now see my mistake and would abolish it tomorrow if I could.No law has been put on the statute book of Colorado for the benefit of women and children that has been put there by the women. The child labor law went through independently of the women’s vote. The hours of working women have not been shortened; the wages of schoolteachers have not been raised; the type of men that got into office has not improved a bit.Frankly, the experiment is a failure. It has done Colorado no good. It has done woman no good. The best thing for both would be if tomorrow the ballot for women could be abolished.
Mrs. Francis W. Goddard, President of the Colonial Dames of Colorado, December 1910
Judge Lindsey, a strong suffragist, says, “Women are as much bound by political expediency as men.” Dr. Helen Sumner says, “A woman rarely either nominates or seconds the nomination of a man except in some cases where the man has shown himself unusually favorable to women in politics.”
In Utah, Idaho and Wyoming, with Colorado not far behind, the Mormons hold the balance of political power, and women are their most ardent propagandists and supporters, even to the point of defending polygamy. In this case the grave menace is the entangling of a church with affairs of state. This country has always stood for the principle known as the “separation of Church and State.” The great additional force of women voters in these states is with the political majority, who are not only un-American regarding our governmental ideals, but anti-American.
As for the question of child labor, we see that Wyoming and Utah prohibit the working of children in the mines only, although other states that are non-suffrage, equally sparsely settled and without factories and mills, have made child labor laws to cover any condition that may arise in the future. In suffrage states no documentary proof of a child’s age is required.
The large increase of divorce is especially noticeable in suffrage states. It increased in Colorado from 450 to 557 in ten years; in Wyoming, from 70 to 143; in Utah, from 225 to 387; and in Idaho, from 139 to 320. These conditions are not charged against the women of these states, but they exist, and women would undoubtedly rectify them if they were able. If the ballot does not make them able, what does it amount to?
The facts about prostitution in Denver are vouched for by Mrs. Kate Waller Barrett, national president of the Florence Crittenton Homes for Wayward Girls. There is a home of this organization in nearly every large city in the land, and Mrs. Barrett says, “In all the seventy-eight Florence Crittenton Homes in the United States I never saw such a collection of girls of the better class as are in the Denver Home.”
Wages in Colorado have not been raised since women were given the voting power. In fact, the most careful observer cannot find any betterment of conditions to match the overturning of political affairs, the increased electoral expense and the development of a corrupt class of women politicians. The suffrage states must do better than this to show the non-suffrage states a reason why votes should be given to women.
An Analysis of a Suffrage Platform
Let us now consider in detail the platform adopted by the Woman Suffrage Party at the New York City Convention on October 26, 1911. It states:
1. “The claim that American Government is a government of the people, by the people, for the people, is a pretense and a delusion as long as one-half of the people are deprived of all voice in that government.”
Women were not deprived of a voice in the government; they were made exempt from its responsibilities in view of other and equally important services rendered to the state in bearing children and making homes.
2. “Food, clothing and shelter are the fundamental necessities of the people, and they are, and always have been the primary concern of women in the home. We, therefore, denounce a political system which robs the home of adequate representation and makes business and finance the chief concern of politics.”
Business and finance in the hands of the man who helps to make a home are absolutely necessary to its continuance. It might therefore reasonably be supposed that when the man who brings in the money that pays for the food and clothing and shelter votes for the things he thinks will enable him to earn or gain money, he “adequately represents the home.”
3. “We protest against the iniquity of a political system which refuses to grant to the six million working women engaged in industries outside the states of Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Washington and Idaho [California was not then included], a share in the making and enforcing of the laws which control every matter which is vital to their health and well-being.”
Various estimates of women in industrial life are given, ranging from one-seventh to one-fifth. We have noted before that there are no laws regulating night work for women in Colorado, Idaho, Utah and Wyoming. There is no time limit on women’s work in Idaho, Utah and Wyoming. Colorado has an eight-hour day but no law limiting hours by the week, and the eight-hour law covers “standing occupations only,” of which there are very few, while the hours of women engaged in seated occupations are unrestricted. In the mining industry, Colorado closes only the coal mines to women. Seats for women at work are not required in Idaho or in Wyoming, and in Utah they are required in stores only. Separate toilets for men and women are not required in Idaho, Utah, Wyoming, Colorado or California. New York and Massachusetts lead in all legislation favorable to working women: laws made by men to protect women. These suffrage states have had equal franchise long enough for working women to have received all needed care at the hands of their sister women. The occupations are not many, and the conditions are not difficult. Why has this care not been given?
