131 audiobooks, 1,134 hours of narration. Give $50 and every one is yours.
Puritan books
Cover of The Way to Prosperity

Modern English edition · 1690 AD

The Way to Prosperity

by Cotton Mather

Cotton Mather's sermon to Massachusetts, 1690: the election sermon he preached to the governor and General Court on 2 Chronicles 15:2, “the Lord is with you while you are with Him,” in the first year after the colony had overthrown Sir Edmund Andros and resumed its charter government. Printed in Boston in 1690, it came with Mather's preface on the revolution of 1689, a Mantissa of three memorable providences, and an appendix on prodigies lately seen in New England.

Start reading free

One free account opens 250+ books and saves your place on every device. Google sign-in or an email link. No card.

Included with your free account

This book, and 250+ more, free to read

A free account opens the whole library to read online, on your phone or at your desk. Open a book on one device and it is waiting at the same page on the next. The PDF and EPUB of every book are yours to keep, and audiobooks play in the same app.

  • 250+ modernized editions Not samples. The whole work, free.
  • Your place, on every device Phone, tablet or desktop, same page.
  • 131 audiobooks From $4.99 each, or all of them with a $50 gift.
  • PDF and EPUB included Download any book to keep.
Create your free account Google sign-in or an email link. No card.
The in-app reader on a phone, mid-chapter of The Mortification of Sin in modern English
My Library on a phone, with a book to continue reading and the cover grid

Summary

Occasion
Massachusetts election sermon, 1690, on 2 Chronicles 15:2
First published
1690 AD
Type
Election sermon, with preface, Mantissa, and appendix
Length
About 12,000 words · a 1-hour read

“The Way to Prosperity” is Cotton Mather's sermon to Massachusetts, 1690, preached to the governor and General Court at that year's election on 2 Chronicles 15:2, “the Lord is with you while you are with Him.” It calls God's presence the colony's one necessary thing, reads recent calamities as signs of His withdrawal, and asks for repentance and peace.

How the argument unfolds

  1. 01

    The text and its occasion. Mather opens with the prophet Azariah meeting Asa's army on its return from Gerar after the defeat of the Cushites. Azariah saw them absorbed in plans for what to do next, but “he calls them back to acknowledge the presence of God as the cause of their success in their recent action” and to secure it for what lies ahead.

  2. 02

    The doctrine. The whole sermon rests on one sentence drawn from the text: “the God of Heaven will be with a people while they are with Him.” Mather sets it out in three propositions and then applies it to New England.

  3. 03

    A threefold presence. God is naturally present with all creatures, gloriously present in the third heaven, and graciously present with His people, and only the third is a people's concern: “God is with us when God is for us.” That gracious presence means His directing, protecting, and assisting them.

  4. 04

    Providence is not the covenant. God's presence in outward providence and His presence in the covenant of grace differ in foundation and in continuance. “We must not judge the stability of the new covenant by whatever variety and sovereignty we may see in providential dealings toward this or that people in the world.”

  5. 05

    Grace, not earning. A people must be with God or He will not be with them, yet Mather guards the condition twice. Grace helps a people even to meet it, and their being with God does not earn His presence: “It is simply the antecedent to which this is the consequent.”

  6. 06

    With, for, and like. The Hebrew particle in the text means with, for, and like. So a people are with God by communion in prayer and worship, for God by activity on His side, and like God in holiness, justice, and mercy.

  7. 07

    The one necessary thing. Turning to the assembly, Mather calls God's presence the sum of every blessing New England could want. “The presence of God is nothing less than the very soul of New England. We are dead and gone if that withdraws.”

  8. 08

    Signs that God is not among us. Blight on corn and trade, Boston twice burned, war after war with the Indians, and the loss of the charter government are read as one lesson. “Why have we had fire after fire, laying our treasures in ashes?” The answer each time: “It is because our God is not among us.”

  9. 09

    Three requests. Return to the Lord by self-examination and the Synod's advice; let sin not be with us, above all contention, for “A divided and quarrelsome people is, in effect, telling the Almighty to depart from us, for he is the God of peace”; and let every man do his part, rulers by supporting ministry, college, and schools, and the rest by public spirit and prayer.