4. “Until the enfranchisement of women we call upon all women to oppose the idea of a uniform divorce law, because at the present time such a law would be made by men only, and would necessarily discriminate against women. We declare that in all public conferences and commissions appointed to consider this subject women should have an equal voice with men.”
The Rev. S. W. Dike of Auburndale, Massachusetts, who has worked faithfully for many years for the League for the Protection of the Family, would be surprised to find that his wise and careful divorce recommendations must “necessarily discriminate against women.” He has worked for years to protect the American home, and all America owes him a debt of gratitude for it. In 1901 a National Divorce Commission, representing all of the states, framed a uniform divorce law to be passed upon by the legislatures of the various states. The causes for divorce in this law are adultery, drunkenness (from alcohol or drugs) if habitual, extreme cruelty, desertion for an unspecified period, non-support, and conviction for felony. All the wrongs suffered by women can be classified under these heads, except such frivolous reasons for breaking up a home as uncongeniality, incompatibility of temper, “mental cruelty,” and the like.
At present one in every twelve marriages brings a divorce. Because divorce conditions in the different states are so lax and so unequal, people who are married in one state are unmarried in another, and the reverse. Suffragists were once urged by one of their own number to ask for “divorce for any cause whatever,” which would make the family, that important unit of the state, a thing to be dashed to pieces at the bidding of a woman’s weariness, whim or unstable affection. This uniform divorce law, so ardently desired by those who have the good of the nation at heart, has been accepted by several states. But it has met opposition for various reasons, one of the most potent being the determined antagonism of women who evidently decided long ago to follow the principle laid down in this platform.
5. “We renew our condemnation of the suicidal policy of permitting child labor, and give our support to all humanitarian legislation looking toward the amelioration of race-destroying tendencies.”
Dr. Bernbaum of Harvard asked Mrs. Florence Kelley, the president of the Consumers’ League and an ardent suffragist, “why the Colorado child labor laws were not even up to those of Nebraska.” She replied, “Colorado laws are better adapted to the needs of the working class in Colorado!” Dr. Bernbaum states that of the ten members of the Executive Committee on Child Labor in Massachusetts, only two are suffragists. The best child labor laws were secured in Indiana by women without the vote, and in many states of the Middle West by the Federated Women’s Clubs. Colorado laws prohibit children under fourteen from working. In New York the age is sixteen. The enforcement of these laws is a different matter from their enactment. Enforcement depends on the number of inspectors supplied, and a law that does not provide for inspectors is everywhere worthless to protect children. New York and Massachusetts are still ahead in legislation.
6. “In face of the revelations of the white slave traffic, and the demonstrated connection between poverty and prostitution, we declare that the time has come for a complete program of social legislation, including a minimum wage, shorter hours, steady employment, better housing and extensive public recreation.”
For an answer to these curiously illogical demands, we must refer to the chapter on the ballot and industry. In that chapter we have spoken of the minimum wage and of equal pay for equal work; the question of seasonal trades was discussed elsewhere.
It is New York, under the leadership of Jacob Riis, that has led the way on the tenement house problem. It is Brooklyn that has an investigating commission which has done away with thousands of dark rooms. It is Washington, D.C., a city with few problems despite its Black population of 100,000, that is struggling with the question of the alleys: the alley tenements and shacks, alleys with only one outlet, where infant mortality is double that on the streets. All these movements are led by men and aided by women. The Housing Committee of the Monday Evening Club, a society of the national capital with no ballot power whatever, promises to clean up the city and free it from disease-breeding houses.
New York has recreation piers. All large cities and many small ones have parks and playgrounds, and most of these playgrounds were secured by disinterested women without the ballot. The whole movement of the public conscience is toward better and more general conditions for recreation, and toward regulating improper forms of recreation, such as unsupervised dance halls and moving picture shows. Women are not the only ones who desire these things. There are still a few men in America who are awake to the needs of the laboring class. Men, too, recognize that the time has come for a “complete program of social legislation,” and they are everywhere working to advance it. Women who ask for these things as nonpartisans will secure a readier hearing and a quicker response than if they appear as voters, open to the suspicion of interested motives.
7. “We view with alarm the reactionary educational movement which would restrict the education of women to domestic science, and ignore their right to a full and free intellectual life.”
With women’s colleges dotting our country from coast to coast, it can scarcely be said that the right of women to a “full and free intellectual life” is being ignored. Nor do the courses in domestic science given in colleges and schools restrict women in any sense whatever. They are intended to supplement intellectual knowledge in a land which has been declared to be “the land of the worst middle class cooking in the world.” The public schools are trying to help. It is a disgrace to American women that our children have to be taught cooking in a public school because so many mothers cannot teach it.