  10. 10

    Providences and prodigies. The Mantissa gives three examples of what befell those who refused the gospel, since “the presence of God will either go or stay with His Gospel,” and the appendix adds the earthquake, the Boston cabbage root, the red snow, and the sights and sounds of October 1, 1689, with the warning that “The heavens have never blazed with empty fires.”

Key themes

  • God's presence as a people's prosperity. Prosperity in the title is not wealth but the presence of God in a people's affairs. “If Christ, if God, is aboard, our little vessel will not sink amid the gaping, roaring, formidable waves now tossing it.”
  • Providence and covenant. Mather insists that God's changeable dealings with nations say nothing against the unchangeable covenant with His saints. David's house and David's salvation rested on different promises: “These two kinds of promise stood on different footing.”
  • Contention as the chief danger. Of all the colony's sins, quarreling in the wake of the revolution worries him most. “Truly, if we are a fighting, quarreling people, we shall not be a pious one.” His remedy is patience with those who see differently and agreement on what every man counts next best.
  • The rising generation. The request to the rulers centers on ministry, the college, and schools. “I do not know whether we suffer from any worse symptom today than the widespread lack of education among the rising generation.”
  • The works of God as warnings. Alongside Scripture, Mather reads recent events, the fate of the Narragansetts and of Philip, an earthquake, a red snow, and a flame in a clear sky, as calls to repentance, while granting that “it is a simple thing to believe every word.”

The Preface

Religion stands on tiptoe in our land, Ready to pass to the American strand. When height of malice and prodigious lusts, Impudent sinning, witchcrafts and distrusts, (The marks of future bane) shall fill our cup Unto the brim, and make our measure up; … Then shall Religion to America flee; They have their times of gospel, even as we. … Yet as the Church shall thither westward fly, So sin shall trace and dog her instantly.

The occasion that first produced the following sermon cannot be better expressed than in the words used by the worthy gentlemen who served as conservators of our peace, in their humble address to Their Majesties, dated May 20, 1689. Among other things, they said:

Your three several princely declarations, encouraging the English nation to cast off the yoke of a tyrannical and arbitrary power under which they were then held, came to the view and consideration of the people of this country, who found themselves under like (if not worse) evil and unhappy circumstances as their brethren in England. First, they had been unrighteously deprived of their charter government and privileges, without any hearing or trial, and under utter impossibility of receiving notice of any writ served upon them. This was followed by the exercise of an illegal and arbitrary power over them, which had almost ruined a once-flourishing country and had become very grievous and intolerable, besides the growing miseries and daily fears of total subversion by enemies at home and invasion by foreign force.

The people, excited to imitate so noble and heroic an example, and strongly and unanimously moved to see to their own safety and defense, resolved to seize and secure some of the principal persons responsible for, and most active in, the ill management of the illegal and arbitrary government set over them by commission. Accordingly, on the eighteenth day of April last past, they rose as one man, seized Sir E. Andros the late governor and other of the evil instruments, and have secured them for whatever justice and order Your Majesties shall direct.

Thus that address.

Following the revolution just described, various debates arose about the further steps needed for the service of Their Majesties and this afflicted country. These debates soon issued in the return of our government into the hands of our ancient magistrates, who, together with the representatives or deputies of the several towns in the colony, made another address to Their Majesties, dated June 6, 1689. In that address were these words:

Finding an absolute necessity of civil government, the people generally made known their desire and urgent wish, again and again, that the governor, deputy governor, and assistants chosen and sworn in May 1686, according to the charter and the court as then formed, would assume the government. The said governor, deputy governor, and assistants, then resident in the colony, consented to accept the present care and government of this people according to the rules of the charter, for the preservation of peace and common safety, and to take further acts of authority as emergencies required, until, by direction from England, there should be an orderly settlement. We hope this will restore us to the full exercise of our government as before, notwithstanding that we have for some time been most unrighteously and injuriously deprived of it.

That royal charter was the sole inducement and encouragement for our fathers and predecessors to come into this wilderness and settle it at their own cost and charge.

In answer to this address, His Majesty, in a most gracious letter dated the 12th of August 1689, used these words to the government here:

Whereas you give us to understand that you have taken upon yourselves the present care of the government until you should receive our order in the matter, we do hereby authorize and empower you to continue, in our name, your care in its administration and the preservation of the peace, until we shall have taken such resolutions and given such directions for the more orderly settlement of the said government as shall most conduce to our service, and the security and satisfaction of our subjects within that our colony.

It was in the time of our greatest troubles and difficulties, at a time appointed for a General Assembly of this great colony, that the sermon that follows was expected from me. By the grace of God, it was not altogether unacceptable at the time to some who desired its publication. But I did not fully consent to their wish until now, when they had the opportunity (with their renewed urging) to join it to another discourse they have also obtained from me. Though the small differences among us at the time the sermon was preached are now so well settled, I still allow myself to hope that what is here set out will not, and should not, be judged unseasonable.

I confess it is a very bold thing for one so unremarkable as myself to address the whole country as I do here. But if it is a fault, it is a fault born of love, and if the general temper of the year will not excuse a breach of order on my part, I have only one more thing to offer in my defense.

There was once a people in the world among whom it was the custom that, when men wished to win the favor of their ruler, they were to present his own son before him, as a sight that would speak more than any advocate could.

In that spirit, so that I may not lack the favor of my country, however blameworthy they may judge my freedom with them, I will present them only with my own father. His cheerful undertaking of a hazardous voyage to a strange land, and of the innumerable difficulties and temptations found there, for no other cause than that he might speak for them, has surely earned a pardon for me, with whom he has now left both his church and family for nearly two years, if I have transgressed by taking the liberty of speaking to them, at the same time, of the things that may promote our enjoyment of the Divine Presence among us. Now may salvation be near to us, and glory dwell in our land!

Cotton Mather.

The Way to Prosperity

It is the word of the eternal God in 2 Chronicles 15:2:

Hear ye me, Asa, and all Judah, and Benjamin: the Lord is with you while you are with Him.

It is a remarkable occasion that has brought these words to be the subject of our present meditations. But it was a still more remarkable occasion on which these words were first uttered. We find them in the sacred book of Chronicles, which are not the civil records referred to elsewhere in the Bible, but an inspired history of things that concerned the line of Christ and the church of God for three thousand five hundred years. It seems, as Jerome put it, an epitome of the whole, and it was written as late as the last of all the books of the Old Testament, and the Hebrew Bibles give it a place accordingly.

The Greeks chose to entitle it The Book of Things (Elsewhere) Passed By, because, as Lyra notes, following the rule of our Savior, “it gathers fragments that nothing may be lost.” Even if there were nothing else to justify that name but the story that gives us our text, it would be enough. It is a story passed by in the book of Kings, but worthy to be held in everlasting remembrance.

The ready pen of Ezra (for we conjecture him to be the scribe of the Holy Spirit here, notwithstanding a few clauses that may be judged added by another hand after his death, the pen of Ezra, I say) tells us here that the people of God had newly been invaded by a vast army of Cushites. But we are still at a loss as to who these Cushites were. Far more scholars in the world than there were soldiers in that army have so far been content with our translation, which renders them Ethiopians here. But that learned Frenchman Bochart, whose happy industry has delved into the treasures in the depths of Scripture more than any man’s, has proven with irrefutable demonstration that the Cushites mentioned in the oracles of God were not Ethiopians but Arabians. These Arabians, though they have not been called Saracens (as some have thought) from their word Sarak, meaning To Steal, well deserved such an origin for their thieving inclinations. They were a wild sort of men who lived largely on the plunder and ruin of their neighbors, and a million of them now had designs on Jerusalem as their prey.