The “paper-bag home,” filled three times a day with bakery trash, is a menace to every factory and mill town. Much of a factory worker’s scanty wages is spent by women who cannot cook, and who waste their few cents on cheap food lacking in nourishment, supplied by the hundreds of low-grade bakers in every industrial community. The delicatessen store is a menace to the middle-class home, where twice the value is spent on ready-cooked food; and the caterer is a great source of domestic extravagance among well-to-do housekeepers. Educational institutions are struggling to keep the science of cookery alive among American women. We do not view this development “with alarm”; we view it with relief. It is an effort to teach young American women the thing their mothers are rapidly forgetting: the necessity and the importance of their own work. All that we view with alarm is the fact that cooking teachers are so scarce.
8. “We congratulate the teachers of New York on their successful struggle for the principle of equal pay for equal work, and urge the extension of the principle to the work of industrial women.”
It is not equal pay for equal work that is being asked, but equal pay for different work. See the earlier chapter on the ballot and industry.
9. “We repeat our plea for the appointment of women as judges and magistrates in the courts in order that the interests of women and children may be better safeguarded.”
Judge Lindsey, the idol of the suffragists, is head of the Juvenile Court of Denver, and there are juvenile courts presided over by men in Boston, Washington and other cities. Judge Lindsey claims 96 percent “cured,” and those who have seen his work are the first to admit his claim. Others claim about 50 percent cured for their own work. It looks as if men were doing fairly well in safeguarding the interests of children. Women are not so noted for their fairness, their judicial minds, and their freedom from prejudice and partisan bias as to make the general application of this demand at all desirable.
10. “We express our deepest appreciation of what our English sisters have done for the woman’s movement the world over, and urge our own women to exhibit equal self-sacrifice and loyalty as occasion may arise.”
With 148 of our English sisters in jail for demolishing property at this writing, it is pertinent to ask, “How much lawlessness does it take to make a good lawmaker?” The spectacular rioting, the window-breaking and stone-throwing, the much-sought immolation in prison, the present threats of resorting to firearms, and the personal assaults on public men, urged with greater violence while the coal strike was impending, are not examples for American women to emulate. If they do adopt such ridiculous tactics, they should be dealt with exactly as men rioters are dealt with. A government that allowed itself to be coerced into granting any political boon because a few women were lawless would make itself the laughingstock of the world, and would not be safe for an hour from the frenzied and impossible demands of its own subjects. The world in general is neither attracted nor impressed by such half-civilized conduct. Nor is it disposed to trust weighty matters of state to frenzied and hysterical women, unthinking, illogical, carried along by an excited mob of lunatics. Such conduct represents a pathological rather than a penological condition. The statement of this plank in the platform will inevitably cause intelligent American women to repudiate it.
11. “We call upon New York to follow the example of Wisconsin, Kansas and the other states where a referendum has been submitted to the people on the question of equal suffrage.”
When this was tried in Massachusetts in 1895, the result showed 4 percent of the voters in favor of suffrage. Dr. Lyman Abbott and Colonel Roosevelt, approaching this question from very different standpoints, advocate the referendum on this matter. The anti-suffrage women cordially welcome the idea, and wish it tried not only in New York but in other states as well. Under these circumstances, only in the most feeble and sparsely settled Western states, or in a state gone mad with socialistic teaching, would the suffragists find a ray of hope.
Conclusion
The anti-suffragists stand very strongly for the position that women do not need the ballot to accomplish their ends. If they are really in earnest, they can secure whatever they are willing to work for in the way of beneficent or remedial legislation. Intelligent and interested women will have by far the larger share in this indirect government; all the objectionable classes will be eliminated, and the women who are moved by high motives will remain. Appearing before legislatures and committees, they will be known as nonpartisan, known only as women with “no political axes to grind, no political trades to make,” women whose animating purposes are above suspicion. As such they will be given careful attention, the attention which they have often received from political bodies of men. The men recognize a disinterested effort toward the good and wise thing. But if women appear before them holding as much power as the men do, the question will arise, or may arise, “What is behind it? How will it affect this or that party?” exactly as it arises among men.
Patriotism for a woman does not begin at the ballot box. It begins when she takes pains to instruct her young son concerning the dignity and sacredness of the ballot. Our fathers used to believe in this, and our country grew great when this doctrine was impressed upon its young men. In recent years, because this has been taken too much for granted, we have seen a strange corruption of the electorate. In every community votes are bought and sold with little thought of shame, little realization of the baseness and treachery involved. Sometimes an effort is made to cover the bald infamy of it, as in a New England rural community, where a conversation has been known to run something like this:
“Did you get two dollars for voting for Mr. So-and-so?”