The blessed God gave His people a notable victory over these invaders, and they were now returning from Gerar (a place between thirty and forty miles off) to Jerusalem. The Holy Spirit of God stirred up and inclined a prophet named Azariah to address them with a faithful and solid sermon on the occasion, and in my text you have the sum and substance of it.

We may observe, first, its preface, which is very solemn and earnest: “Hear ye me, Asa, and all Judah, and Benjamin.” He was probably not among the greatest of men, and likely not among the oldest either, for it appears from verse eight that his father was still alive and present at this time. Yet, speaking in the name of the great and eternal God, he expects and demands the attention of the whole army.

Second, its design, which is to declare both the source and the use of their recent prosperity. “The Lord is with you, while you are with Him,” or as the Vulgate has it, “inasmuch as you have been with him.” What follows is only an explanation and expansion of this. He saw they were absorbed in various business and plans; they had their enemies subdued, and their minds were full of thoughts and concerns about what to do next. But he calls them back to acknowledge the presence of God as the cause of their success in their recent action, and above all, to obtain and secure the presence of God so that they might succeed equally well in their future undertakings.

I am therefore to call for your attention to this faithful saying.

Doctrine. That the God of Heaven will be with a people while they are with Him.

The explanation of this truth will be pursued through the following propositions.

It is the interest, and should be the desire, of every people to have the God of Heaven with them. But we must ask: what is implied in that presence of God we should be concerned about?

In answer to this, there is a threefold presence of God mentioned in the Scripture of truth.

First, God is naturally present with all creatures. He is an immense being, and no creature can exist without Him. The apostle argued this way in the court at Athens, in Acts 17:27: “God is not far from every one of us.” No, He is near us all, He is with us all. And Paul could have had the Gentiles themselves confessing it, for besides what their own Seneca acknowledged, one of their own poets had said, “All things are full of Jove.” It is the speech of our God, in Jeremiah 23:24: “Do not I fill Heaven and Earth, saith the Lord?” Yes, He does.

The Jews call God by the name Makom, meaning “Place,” because all things exist in Him. This, if I am not mistaken, is His name in the book of Esther. Whether it is proper and fitting to speak of an imaginary, infinite space beyond the utmost edge of the world, filled with our God alone, we cannot say for certain. But we are sure that the heaven of heavens sets no limits on His being, and the ancients were not mistaken when they said, “God Himself is His own world, place, and all things.” We cannot so well say that God is in the world as we may say that the whole world is in God, and we may say with the psalmist in Psalm 139:7, “Whither shall I flee from thy presence?”

Second, God is gloriously present with the inhabitants of the third heaven. The heaven of heavens contains the most intimate and marvelous manifestations of God. It is the place of which we may say, as is said of that state in Revelation 21:23, “The glory of God doth lighten it.” There the blessed ones have God with them, so that they always behold His face, and are satisfied with His likeness forever. When we come to heaven, then, as in 1 Thessalonians 4:17, “We shall ever be with the Lord.” So the Lord will be with us forever. Heaven is the throne of the Most High; He is there as a prince on his throne, the great King residing there in a manner very much beyond words. To be there is called, in 2 Corinthians 5:8, “a being present with the Lord.” So it is toward heaven, and not toward a Bible, that we are directed to make our bodily gestures when we pray or take an oath before the Lord.

But third, God is graciously present with His people by being favorable to them. This gracious presence of God is what a people ought to be concerned about. It consists in the engagement of divine providence for the welfare of such a people. God is with us when God is for us.

To particularize: first, God is with a people by directing them. When Israel was to pass through the wilderness, they had that encouragement in Exodus 33:14, the presence of God going with them. What was that? They had a cloudy, fiery pillar miraculously leading them every step of the way. There was a wonderful pillar that was a cloud by day and a fire by night, its lower part resting on the tabernacle while its upper part was visible to the whole congregation, its motions managed by the ministry of angels. Now God was with them, and He led them forth by the right way.

A people are often brought into a wilderness of difficulties and emergencies, but if God is with them, He guides them to a good outcome in all of it. The presence of God appears in His directing and inclining a people toward actions that serve His honor and their safety, and toward methods that may free them from all distress. When God is with a people, He shapes their counsels for them, and disposes them toward the things that should be done. He supplies them with insight beyond the reach and range of their own wisdom, and He lays before them invitations and provocations that, as it were, push them into the way they should go.

When the Jews were about to reclaim the desirable things the Babylonians had deprived them of, they took the right way to disappoint all who wished to interrupt them in it. We find in Nehemiah 4:13 that while those efforts continued, they kept watch in a manner suited to the danger, and when the danger had passed, they returned each to his own work. How did this come to pass? It was because God was with them.

Second, God is with a people by protecting them. It was God’s promise to His people in Isaiah 43:2: “When thou passest through the waters, I will be with thee, and through the rivers, they shall not overflow thee.” On this text, blessed Bilney, after his condemnation, wrote so sweet a paraphrase that his friends had the whole sentence fairly copied onto their tables. A people may seem ready to be swallowed by a stormy, gaping ocean of troubles, but if God is with them, they will escape it all unharmed.

The presence of God is a defense, a refuge, to the people who share in it. It was said to David in 2 Samuel 7:9: “I was with thee, and have cut off all thine enemies out of thy sight.” When God is with a people, He distracts and confounds their enemies, and He troubles those who trouble them. A people who have God with them are too strong for all the malice and power of their enemies. No adversary, no desolation, will make such a people miserable. They are the Jacob to whom it was said in Genesis 28:15: “Behold, I am with thee, and I will keep thee, saith the Lord.”

Third, God is with a people by assisting and succeeding them. When Joshua had a vast undertaking before him, it was said to him in Joshua 1:9: “Be of good courage, for the Lord thy God is with thee, whithersoever thou goest.” In other words, God will assist you, and give you success, in your undertakings. The presence of God will carry a people comfortably through all they take in hand. Whether they have Canaanites to subdue, or possessions to gain or keep, the presence of God will make them prosper in it all. It was said to Solomon in 1 Chronicles 22:11: “My son, the Lord be with thee, and prosper thou, and build the house of the Lord thy God.” So if the Lord is with a people, they will prosper in all their affairs. In every undertaking they will come off satisfied, and they will not fail in anything they attempt. This is the presence of the Lord.

The presence of God with a people in His outward providence has a different foundation, and a different continuance, from His presence with His people in the covenant of grace. As the great Owen well observed in a discourse to Parliament, “these two must be carefully distinguished.” We must not judge the stability of the new covenant by whatever variety and sovereignty we may see in providential dealings toward this or that people in the world. David settles this matter in 2 Samuel 23:5: “Though my house be not so with God, yet He has made with me an everlasting covenant, ordered in all things and sure.” David had promises for the prosperity of his house; he also had the sure mercies of the covenant made over to him in God’s promises. These two kinds of promise stood on different footing. The sure mercies of the covenant were, for him, absolute and unchangeable, but the prosperity of his house we find governed by another law, and subject to dreadful change.

To bring this to the matter before us: in the covenant of grace, God has promised that He will be with His people. We read this in Hebrews 13:5: “He hath said, I will never leave thee, nor forsake thee.” The all-sufficient God, who answers our necessities whatever they may be, the unchangeable God, who is still what He was to the saints of old, this God has said it. And how much better is this He Himself has spoken it than the best the master said so in all the world!

He has said it, and said it with negatives multiplied. In the original they are heaped one upon another: “I will not, I will not leave thee; I will not, I will not, I will not forsake thee.” Well, but God is not with a people in His outward providence in quite that same manner.

This twofold presence of God differs in two ways.

First, it has a different foundation. When we look at the covenant of grace, there the sins of one are atoned for by the sufferings of another, and so God comes to be with His people, for whom the atonement has thus been procured. So it is said in 2 Corinthians 5:21: “Christ was made sin [or a sin-offering] for us, that we might become the righteousness of God in Him.” Now turn to outward providence, and there you see different terms at work. Here God is with a people according to those terms in Ezekiel 18:20: “The soul that sinneth, it shall die; one shall not bear the iniquity of another.”