“No, I didn’t.”
“Then why did you vote for him?”
“Because I like him.”
“And why do you like him?”
“Because he gave me two dollars.”
The lack of appreciation of simple honesty and honor goes back to home training, back to those women who, by training the voters, will eventually hold more power than if they were voting themselves. The best and highest patriotism consists in doing our own work of teaching. Women are the world’s educators; men are the world’s exponents. We have educated amiss if we have raised up a generation of men who can be so little trusted that now we must sweep them aside and take the reins into our own hands.
If we are given the franchise, this country will present the spectacle of women possessed of “rights in excess of power.” A preponderance of women voters would give, as Professor A. V. Dicey of England points out, “sovereignty without force,” a governmental anomaly. He shows the basic relation between force and sovereignty: sovereignty meaning dominant power, and force meaning that physical possession without which sovereignty can never be effective. All law is based upon the supposition that behind its edicts lies the force that can be summoned to make those edicts imperative, no matter what. In the very nature of the case, if women claim sovereignty, they must call upon men for the force: a humiliating state of affairs. This is the absurd position at which we arrive if we follow the relentless logic of the initial proposition, as offered by the suffrage party.
The methods used by many of the suffragists to attain their end are of such a nature that plain common sense, educated or uneducated, refuses to sanction them. The militant methods require no comment. The peaceful methods are also very objectionable, for no sensible person can be won to a cause whose devotees display such ignorance of the laws and existing conditions as are shown in the street campaigns and speeches. The speakers usually remind their hearers with great force of Artemus Ward’s friend, “who knew so many things that were not so.”
When Mrs. Pankhurst, on a New York street corner, held out a list of deserted wives secured from the office of the Associated Charities, and informed her audience that if women had the ballot such things could not be, she proved herself quite ignorant of the very stringent laws existing in New York for the punishment of men who abandon their families. The proper law, the best possible law, has been enacted. Enforcement of any law is a far different matter.
The most recent method which has been used is the “philanthropy boycott,” known as “the pledge of will and won’t”:
“I hereby promise that I will give what I can and do my share of work to gain votes for women.”
“I will not give either money or services to any other cause until the women of New York State have been enfranchised.”
In New York State one suffragist spent $36,890 between October 1909 and March 1910; another spent $37,750 in the same time. The fund in England was found to be half a million dollars, with $20,000 spent for the hire of halls alone. Charity reports in England and America in this past year have shown the loss of contributions and the loss of the names of well-known and hitherto generous women.
This pledge is an English importation. It shows no conscience or feeling for the many afflicted and helpless people now being aided by voluntary subscriptions to charity, who will be made to suffer by the curtailing of funds relied upon for their support, in order that they may be made pitiful factors in the fight. In effect these suffragists say, “We will make the helpless suffer, and see if the sight of their suffering will compel you to let us have our own way.” Such a spirit cannot commend itself, nor make these women worthy of the very thing they seek. It proves that their methods of warfare will be the same later as they are now: childishly lawless where militant, ignorant or cruel where peaceful.
The arguments all lead back along a circular trail. In this forest of questions and statistics and opinions, we return to the point from which we started out. We of the majority insist that universal adult suffrage will be a menace to American government and to American womanhood, and that it is lacking in the fundamental principle of patriotism.
Note on Suffrage Membership Figures
Since the number given earlier in this book (80,000) is the number connected with the National Association, and since there is no way of estimating those not so connected, other organizations are doubtless included in the 3,000,000 figure mentioned as interested in suffrage for women.
G. D. G.
Finis
Keep this book
Free PDF/EPUB
It stays free to read here. Choose how you would like to take it with you.
One free account opens 400+ books and saves your place on every device. Google sign-in or an email link. No card.
Theme
Typeface
Size
Save your place
A free account remembers where you stopped, on your phone or at your desk, and adds the PDF/EPUB to your library.
Create a free accountAlready have one? Log in
Readers like you keep these books free
Every edition takes real work to modernize and record. One gift funds the next classic, with no subscription.
Supporters receive
All 153 audiobooks, now and future
The whole ebook library as one download
Support the work
Copied words
Take the whole book with you
Your passage is on your clipboard. If you want the full text to quote, print or read offline, the PDF/EPUB is free with an account.
Get the free PDF/EPUBGoogle sign-in or an email link. No card.
You are reading Anti-Suffrage: Ten Good Reasons, free
Readers like you keep these books free
Every edition takes real work to modernize and record. One gift funds the next classic. No subscription.
- All 153 audiobooks, now and future
- The whole ebook library as one download