Again, it has a different continuance. In the covenant of grace, God has bound Himself to be with His people forever, indeed to ensure that they will therefore be with Him forever. He says in Jeremiah 32:40: “I will not turn away from them to do them good, but I will put My fear in their hearts, that they shall not depart from Me.” Now turn to outward providence, and there you see it is otherwise. God is with a people for a time, and upon their misbehavior and provocations He changes the course of His dealings with them. It is with them as it was with that family in 1 Samuel 2:30: “I said indeed that thy house should walk before Me for ever; but now the Lord says, that be far from Me.”

The sense of all this will prepare your thoughts for one more conclusion.

Questions

What is The Way to Prosperity about?
It is Cotton Mather's election sermon to the Massachusetts government in 1690, on the words of 2 Chronicles 15:2, “the Lord is with you while you are with Him.” Mather argues that a people prosper only while God is present with them, distinguishes that providential presence from the covenant of grace, explains what it means for a people to be with God, and then asks New England to read its recent calamities as signs of God's absence and to return to Him.
What else is in the book besides the sermon?
Three shorter pieces by Mather, all printed with the sermon in 1690. The Preface quotes the colony's addresses to Their Majesties and the King's reply to explain the revolution of 1689 and the occasion of the sermon. The Mantissa gives three memorable providences about those who refused the gospel. The Appendix Touching Prodigies in New England records the earthquake, the Boston cabbage root, the red snow, and the sights and sounds of October 1, 1689.
When and why was the sermon preached?
At the Massachusetts election of 1690, before the governor and General Court. The colony had overthrown Sir Edmund Andros in April 1689 and was governed provisionally by its old charter magistrates while awaiting a settlement from England, and the expedition against Quebec of that year was in view. Mather says the sermon was expected of him in the time of the colony's greatest troubles and was printed only later, joined to another discourse.
How is the sermon structured?
After introducing the text and its doctrine, Mather gives three propositions: that every people should desire God's presence, which is threefold; that His presence in providence differs from His presence in the covenant of grace; and that a people must be with God by communion, activity, and likeness. The Use then offers three considerations, how necessary the presence is, what signs show it withdrawn, and how aggravated an apostasy would be, followed by three requests.
What is the sermon's central idea?
That God is with a people while they are with Him, and that this is a matter of grace rather than earning. Mather is careful to say that the condition does not cause the blessing but precedes it, and that grace helps a people even to meet it. From the Hebrew particle in the text he draws the three duties: to be with God in prayer and worship, for God in zeal for His glory, and like God in holiness, righteousness, and mercy.
How does it relate to Mather's other works on this site?
It is the earliest of the three. The Mantissa draws on what Mather calls a reserved collection of Memorable Providences, and the appendix on prodigies shows the same attention to wonders and judgments in New England that marks The Wonders of the Invisible World. The call here for every person to do his part, for rulers, ministers, and private people alike, anticipates the practical program of Essays to Do Good.
Who is this book for?
Readers interested in the Puritan election-sermon tradition, in the Massachusetts revolution of 1689 and the years just before the new charter, or in Cotton Mather's early preaching. It is also a short, complete example of how a New England minister read civic events through Scripture, with the preface and appendix giving the documents and reports he thought his hearers needed.
Portrait of Cotton Mather

About the author

Cotton Mather

Cotton Mather (1663–1728) was a New England Puritan minister, prolific author, and one of the most influential figures in early American intellectual life. The son of Increase Mather and grandson of both Richard Mather and John Cotton, he was educated at Harvard and served as minister of Boston’s North Church for over forty years. Mather published more than 450 works on theology, science, history, and practical piety, including his monumental Magnalia Christi Americana. His Essays to Do Good, published in 1710, became one of the most widely read books in colonial America and was credited by Benjamin Franklin as a decisive influence on his own commitment to public service.

“Updated Works has been an incredible blessing to my Christian life and ministry… remarkably faithful to the original authors while making these timeless treasures understandable for modern readers.”
— Pastor Mike Cleveland